- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents Planetary Feature Fields (PFFs), which jointly compress heterogeneous Earth-observation products using local, factored spatiotemporal neural fields with product-specific decoders. PFFs allow new timesteps or products to be added while preserving existing outputs bit-exactly. Evaluation on 14 products spanning 2017–2025 shows that PFFs achieve better average reconstruction quality than storage-matched single-product neural fields, generally retain at least 90% of source-feature performance across several downstream tasks, and provide faster feature retrieval than the evaluated API and cloud-storage pipelines. Continual-learning experiments further demonstrate efficient adaptation to new timesteps and products without changing previously supported outputs.
Critical strengths
Strong empirical validation at a meaningful scale: the paper evaluates 14 heterogeneous EO products spanning 2017–2025, with reconstruction experiments covering 100 global tiles and 16 TB of source data, plus downstream-task and retrieval-latency evaluations. This breadth makes the approach's practical relevance more convincing than a small-scale neural-field demonstration.
Critical weaknesses
- The presented evidence does not fully substantiate the claim of a general-purpose Earth representation. Most downstream evaluations rely on reconstructed products instead of the shared latent representation, and each local field is fitted specifically to its region without demonstrating transferability to previously unseen areas. Consequently, the results establish PFF more convincingly as a multi-product neural compression system rather than as a broadly transferable Earth representation, which undermines the central framing of the paper.
- The compression evaluation does not include sufficiently competitive non-neural-field baselines. The comparisons focus primarily on storage-matched coordinate networks and neural fields, without direct evaluation against multivariate autoencoders, tensor compression methods, scientific-data codecs, or related latent-field approaches. Furthermore, because the reported compression ratio depends on product dimensionality and redundancy, the current experiments do not show whether PFF competes with the most robust alternative compression paradigms.
Questions for authors
- Most downstream results evaluate reconstructed product features rather than the shared PFF latent, while the direct probe of the shared feature appears substantially weaker. What evidence supports framing PFF as a general-purpose Earth representation rather than primarily a multi-product compression system?
- How is the reported ~1800x compression ratio calculated, including product decoders, metadata, numerical precision, and missing coverage? Do the reconstruction and storage advantages hold when you exclude redundant high-dimensional embeddings and compare PFF with competitive conventional or learned codecs under identical data composition and quality targets?
2 comments
Response to Reviewer Y4CP (2/2)
[Q2]
[Q2a] How is the reported ~1800x compression ratio calculated, including product decoders, metadata, numerical precision, and missing coverage?
The exact reported ratio in our paper is 227.712 GB / 0.128 GB = 1,779x. The numerator uses the products’ native (quantized) shipped precision, including the int8 quantization of AlphaEarth and TESSERA precomputed embeddings. Absent product-years and missing products as well as nodata values are excluded from the numerator calculation.
The denominator includes the final PFF checkpoint with fp16 weights, all product decoders, and metadata. Across over 1000 PFFs trained, our checkpoints are of the following structure:
1. 121.07 MB of feature-volume and basis parameters.
2. 6.86 MB of decoders.
3. 0.07 MB of metadata (for example, the coordinate transform needed to map a geographic location into a spatial location for a specific product within a PFF).
Note that as mentioned in Section 6 of our paper, our compression ratios can change significantly depending on product composition, as well as the processing stage we consider to be the numerator. For example, the dequantized products at float32 precision (normally recommended before being used for analysis [3,4]), increase the numerator to 534.45 GB, giving approximately 4,175x compression. We therefore state the source precision explicitly in Table 2 and report separate comparisons against lossless compression techniques applied to the quantized embeddings. These comparisons are tabulated below (and have been added to Table 3b of the revised manuscript).
| Method | Storage per tile (GB) | Size relative to PFF |
|---|---|---|
| DEFLATE | 84.86 +/- 4.65 | (663 +/- 36)x |
| ZSTD | 84.28 +/- 4.64 | (658 +/- 36)x |
| LZMA | 83.45 +/- 4.49 | (652 +/- 35)x |
| LERC, zero error | 139.14 +/- 3.86 | (1,087 +/- 30)x |
| JPEG2000, lossless | 85.32 +/- 4.98 | (667 +/- 39)x |
| PFF | 0.128 | 1x |
Overall, PFFs are ~650x smaller than the best lossless codec evaluated, and are ~9 reconstruction score percentage points better than the best lossy codec evaluated at matched storage.
