acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Beyond Answer-Checking: Generalizable Verifiable Rewards from Task Understanding

Abstract

High-quality reward signals are critical for enhancing the capabilities of large language models on complex tasks through reinforcement learning post-training. However, existing reward approaches struggle to simultaneously achieve generality, verifiability, and interpretability. Learning-based reward models and rubric-based rewards often rely on additional models for semantic judgments, making the reward criteria and evaluation process difficult to explicitly verify, while verifiable rewards are mainly limited to tasks with easily automated evaluation and often provide only coarse-grained feedback based on final outcomes.To address these limitations, we propose Task-understanding-based General Verifiable Reward (T-GVR), a task-understanding-based general verifiable reward framework that explicitly transforms the model’s understanding of task requirements into verifiable supervision signals, providing fine-grained reward signals beyond final outcome evaluation.Specifically, T-GVR constructs a structured task representation containing task categories, task types, and key constraints, based on which it derives a Task Understanding Reward and employs a one-to-one constraint alignment strategy to improve the reliability of constraint reward estimation.Extensive experiments on mathematical reasoning, code generation, tool use, and open-ended generation tasks demonstrate that T-GVR consistently improves model performance across diverse task scenarios and highlights the effectiveness of task understanding rewards as general reward signals. Further analysis shows that explicit supervision over key task constraints is an important factor underlying the effectiveness of the Task Understanding Reward, while structured task representations and constraint alignment mechanisms further enhance the effectiveness and stability of the reward signals.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Verifiable Reward, Task Understanding

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_hi62OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes T-GVR, which asks a model to generate a task category, task type, and constraints before answering. These predictions are matched against offline annotations to provide an auxiliary reward alongside answer-level feedback. The method is evaluated on reasoning, tool-use, and open-ended generation tasks.

Critical strengths

Improving supervision beyond final-answer correctness is a useful problem. The structured task description and one-to-one constraint matching are straightforward design choices, and the experiments cover several task domains.

Critical weaknesses
  • The method is not described clearly enough to establish what is actually being compared. Section 3.4 disables answer-level rewards when deterministic verification is unavailable, while Appendix A.4.6 enables them for open-ended tasks using a separate evaluator. What rewards and evaluators are used in those experiments?

  • The main contribution is not sufficiently isolated. The method combines a task-analysis prefix, additional annotations, and auxiliary rewards. It is unclear whether the RLVR baseline generates the same prefix. A comparison using the same prefix with outcome reward alone is needed to establish the benefit of the proposed reward.

  • The choice of category, type, and constraints is weakly justified. The TACO ablations show performance drops, but do not clearly explain what was removed or how reward weights were adjusted. They also do not establish why this representation is preferable to ordinary task analysis.

  • The evidence does not support the broader claims of reliable, general task understanding. Lexical similarity does not establish semantic correctness, the key results lack training-run variability, and BLEU/ROUGE provide limited evidence of improved empathy.

Questions for authors

See weaknesses.

1 comment

We thank the reviewer for the detailed feedback.

Q-1: What rewards and evaluators are actually used for open-ended tasks?

A-1: We clarify that open-ended tasks use rubric-based answer rewards evaluated by an independently deployed, frozen Qwen3-8B judge. The judge operates in a separate vLLM process, and policy/LoRA updates are never synchronized to it. Meanwhile, the proposed reference-matching reward RUR_U remains deterministic and requires no online judge inference. Thus, the model-call-free property applies specifically to RUR_U, not the entire training pipeline. We will correct the inconsistency in Section 3.4.

Importantly, the direct Rubric-only baseline uses the same training examples and policy initialization. On WebNovelBench, T-GVR improves Reward from 0.3992 to 0.5108 and Percentile from 0.1165 to 0.3571, demonstrating the additional value of structured task supervision under the reported evaluation protocol.

Q-2: Is the contribution sufficiently isolated from the structured prefix?

A-2: The distinction is fundamental: generating a task-analysis prefix does not guarantee that the identified requirements are correct. T-GVR explicitly evaluates this intermediate representation against offline references and incorporates the resulting feedback into RL optimization. Thus, the contribution is not merely adding a reasoning prefix, but making requirement identification a directly rewarded objective.

