- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes A²RD, a training-free agentic framework that formulates long-video synthesis as a closed-loop, segment-level autoregressive process to improve cross-segment and transition smoothness. It also introduces LVBench-C, a benchmark with non-linear entity and environment transitions and evolving states. Result-wise, it achieves state-of-the-art temporal consistency and narrative coherence.
Critical strengths
S1. The adaptive extrapolation/interpolation mechanism is novel. It automatically selects begin-only or begin-and-end boundary frames per segment, improving consistency while preserving narrative progression.
S2. LVBench-C is a challenging benchmark for long-form T2V story generation, requiring entities to disappear for at least 10 segments and reappear with evolved states.
S3. The evaluation is comprehensive and thorough. Beyond automatic metrics and case analysis, this work also provides human studies with all-round evaluations, which further demonstrate the research gap for state consistency and superior performance of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Several gains are marginal. e.g., In Table 1, the proposed framework is comparable to the best baseline on inter-shot motion (0.9935 vs. 0.9903), intra-shot subject (0.9231 vs. 0.9215), and intra-shot environment (0.9514 vs. 0.9492). In Table 2, the same holds for semantic alignment (0.2215 vs. 0.2116 at 3 min) and inter-shot motion (0.9941 vs. 0.9856 at 3 min).
Questions for authors
Q1. What are the end-to-end latency and cost per complete video? Sec. E.9 gives only per-segment estimates under ideal hardware, and the reported cost (under $0.50 per segment, Sec. C.1) excludes image and video generation.
Q2. How reliable are the MLLM-as-a-judge rubrics for Boundary Frame and Video Segment Self-Improvement (Eqs. 7 and 9)? No human agreement is reported for them.
Q3. In Fig. 2, why does the full model underperform the always-interpolate variant on inter-shot character and environment consistency (0.7353 vs. 0.7400; 0.8368 vs. 0.8499)?
3 comments
Official replies by authors (cont.)
Q3. In Fig. 2, why does the full model underperform the always-interpolate variant on inter-shot character and environment consistency (0.7353 vs. 0.7400; 0.8368 vs. 0.8499)?
Thank you for your insightful question. This reflects the fundamental trade-off between visual consistency and narrative progression in long-video generation. We explained this in Section 5.4 (L474–478).
Specifically, in the always-interpolating setting, we always synthesize the end frame for every segment. This can lead to high consistency since sometimes we see that the newly generated end frame is not very different from the segment’s beginning frame. This happens because the TI2I model struggles to anticipate how the scene should evolve over time, while being heavily conditioned on retrieved past frames and states to maintain visual faithfulness. Coupled with HITS (Video) enforcing intra-shot consistency, the generated segment can be over-constrained with little visual progression, resulting in higher consistency scores but low narrative coherence. Our adaptive mechanism balances this trade-off, achieving comparable consistency while preserving much stronger progression.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for your valuable and constructive feedback again, which has helped us improve our manuscript. We hope our clarifications address your concerns. We thank you again for your encouragement.
Thank you for your detailed response! Most of my concerns have been resolved, and I will maintain my positive rating : )
Official replies by authors
Thank you for your insightful reviews and encouraging comments. We greatly appreciate your careful reading and the time and effort you have put into providing constructive feedback. We would like to address your concerns below with additional results and highlight our updated details in orange in our PDF manuscript.
Thank you for the careful observation. We would like to respectfully clarify that the automatic intra-shot consistency and inter-shot motion metrics show signs of saturation with state-of-the-art video generation models (e.g., Veo 3.1). Therefore, in our experiments, they are crucial for verifying that high local segment quality is maintained or improved, but we do not intend to use them to demonstrate substantial improvements over the baselines. Instead, our experiments aim to show A²RD’s primary benefits in tackling long-horizon inter-shot consistency and narrative coherence, where we achieve significant gains. In addition, for inter-shot motion, we emphasize more on our human evaluations in Tables 3 and 10, where human evaluators can better distinguish the naturalness and transition smoothness across segments.
Thank you for your question. On VBench-Long (8 segments; 1 minute generation), on average, A²RD with our default configuration requires 79 minutes and 50 USD, compared with 26 minutes and 13 USD for VideoMemory and 17.5 minutes and 12 USD for Naive-AR as of Nov, 2026.
Additionally, we can estimate such statistics following our analytical framework in Appendix E.9 (Cost and Latency Analysis) if we always use two refinement iterations. Assume that:
We obtain the upper-bound end-to-end runtime and generation cost for 1 segment:
In practice, we see that the actual latency is quite similar to the upper bound estimate because batch inference incurs slightly more overhead than a single call, whereas A²RD sometimes stops early without using all refinement rounds. These results justify the practicality of our proposed framework, especially compared to the human effort and time needed to manually achieve high-quality long videos.
Finally, we also see opportunities to further improve the e2e efficiency: (i) we can reduce the number of refinement iterations, as Figure 3 and Table 13 show that even one iteration already brings substantial gains, and (ii) we can serve many independent generation requests in parallel to improve throughput.
Following your question, we have added a short summary of empirical end-to-end latency and cost in Appendix E.9.2, L1692-L1696.
Thank you for your question. Our MLLM-as-a-judge rubrics in Eqs. 7 and 9 were carefully designed and calibrated during development. Following your suggestion, we have conducted a human verification study by randomly sampling 50 frame evaluations and 50 video evaluations from our generation logs, and asking three highly qualified independent human evaluators to check whether they agree with the final better and worse decisions from the MLLM-as-a-judge rubrics.
We observe an average agreement rate of 83.3% for Boundary Frame judging and 77.3% for Video Segment judging, with good inter-annotator agreement, confirming the reliability of our rubrics.
Following your question, we have added these results in Appendix E.8.2.