- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors investigate medical image classification, particularly ultrasound images, where fine anatomical boundaries and texture can be informative but speckle and acquisition artifacts can also influence prediction.
In their method and architecture desig, they have used the semantic features and frequency features together to address this problem. A ConvNeXt encoder extracts image features and produces an auxiliary class prediction. The authors add a wavelet branch that extracts high-frequency image details and uses a learned gate to combine those details with semantic features.
They introduce two architectural components, Adaptive Frequency Guide (AFG) and Frequency Alignment Module (FAM).
The authors evaluate their architecture on six medical imaging datasets and report improvements over discriminative classifiers and DiffMIC baselines. Their central argument is that explicitly representing frequency information, selecting it adaptively, and using it during label denoising improves classification accuracy.
Critical strengths
The motivation and architecture they have designed is aligned with ultrasound imaging: The authors recognize that high-frequency information can contain both useful anatomical detail and nuisance variation such as speckle. Their approach avoids assuming that all high-frequency information should be preserved or suppressed.
Experiments: The beat the other baseless and capacity-matched comparison against a second branch receiving the original image is a well-designed comparison. This helps address the concern that performance improves simply because the model has more parameters. The authors test ultrasound, CT, dermoscopy, and MRI datasets. It demonstrates applicability beyond one ultrasound benchmark.
Critical weaknesses
Figure 1 is a little bit confusing. Your method also use semantic features while I can interpret that from the box b that you use only frequency features. (The captions is correct and mention it but the schematics a little bit misleading.)
The necessity of label diffusion is not clear: The authors demonstrate that frequency features improve their diffusion classifier. However, this does not establish that diffusion is necessary to exploit those features.
Consider two models:
\text{Model A:}\quad& (F_s,F_h)\rightarrow\mathrm{AFG} \rightarrow\mathrm{MLP}\rightarrow\hat y,\\ \text{Model B:}\quad& (F_s,F_h)\rightarrow\mathrm{AFG} \rightarrow\mathrm{FAM}\rightarrow \text{Label diffusion}. \end{aligned}$$ If Model A obtains comparable results, the contribution may be a frequency-enhanced classifier rather than a meaningful advancement in diffusion modeling. Limited methodological novelty: Prior work has already combined wavelet representations and adaptive attention for medical classification and ultrasound segmentation, including FEANet and Wavelet Attention Fusion. Combining different parts together to get the best results is a valid contribution but every parts need an ablation why this specific features and architecture needed. A convincing experiment should compare WDFNet with and without FAM, semantic-only guidance with FAM, and frequency-only guidance with FAM.Questions for authors
Is label diffusion necessary for the proposed improvements? Could the authors compare WDFNet against a conventional discriminative classifier using the same semantic encoder, wavelet features, and AFG module? This would help determine whether the improvements come from frequency-aware representation learning or specifically from label diffusion.
What is the independent contribution of FAM? Since FAM is retained in all configurations in Table 3, could the authors provide an ablation removing FAM while keeping the other components unchanged? How much does FAM actually improve classification performance?
What is the computational benefit of using label diffusion for this classification task? Given that WDFNet uses 100 reverse sampling steps, could the authors report inference latency, FLOPs, and performance under fewer sampling steps? How does its accuracy–efficiency tradeoff compare with frequency-enhanced discriminative classifiers?
3 comments
Thanks for your proper response and the additional experiments for answering my concerns. FAM's importance addressed well. I still have concern regarding the label diffusion as they are performing same over 10 to 100 steps so essentially the Diffusion model learned an easy distribution and when map can not reach the same performance is interesting. Maybe it is too late to ask to check the training process and make sure fairness there. Also I can not see the edits in the uploaded paper yet. I need to read the paper one final time for my final decision. please update the final versions with all of the necessary edits.
Thank you for your thoughtful follow-up and for recognizing the contribution of FAM.
