- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the challenge in Multi-Focus Image Fusion (MFIF) where blurred regions may exist in both input images. To tackle this, the authors propose Focus Aware Content Routing, which uses a focus map to distinguish between regions that should be preserved from the input images and those that require restoration. The final image is then generated by combining a pre-trained restoration model with contextual refinement. The authors introduce a new benchmark and a region-specific evaluation method, reporting performance that surpasses existing approaches.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses the limitations of the complementary focus coverage assumption, a premise common to many traditional MFIF methods, by specifically evaluating restoration performance in scenarios where blurred regions appear in both input images.
-
The overall reconstruction performance is high, and the paper includes ablation studies on key components, as well as visualizations of the routing masks.
Critical weaknesses
-
There is a lack of quantitative comparison with GMFF, the most relevant existing method. GMFF also deals with incomplete focal plane coverage and generative restoration, a fact acknowledged in the Related Work section of this paper. However, the authors do not compare their method against GMFF in their experiments, nor do they explain why it was excluded. Consequently, it is difficult to determine whether the proposed method truly outperforms the most similar existing approach.
-
The Focus Aware Router applies a fixed weight allocation based on predicted focus maps, and the restoration and refinement processes are also built upon existing models. In particular, for CommonBlurGeometry, even when source preservation is excluded, the PSNR reaches 32.12 dB, a figure not significantly different from the 32.64 dB achieved by the full model. Consequently, it remains unclear to what extent the proposed routing mechanism itself contributes to the reported performance gains.
-
The independence of the region wise evaluation is insufficient. The restoration region is defined based on the routing weights predicted by the proposed method, rather than on GT data regarding the actual blur state. While applying the same regions across all baselines is fair, it has not been verified whether these regions actually correspond to areas where both input images are blurred. Given that CommonBlurGeometry includes GT focus information, an evaluation using independently defined regions is feasible.
Questions for authors
-
GMFF is a prior study directly relevant to this work, as it addresses incomplete focal plane coverage. Please explain why this method was excluded from the quantitative comparison and, if possible, provide comparison results using the same two input images and evaluation metrics.
-
When the focus scores for both inputs are low, the weight assigned to the second image also becomes small. As a result, the blended image used by the restoration model relies primarily on the first input image. However, even when both input images are blurred, each may still contain distinct, useful information. Please clarify whether the current input configuration effectively leverages information from both images, compared to an approach that conditions the two original images independently.
-
Please provide a quantitative analysis of how well the predicted routing masks align with the actual sharp regions and jointly blurred regions, using the ground truth focus information from CommonBlurGeometry. Additionally, please verify whether the results presented in Table 2 hold when using ground truth region masks.
-
In Table 4, while the contributions of restoration and contextual refinement are significant, the further improvement gained from source preservation within CommonBlurGeometry appears relatively minor. Please conduct a comparison in which only the routing method is varied, while keeping the pretrained restorer and refiner constant, to more clearly demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed Focus Aware Content Routing approach itself.