The TACO ablations demonstrate that removing individual supervision components substantially reduces complete-program correctness. While a same-prefix control would isolate the reward contribution more precisely, the existing evidence supports the effectiveness of the proposed framework rather than mere prompting.

Q-3: Why Category, Type, and Constraints? How are ablations implemented?

A-3: The three components serve complementary purposes: Category identifies the broad task domain, Type specifies the fine-grained objective, and Constraints capture instance-specific requirements. This decomposition enables exact verification of predefined labels and flexible alignment of variable-length requirements, which ordinary free-form task analysis does not directly provide.

TACO ablations use group-wise redistribution rather than simply zeroing coefficients:

SettingCategoryTypeConstraints
Full0.200.200.60
w/o Category00.400.60
w/o Type0.4000.60
w/o Constraints0.500.500
w/o Matching0.200.200.60

Corresponding prompt fields and format checks are also removed where applicable, while the outer reward weights remain 0.1/0.8/0.1.

The ablations reveal a meaningful distinction between partial and complete correctness. Removing Constraints preserves much of Case Accuracy (0.2854 vs. 0.2698) but reduces Program Accuracy from 0.0990 to 0.0588. Removing Matching similarly reduces Program Accuracy to 0.0580 despite higher Case Accuracy. These results support the role of constraint supervision and alignment in satisfying complete task specifications.

Q-4: Is there sufficient evidence for generality and reliability?

A-4: T-GVR's generality concerns the applicability of a shared reward-construction mechanism across heterogeneous tasks, rather than a claim of perfect semantic verification. The framework is evaluated on five benchmarks spanning mathematical reasoning, code generation, tool use, empathetic dialogue, and creative writing.

The improvements are not limited to lexical evaluation: T-GVR exceeds RLVR on Dapo-Math (0.4785 vs. 0.3955), TACO Program Accuracy (0.0990 vs. 0.0610), and BFCL V4 (0.4094 vs. 0.3105). It also outperforms Rubric-only on WebNovelBench and improves BLEU-1 and ROUGE-L on EmpatheticDialogues. These results provide consistent evidence of usefulness across distinct task settings and evaluation mechanisms. Broader model coverage and multi-seed evaluation would strengthen statistical generalization claims, but do not invalidate the observed results.

Reviewer_GPV7OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes T-GVR, a framework for improving reinforcement learning of LLMs by rewarding their understanding of task requirements rather than relying solely on final-answer correctness. The method require model to generate a structured task representation (task category, etc) before producing its response, which is evaluated aganst offline-generated reference annotations. The authors evaluate T-GVR using Qwen3-8B across five benchmarks, and show improvements.

Critical strengths

The paper proposes a relatively simple approach to obtaining fine-grained reward signals from structured task requirements. T-GVR makes its task-understanding reward more interpretable than black-box reward modeling, and computing this component does not require additional LLM calls.

Critical weaknesses
  1. A concern is that whether the proposed reward truly captures task understanding. the method evaluates the response through lexical similarity measures, which doesn't not imply semantic equivalence.

  2. T-GVR introduces both an intermediate structured task-analysis stage and additional reward supervision derived from offline LLM annotations. So the improvement can benefit from both the additional analysis and the proposed rewards. It is not clear which part leads to the gain.

Questions for authors
  1. How do the authors validate that lexical similarity between predicted and reference constraints reflects actual semantic task understanding? Could the authors provide evidence, such as agreement with human judgments?

  2. Do the baselines use the same prompt and structured task-analysis format as T-GVR, with only the reward function changed? If not, could the authors include this controlled comparison to isolate the contribution of the proposed reward?

2 comments

We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments.

Q-1: Does lexical similarity genuinely reflect task understanding?

