- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
As far as we know, existing backpropagation algorithms, parameters are tightly coupled across the time dimension, hindering the quantification of individual impacts and limiting the depth and theoretical interpretability of gradient dynamics analysis. In this manuscript, the author proposes a spatio-temporal spectral backpropagation (STSBP) framework that decomposes error propagation in pulse-coupled neural networks into the spatio-temporal frequency domain.
Critical strengths
- In the field of time series forecasting, developing efficient algorithms for training light-weight SNNs is a very meaningful research topic.
- The integration training from the perspective of time and space is more conducive to the SNN model obtaining valuable information.
Critical weaknesses
- The current title and abstract seem to need further improvement. After all, the experiment focuses on the task of time series prediction. Looking at the title, it seems that this is a training method designed for classification tasks, similar to most SNN models.
- By observing Table 1, it is intuitively seen that the performance improvement effect is rather limited, and further significant verification is required. Furthermore, how significant is the efficiency advantage when compared to other complex full-precision Transformer models?
- During the formal analysis process, several lines of integral expressions were added. Some details of the binary integrals are suggested to be placed in the appendix.
- Could some visualized results of the gradients be provided to verify the correctness of the proposed theory?
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses!