- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a multi-human animation framework built on direct in-context video conditioning without explicit pose or mesh extraction at inference. They further introduce Reference Asymmetric RoPE Conditioning to preserve fine-grained appearance details, and Identity Binding Supervision to associate each reference identity with its intended motion trajectory. They also construct MotionTwin, a dataset containing approximately 14.4K cross-identity video pairs, and the MotionTwin-Bench evaluation set. The validation includes quantitative comparisons and ablations on MotionTwin-Bench, automatic metrics and qualitative comparisons on real-world inputs, and a human preference study.
Critical strengths
- The author proposes a new way for constructing cross identity video pair dataset and build the large-scale MotionTwin dataset which contains both single-person and multi-person pairs, providing direct supervision for effective motion transfer and identity-motion binding. It supports the training and evaluation of the proposed method and could also provide a valuable resource for future research.
- The author proposes novel improvements, particularly IBS, which effectively enhances the model’s ability to preserve information about each subject, and conduct extensive ablation studies on the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
The paper lacks powerful automatic metrics for identity binding. IAA uses color features to match subjects. It may confuse people wearing similar-colored clothes or fail to detect identity swaps. Ground truth masks may not align with generated subjects if their body shapes, poses, or positions are different. In those cases, the score may be affected even when identities are correct.
Questions for authors
None.
5 comments
Thank you for the additional evaluations. They substantially alleviate my main concern. However, the metrics are not yet fully validated. WL2P ranking first across evaluators supports its advantage, but does not establish how accurately these metrics detect identity-binding errors. Agreement with human judgments would provide stronger evidence. But overall,given the creativity of the work and the thorough, thoughtful rebuttal, I am raising my score from 3 to 4.
Thanks for the response. I will maintain my rating.
Official Response to Reviewer hoKM
W1. Reliability of Identity Assignment Metrics
We appreciate the reviewer's concern about the limitations of color-based identity evaluation.
To complement the original color-based IAA, we evaluate identity binding on all 225 multi-person pairs using CLIP-ReID and Gemini 3.8 Flash. CLIP-ReID uses identity embeddings for assignment, while Gemini serves as a VLM judge [1], comparing full generated frames with paired GT frames using its own visual grounding.
Spatial misalignment. Gemini assesses identities using global scene context, without restricting generated subjects to fixed GT-mask regions. Baseline scores and rankings differ between the region-based and full-frame evaluators, underscoring the value of assessing identity binding beyond localized crops. Especially, we observe that Wan-Animate-2 tends to render subjects larger than their GT counterparts, which can adversely affect identity matching within fixed GT-mask regions. WL2P ranks first under both, supporting its advantage when the evaluation does not require exact alignment with GT masks.
Similar reference colors. On the 57 pairs with the most similar reference colors, WL2P achieves the highest score under all three evaluators.
Together, these results support WL2P's advantage beyond color-based matching and fixed GT-mask crops. We welcome suggestions for additional identity-aware metrics and would be happy to incorporate them into our evaluation during the remaining discussion period.
[1] Cong et al. OmniXRef: A Unified Framework for Multimodal Multi-Reference Video Editing. 2026. arXiv:2610.22744.