A-1: T-GVR does not equate lexical similarity with semantic equivalence. The proposed reward combines exact Category/Type matching, weighted constraint similarity, one-to-one bipartite alignment, and symmetric normalization. These mechanisms jointly supervise requirement identification while penalizing omissions and redundant predictions. Crucially, lexical matching is applied to the intermediate task representation, not used as a substitute for final-answer correctness. The improvements on objectively verifiable tasks provide additional evidence of its practical utility: T-GVR outperforms RLVR on Dapo-Math (0.4785 vs. 0.3955), TACO Program Accuracy (0.0990 vs. 0.0610), and BFCL V4 (0.4094 vs. 0.3105). These gains cannot be explained by lexical similarity in the evaluation metrics, since the corresponding outcomes are independently verified. Human semantic agreement remains an additional validation question, not a prerequisite for establishing the usefulness of the proposed supervision.

Q-2: Are the gains caused by the structured prefix rather than the reward?

A-2: A structured prefix alone only encourages the model to generate task analysis; it does not establish whether that analysis correctly identifies the task requirements. T-GVR introduces an explicit optimization signal by comparing the intermediate representation with fixed, withheld references. This is the central distinction between prompting for task analysis and rewarding its correctness.

The ablation results further support the importance of structured supervision: removing Category, Type, or Constraints reduces TACO Program Accuracy from 0.0990 to 0.0457, 0.0410, and 0.0588, respectively. Although a same-prefix answer-only baseline would provide finer causal isolation, the existing comparisons and ablations demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed integrated framework. The absence of this additional control does not negate the reported performance improvements.

Thank you for the thoughtful response and helpful clarifications. I appreciate the promising results and the additional explanations. However, my main concerns regarding semantic validation and the missing controlled baseline remain unresolved. I therefore maintain my current rating.

Reviewer_kLnjOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes T-GVR (Task-understanding-based General Verifiable Reward), a reward framework for RL post-training of LLMs. It rewards the model for identifying what a task requires, not solely for its final answer. Before responding, the policy writes a structured task analysis in a fixed XML template. The analysis gives a task category and a task type, both chosen from predefined label sets, and a list of key constraints in natural language. This analysis is scored against a reference written offline by Gemini 3 Flash Lite, which is used only to compute the reward and is never shown to the policy: (a) Category and type are scored by exact match after normalization. (b) Constraints are scored by word overlap (a weighted mix of token F1, ROUGE-L and BLEU). Each predicted constraint is paired with at most one reference constraint by maximum-weight bipartite matching, and the total is normalized by the lengths of both lists, which penalizes both missing and redundant constraints.

The resulting task-understanding reward is added to whatever answer check the task has (exact-match math answers, code unit tests, tool-call checks) and to rule-based checks of the reference constraints. The authors argue this gives finer-grained, interpretable feedback with no judge model in the training loop, for both objective and open-ended tasks.

For experimentation, Qwen3-8B is trained with GRPO and LoRA, separately per task, on 200 examples for 100 steps. There are five tasks: math (Dapo-Math), code (TACO), tool use (BFCL V4), empathetic dialogue (EmpatheticDialogues) and creative writing (WebNovelBench). Baselines are answer-only RL (RLVR) on the verifiable tasks, a rubric-only reward on the open-ended tasks, and two general reward models, POLAR and Skywork-Reward-V2, on all five. T-GVR reports the best results across tasks. The largest gain is on TACO, where the share of programs passing all tests rises from 0.061 to 0.099 and the average share of tests passed from 0.080 to 0.285.

Critical strengths
  • Simple and cheap: no judge model is called during training, and the reward is deterministic + rule-based. The rule-based checks use the stored constraints, not the model's own list, so the model can't gain by leaving constraints out.
  • The one-to-one constraint pairing, scaled by both list lengths, stops the model from inflating its score with repeated or padded constraints.
  • Covers five quite different tasks, including open-ended ones, and works alongside answer-only RL rather than replacing it.
Critical weaknesses
  1. "Verifiable" is overclaimed. The constraint reward is word overlap (token F1, ROUGE-L, BLEU) with paraphrases written by an LLM (Gemini 3 Flash Lite). It measures matching wording rather than understanding, and it may reward copying phrases from the prompt. The quality of the Gemini annotations is never checked, e.g., against human annotations. Overall, the checks read as a heuristic, and I am not convinced they will scale to a wide range of difficult tasks.
  2. The "no judge model" claim contradicts the appendix. Sec. 3.4 states that open-ended tasks receive no answer-level reward (bx=0b_x = 0), whereas App. A.4.6 states that they do (bx=1b_x = 1), scored by a rubric or reference-based evaluator. This also conflicts with the "zero-model-call" contribution. If the WebNovelBench training reward matches its test metric, the open-ended evaluation is circular.
  3. The key control is missing. There is no run that keeps the task-analysis prefix but uses only the answer reward. Without it, it is unclear whether the gains come from the proposed reward or simply from planning before answering. The closest prior work, rubric-based RL (e.g., Rubrics as Rewards, checklist rewards, RiT), is also not compared.
  4. The experimental setup is small and underspecified.
    • A single seed, with no variance reported.
    • 200 training examples per task, with batch size 2.
    • The weights λ, α and η and the category/type label sets are never given.
    • Rollout counts differ between methods on EmpatheticDialogues: 8 for T-GVR vs 4 for the reward-model baselines.
  5. Several numbers look implausible. It would be good to have sme explanations for these in the paper:
    • Base Qwen3-8B scores 5.3% on Dapo-Math, which suggests responses may be cut off at the 2,048-token generation limit.
    • Answer-only RL scores below the base model on BFCL V4 (0.311 vs 0.328).
    • SFT scores 0 program accuracy on TACO.
    • Dapo-Math-17K is a training set, yet it serves here as a 17,000-problem test set. A standard math benchmark (e.g., AIME or MATH-500) would be more convincing.
  6. The ablations are hard to interpret. Removing the category term leaves the model worse than the base model (0.046 vs 0.058 program accuracy on TACO). Removing the matching step gives higher case accuracy than the full method (0.301 vs 0.285). With a single seed, these differences may reflect noise rather than the effect of each component.
  7. The open-ended evidence is weak. EmpatheticDialogues is scored only by BLEU/ROUGE against a single reference response. The gains are marginal, and BLEU-3 is below the base model. The t-SNE plots and transfer bar charts are qualitative, with no numbers reported.
  8. Figure 1 is hard to follow. It reads as a collection of boxes, without a clear indication of the input, the output, or the order of steps. A left-to-right flow from prompt, to task analysis, to answer, to the separate reward terms would make the method much easier to grasp.
  9. The comparison is not exhaustive. Tables 3 and 4 compare only against RL baselines trained on Qwen3-8B. Reference results from frontier models and agentic pipelines on the same benchmarks would help place the absolute numbers in context.
  10. The paper does not have a reproducibility section or associated source code provided as supplementary.

Overall, moving beyond sparse, outcome-only rewards toward finer-grained supervision of task understanding is a worthwhile direction. However, the proposed reward is essentially a heuristic. It rests on surface-level similarity metrics such as BLEU and ROUGE rather than on any logical or semantic verification. It may help on the relatively simple tasks studied here, but I am not convinced it will scale to harder tasks, other models (only Qwen3-8B is tested) or other benchmarks.

Questions for authors

see weaknesses

2 comments

Q-1: Verifiability and annotation quality (W1).

A-1: T-GVR does not claim to prove semantic equivalence. With fixed offline references, its task-understanding reward is deterministic and inspectable, unlike black-box judgments. Exact label matching and one-to-one constraint alignment with symmetric normalization penalize redundant or missing requirements. Extracting prompt requirements is the intended skill; response rewards assess execution. Gemini references may be imperfect, but the reward mechanism is annotation-model agnostic.

Q-2: Open-ended rewards and judge calls (W2).

A-2: We clarify a presentation error: open-ended tasks use an enabled rubric-based answer reward from a separately deployed, frozen Qwen3-8B judge. Policy updates do not alter it. “No online judge calls” applies only to the deterministic reference-matching term, not the complete training pipeline. This incurs cost and potential same-family bias. Both methods share the evaluation protocol, yet T-GVR exceeds Rubric-only on WebNovelBench (reward 0.5108 vs. 0.3992; percentile 0.3571 vs. 0.1165). We will correct Sec. 3.4 and narrow the efficiency claim.

Q-3: Prefix confound and rubric-related work (W3).