Following your suggestion, we audited the AFG+MLP implementation, training logs, checkpoints, and gradient propagation. We verified that its ConvNeXt–Haar–AFG branch produces identical features to WDFNet when using the same weights and inputs, and that all active trainable parameter tensors received optimizer updates. AFG+MLP completed 600 training epochs, with its cross-entropy loss decreasing from 1.2983 to 0.00217 and approaching zero toward the end of training. These observations indicate that the baseline was adequately fitted to its training objective.
Both models share the data partitions, preprocessing, augmentation, pretrained encoder initialization, and training budget. Their auxiliary optimization protocols differ, reflecting their respective training objectives.
We also independently repeated DDIM inference at all four sampling budgets. Although the predicted classes remain identical, the continuous label vectors differ across all test images between 10 and 100 steps, with a maximum absolute difference of 0.05218. Thus, the observed consistency reflects stable classification decisions rather than identical denoising outputs. Moreover, a short reverse trajectory does not imply equivalence between conditional label-noise estimation and direct cross-entropy training.
Following CARD and DiffMIC, our contribution focuses on frequency conditioning within label diffusion. The AFG+MLP comparison supports the empirical benefit of the complete prediction pathway, rather than isolating the effect of diffusion alone.
We have revised the manuscript to incorporate the additional experiments. Thank you again for your constructive suggestions and careful evaluation.
Thank you for recognizing the ultrasound motivation, capacity-matched spatial control, and evaluation across imaging modalities. We clarify the semantic/frequency streams and report prediction-pathway, FAM and single-stream controls together with inference costs. WDFNet gains 7.71 Accuracy points over AFG+MLP under speckle, and 10-step DDIM takes 1.09 ms/image with matching predictions across sampling budgets.
1. Semantic and frequency streams
Thank you for pointing out the schematic ambiguity. Both streams enter the condition through
Ffuse=Fs+G(Fs,Fh)⊙Fh.
The semantic feature Fs supplies the residual and helps compute the gate that selects frequency details.
We will revise Figure 1 to show the semantic residual and gated frequency branch explicitly.
2. Added value of label diffusion
Following your suggestion, we train the same ConvNeXt–Haar–AFG image architecture with an MLP and end-to-end cross entropy.
These comparisons use the paper's training settings. WDFNet's Accuracy/F1 gains are 2.86/2.97 points on clean images and 7.71/7.31 points under speckle. The larger speckle margin highlights the added prediction pathway's value when image conditions are perturbed.
3. Independent FAM ablation
Thank you for suggesting this control. We replace FAM with fixed addition, ht=Vg+zt, retaining AFG and the noisy-label/timestep/prior inputs.
Values are mean ± SD over five training seeds, using the paper's training settings and original BUSI split. FAM raises mean Accuracy/F1 by 2.26/1.61 points.
4. Inference cost and sampling steps
Thank you for asking about practical cost. Measurements cover the full model on RTX 5090/FP32, batch size 16. Latency is the median of ten runs after three warmups, excluding I/O, preprocessing, and transfer.
GFLOPs are profiler-counted lower bounds. Caching reuses the image condition across steps, with zero output difference in the parity check. This reduces counted GFLOPs by 77.4% and measured latency by 45.7% for the original sampler.
With DDIM indices spanning the full diffusion schedule, 10, 20, 50 and 100 steps give identical class predictions:
Thus, 10 steps retain the measured classification performance at lower inference cost.
5. Frequency conditioning and branch ablations
Our focus is adaptive frequency conditioning during label denoising. In Table 3 of the paper, replacing the raw-image branch with wavelet details improves Accuracy/F1 by 2.1/2.4 points, with the same branch and gating architectures and FAM retained.
Following your suggestion, we also compare single-stream image conditions:
These new experiments use the paper's training settings. All retain FAM and the auxiliary prior; stream labels refer to the image condition. Combining streams improves Accuracy by 1.28 points over semantic-only and 1.01 over frequency-only, supporting complementary image cues.
We will add the prediction-pathway and image-stream controls and a compact accuracy–cost comparison to the main text, with detailed sampling-budget measurements in the appendix.