- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Joint Flow Matching (JFM), where there is one flow over pairs that starts from at and ends at at . Integrating forward generates given , and integrating backward classifies. The main claim (eqs. 5-7) is that both directions are the conditionals of one induced joint, so generation and classification are consistent by construction. The method is experimentally validated.
Critical strengths
The construction is simple and quite practical, just one U-net does both conditional generation and classification with reasonable accuracy. The derivation of the induced joint and its density is clear, though the construction itself is not new (see weaknesses).
Critical weaknesses
I don't find any significant difference in the generation and classification task, or in the training loss, between JFM and Symmetrical Flow Matching [1], mentioned in the introduction. The paper's claimed addition is the joint and the consistency argument, which, in fact, does not identify the induced joint with the data. Indeed, it only shows that generation and classification are the two conditionals of whatever joint the flow defines. This is Bayes' rule for that joint, so it holds even when the joint differs from the data distribution. There is no comparison in experiments as well and other minor points.
[1] Caetano, Francisco, Christiaan Viviers, and Fons Van der Sommen. "Symmetrical Flow Matching: Unified Image Generation, Segmentation, and Classification with Score-Based Generative Models." Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Vol. 40. No. 4. 2026.
Questions for authors
Does the optimum of the loss recover the true dependence between the two variables, or a weaker one with the same marginals? How large is the gap at the label noise used for the images?
The consistency argument assumes continuous densities. How does it apply to one-hot labels, where the reverse output is a real vector turned into a class by an argmax?