A-3: A task-analysis prefix alone supplies no explicit correctness signal for the analysis. T-GVR rewards agreement with withheld references, explicitly supervising whether the model identifies the right requirements. This differs from grading the response alone. On TACO, Program Accuracy rises from 0.0610 (RLVR) to 0.0990 (T-GVR), with Case Accuracy rising from 0.0796 to 0.2854. These results support the integrated method, although a same-prefix control would better isolate the reward. Unlike rubric-based intermediate-reasoning methods, our reward directly scores a predefined task-requirement representation.

Q-4: Scale, weights, and rollout fairness (W4).

A-4: The 200-example, 100-step setup tests reward utility in low-data RL. We use task-specific reward coefficients (e.g., TACO 0.20/0.20/0.60; BFCL 0.25/0.25/0.50 for Category/Type/Constraints). On EmpatheticDialogues, T-GVR and Rubric-only both use eight rollouts, versus four for reward-model baselines. Thus, the direct Rubric-only comparison is rollout-matched. We will clarify label sets; single-seed results are point estimates.

Q-5: Benchmark anomalies (W5).

A-5: Although Dapo-Math is commonly used for training, our 200 training examples are strictly disjoint from the evaluation set, preventing train–test overlap in our fine-tuning experiments. Moreover, Dapo-Math contains challenging mathematical reasoning problems, making it a meaningful evaluation of reasoning ability. Under identical evaluation settings, T-GVR substantially outperforms RLVR (0.4785 vs. 0.3955). The 2,048-token limit is applied consistently across methods and therefore does not invalidate the relative comparison. On BFCL, T-GVR also exceeds both RLVR (0.3105) and Base (0.3280), reaching 0.4094. On TACO, SFT achieves nonzero Case Accuracy but zero Program Accuracy because no generated program passes all test cases.

Q-6: Ablation interpretation (W6).

A-6: Ablations remove corresponding prompt fields/checks and redistribute weights by group, not merely zero coefficients. For TACO, the full Category/Type/Constraint weights are 0.20/0.20/0.60; w/o Category: 0/0.40/0.60; w/o Type: 0.40/0/0.60; w/o Constraints: 0.50/0.50/0. The outer 0.1/0.8/0.1 weights remain fixed. Removing Matching raises Case Accuracy (0.2854→0.3014) but lowers Program Accuracy (0.0990→0.0580), consistent with alignment favoring complete correctness. We do not claim statistical significance.

Q-7: Open-ended evidence (W7).

A-7: We do not equate BLEU/ROUGE with empathy. Yet T-GVR exceeds Base/Rubric-only on BLEU-1 (0.1088 vs. 0.1040/0.0770) and ROUGE-L (0.1286 vs. 0.1212/0.0987). BLEU-3 is not uniformly improved. WebNovelBench improves on both reported metrics; transfer plots and t-SNE are supplementary diagnostics rather than the primary evidence.

Q-8: Figure 1 (W8).

A-8: The workflow is prompt → task analysis → answer → separate reward components. Offline references never enter policy inputs; we will clarify the diagram.

Q-9: Frontier-model comparisons (W9).

A-9: We evaluate reward design, not frontier-model capability. A shared Qwen3-8B policy better isolates supervision effects than comparisons across different model scales and agentic budgets.

Q-10: Reproducibility (W10).

A-10: The reward consists of exact label scoring, weighted lexical similarity, bipartite matching, and symmetric normalization—all auditable operations. We will clarify coefficients, label sets, and evaluator configurations. Code availability would further improve replication, but the reward computation itself is explicitly specified.

Reviewer_kLnjOpenReview ↗

Official comment by Reviewer kLnj

Thank you for the rebuttal and for addressing my comments. While I appreciate the clarifications, I still have some important concerns. In particular, without a same-prefix control using only the answer-level reward, it remains unclear how much of the improvement comes from the proposed task-understanding reward itself. I am also not fully convinced that lexical similarity against LLM-generated references reliably captures task understanding, especially without any validation of the annotations. Further, all results are based on a single seed, and the ablations do not provide enough evidence to establish the contribution of individual components.

Further, some of the author responses are quite brief and do not fully address my questions. I did not see any new experiments or corresponding changes to the paper addressing these concerns. I appreciate the authors' efforts, but unfortunately, my main concerns remain, and I do not feel the rebuttal warrants changing my score.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.