- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes StrainPair, a fine-tuning objective for adapting pretrained interatomic potentials to elastic properties. In addition to the regression loss on energy, force, and stress, StrainPair adds an L1 loss on the stress differences between deformed configurations of the same material along the same strain axis, using the existing stress labels of Materials Project elasticity calculations. The authors argue that this pairing cancels a common stress offset and constrains how the stress changes with strain, and they support this with an analysis for affine residual paths. Starting from a pretrained Orb-v3 model, StrainPair gives lower shear and bulk modulus errors than fine-tuning on the same data without the paired loss, both on Matbench and on a separate set of materials. The authors attribute the gain to a more accurate stress changes along each strain path.
Critical strengths
The method is simple and easy to adopt, as it reuses stress labels that already exist in elasticity datasets.
Critical weaknesses
Limited methodological novelty. The main contribution appears to be an application of established training ideas to elasticity. Learning output differences has precedents in GAR [1], derivative supervision in Sobolev training [2], and supervision of energy curvature in interatomic potentials in PFT [3]. StrainPair’s main distinction is to pair deformations of the same material along the same strain axis using existing stress labels. The analysis explains offset cancellation and its connection to stress response, but I find the additional insight beyond these expected properties limited. I therefore view the methodological contribution as incremental. Experiments beyond a single Orb-v3 variant would help establish its broader value.
Missing baseline and unclear scoring criteria. Table 2 omits the pretrained model, so it is unclear whether either method improves external performance over its starting point. The criteria for accepting an elastic estimate are also not fully specified. Invalid estimates receive a median replacement when calculating MAE, where in Table 1, StrainPair produces 84 more valid estimates than Single. The comparison therefore includes materials for which one method uses its prediction and the other uses the replacement value. Please define the validity criteria and report MAE on materials for which all models produce valid estimates, alongside the existing scores. This would show whether the accuracy gains persist without median replacements.
Unclear practical advantage. Compared with Single, StrainPair has higher force and stress errors and larger deviations under rotation. On the 1,500 frames excluded from training, force MAE increases by 17.76% over the pretrained model, compared with 10.73% for Single. Both satisfy the authors’ stated error limit, but energy errors mentioned in Section 2 are not reported. The improvement in modulus MAE also yields only a small screening gain: eight additional materials with $ G \geq 100$ GPa among 1,099 selections, with no increase in bulk threshold hits. These results leave unclear when the modulus improvements justify the accompanying losses in other predictions.
Questions for authors
-
Could you add the pretrained model’s results on the external materials to Table 2, using the same evaluation procedure? This would make it clear whether either method improves over its starting point.
-
What are the criteria for accepting an elastic estimate? Please also report MAE on materials for which all models produce valid estimates, alongside the existing scores, to clarify the effect of median replacements.
-
Could you report the energy errors mentioned in Section 2? How do modulus accuracy and force and stress errors change as the weight of the pair loss is varied?
-
Do the improvements over matched Single persist with another Orb-v3 pretraining variant or a different potential architecture?
References
[1] Dixian Zhu, Tianbao Yang, and Livnat Jerby. Gradient Aligned Regression via Pairwise Losses. ICML, 2025.
[2] Wojciech M. Czarnecki, Simon Osindero, Max Jaderberg, Grzegorz Swirszcz, and Razvan Pascanu. Sobolev Training for Neural Networks. NeurIPS, 2017.
[3] Teddy Koker, Abhijeet Sadashiv Gangan, Mit Kotak, Jaime Marian, and Tess Smidt. PFT: Phonon Fine-tuning for Machine Learned Interatomic Potentials. ICML, 2026.