- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on unseen dance restyle. It adopts concepts from Labanotation motion analysis. Given three keyframes, the method uses LMA to discretize motion into multiple LMA-based attributes and then pretrains an MLP-based field to predict the residual between the input dance and the target style dance, thereby completing the restyle task.
Critical strengths
- The use of LMA is interesting. Many works have shown that Labanotation offers advantages for motion understanding and modeling.
- The claim that the method can transfer an unseen style using only three keyframes is ambitious. If the paper has indeed solved this task, I would be very excited.
- Although the writing is poor, the paper consistently tries to distinguish itself from existing work, and want to tell something to the audience. I appreciate it.
Critical weaknesses
The introduction is very poorly written. Fortunately, I am familiar with Labanotation and phase representation; otherwise, I would have had no idea what the paper was discussing. The main text tries to highlight the core differences between the proposed framework and existing style transfer methods. I appreciate this effort, and the proposed ideas are interesting and exciting. However, the English writing is poor. Sentences are over-compressed and readability is low.
The related work should at least introduce what Labanotation is. Alternatively, the appendix should describe LMA, including what it is, where it can be used, and why it is effective.
The English writing in the methodology is even more confusing. It does not read as academic English, and I found it difficult to follow. What does "no support" in Figure 2 mean? The figure gives me the impression that it was produced with an AI-assisted research tool. Overall, the writing is too poor. Even if the idea is strong, I cannot accurately judge from the methodology description whether the method works or what its defects are. I simply cannot understand it.
The main text mentions a newly collected Laban dancing dataset. I am willing to treat this as a contribution, but I searched the entire paper with CTRL+F and found no related content. How was this dataset constructed? How can the fidelity of Laban information extraction be guaranteed? These points are unclear. These critical problems lead me to a clear rejection.
From the supplementary video, my main concern is that the results are not good. I kept observing motions under the "sexy" label. The hands move abruptly, which makes the overall motion poorly coordinated. Visually, the restyle results are not intuitive, and the method does not achieve the stylization seen in methods on the XIA dataset. The sentences in the appendix are not grammatical at all. Overall, the paper falls below the acceptance bar.
Questions for authors
Please answer the questions I mentioned in Critical Weaknesses section.