[Q2b] Do the reconstruction and storage advantages hold when you exclude redundant high-dimensional embeddings and compare PFF with competitive conventional or learned codecs under identical data composition and quality targets?
Precomputed embeddings are part of the storage problem that motivates PFFs. Our evaluation therefore includes them alongside raw satellite observations and derived maps. Each codec receives the same product stack, so exploiting redundancy within these products is an opportunity available to every method. Our results cover a reasonably large, heterogeneous, and representative product stack. We leave a systematic study of which products compress best together, including subsets without AlphaEarth and TESSERA, to future work.
[1] Mildenhall et al. “NeRF: Representing Scenes as Neural Radiance Fields for View Synthesis.” ECCV, 2020.
[2] Fridovich-Keil et al. “K-Planes: Explicit Radiance Fields in Space, Time, and Appearance.” CVPR, 2023.
[3] Google. (2026, July 7). AlphaEarth Foundations GCS data. Google for Developers.
[4] GeoTessera. (n.d.). Architecture guide: Quantization system. GeoTessera documentation.
Response to Reviewer Y4CP (1/2)
Thank you for critically engaging with our work, and the positive feedback.
Responses to weaknesses and questions
[W1,Q1] On claims surrounding a general-purpose Earth representation vs multi-product compression system
Thank you for the insightful question. We do not claim that PFFs provide a new general-purpose embedding or transfer to unobserved regions without fitting. Existing methods that provide reusable Earth representations are in plentiful supply (for example, AlphaEarth, TESSERA, Copernicus-FM, or CROMA). Materializing our shared latent as another dense, global embedding archive would reintroduce the storage and serving costs that motivate PFFs. Each regional field is fitted independently, without requiring its latent channels to have consistent meanings across tiles. The product decoders map these internal features into consistent product feature spaces, enabling downstream use across regions.
Multi-product neural compression is central to our approach. PFF’s neural compression is however achieved by learning a shared Earth representation. As in neural radiance fields and hybrid INRs [1,2], the data are encoded in a fitted field and recovered through learned decoding. PFFs use this formulation to represent heterogeneous Earth products within a common regional field. Figure 4 shows that sharing this representation improves reconstruction over separate fields at matched storage and preserves important predictive information (Table 1). These results support a learned Earth representation for compression and retrieval. A general-purpose embedding that transfers to unseen regions without fitting would be a stronger claim that we do not make.
[W2]
[W2a] Direct evaluation against multivariate autoencoders, tensor compression methods, scientific-data codecs, or related latent-field approaches
Thank you for prompting us to incorporate additional non-neural field baselines to our manuscript. We added SZ3, a prediction-based scientific-data compressor, and TTHRESH, a tensor compressor to Appendix Table 3a of our manuscript. In addition, we add several lossless compression methods and tabulate their final storage per-tile in Table 3b. The comparison below uses the same ten-tile PFFBench subset of all 14 products, and the same reconstruction metrics, with a total budget of 128 MB per tile (canonical PFF size).
We generally find that the evaluated lossy compression methods require approximately 16 times the bit budget to beat PFFs on the 14-product reconstruction task. At matched storage, PFFs beat these lossy codecs by ~9 reconstruction points.
[W2b] Furthermore, because the reported compression ratio depends on product dimensionality and redundancy, the current experiments do not show whether PFF competes with the most robust alternative compression paradigms.
Exploiting redundancy, both within a product and across products, is an explicit goal of PFFs. We discuss how product composition affects the compression ratio in Section 6. Additionally, to ensure fair comparisons, we evaluate reconstruction at matched storage budgets using the same products, spatial extent, and observed years for each method. This measures how well each method represents the same data within the same budget (Table 6). Because all methods represent the same source data within the same storage budget, PFFs’ reconstruction advantage cannot be attributed to a larger compression-ratio numerator.