- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors take a subset of the full wiring diagram of the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, and use it as the architecture of a controller that is trained by behavioral cloning to drive a biomechanical fly model in MuJoCo. The connectome fixes which neurons connect and with what sign; training fits input routes, cell-type physiology, synaptic scales, and motor readouts. The resulting policy walks, and the authors read out activity in known steering neurons as evidence that the model is biologically interpretable.
Critical strengths
- The model is tied to identified neurons, so in principle its activity can be compared against experiments.
- The matched-parameter baselines and the degree-preserving rewired control are a reasonable experimental design.
- The paper is easy to read.
Critical weaknesses
- The model keeps 22,688 neurons, whereas the fly brain (e.g., the FAFB dataset) alone has about 140k neurons. The paper does not explain why these seven populations were picked and what was dropped, nor how much of the connectome the retained subset actually covers.
- It takes a trip to the appendix (Fig. 5, App. B.1) to work out what the 75 "body readings" are, that the 59 controls are joint/adhesion/head-abdomen targets rather than muscles, and what each of the seven linear readouts does. These should be spelled out up front where the architecture is introduced.
- Initialization, learning rates, and clamping are described, but only one seed is ever trained. Task-optimized connectome models can settle into different solutions because the fly brain carries many redundant, parallel pathways. Lappalainen et al. [1] and Ozdil et al. [2], for example, trained an ensemble of models for exactly this reason. Drawing conclusions about specific cell types in Fig. 4 from one network is therefore problematic.
- The yaw command is fed only into FC2, and the analysis then checks whether cell types known to sit downstream of FC2 respond. That is close to guaranteed by the anatomy. What is missing is a check that descending neurons which should not carry turning signals, for example MDN [3] or the antennal-grooming aDNs [4], stay quiet. Comparing against a population mean is not a control.
- Only proprioceptive and inertial feedback is closed through MuJoCo. There is no exteroceptive input (vision, olfaction), so the compass and goal circuits the interpretation leans on never receive the kind of sensory drive they get in the animal.
- What do we exactly learn from this study? Embodied connectome demonstrations are no longer rare and a paper submitted to ICLR should say what new insight we gain from such work. No prediction about the biological circuit is made and tested; the MLP baseline outperforms the connectome model on every metric; and the rewired network keeps the same cell-type selectivity. By contrast, recent mechanistic work on this same circuit, such as the network model of path control by Osman et al. [5], is built around experimentally testable mechanisms. The present paper does not reach that standard.
References
[1] Lappalainen, J.K., Tschopp, F.D., Prakhya, S., et al. (2024). Connectome-constrained networks predict neural activity across the fly visual system. Nature 634.
[2] Ozdil, P.G., Arreguit, J., Scherrer, C., Ijspeert, A.J., Ramdya, P. (2026). Centralized brain networks underlie body part coordination during grooming. Nature Communications 17. doi: 10.1038/s41467-026-72152-x.
[3] Bidaye, S.S., Machacek, C., Wu, Y., Dickson, B.J. (2014). Neuronal control of Drosophila walking direction. Science 344.
[4] Hampel, S., Franconville, R., Simpson, J.H., Seeds, A.M. (2015). A neural command circuit for grooming movement control. eLife 4, e08758.
[5] Osman, M.A.M., Zhang, W., Pehlevan, C., Wilson, R.I. (2026). A network model of path control. bioRxiv, doi:10.64898/2026.10.02.756268.
Questions for authors
- Why were these seven populations kept and the rest of the brain discarded? What fraction of BANC does the model represent?
- Can the authors train several seeds and report the variability of the Fig. 4 cell-type responses across them?
- Do non-steering descending neurons (e.g., MDN, aDN) respond to the yaw intervention?
- Why was no exteroceptive feedback included, given that the simulators cited already support it?
- What specific, testable prediction about the fly’s steering circuit does this model make that was not already known from the anatomy?