- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tries to explore methods for generating lesion masks by combining inverse optimization and topological constraints with an annealing strategy that integrates stochastic exploration and deterministic optimization; the authors try to validate approach through downstream segmentation experiments across multiple datasets.
Critical strengths
Generating masks with appropriate shapes and locations for lesions is an intriguing area of exploration and holds clinical importance; the motivation behind the paper is commendable.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological design raises concerns; specifically, certain operations—such as the use of truncation thresholds in the algorithms—lack a solid theoretical basis, making the method susceptible to dataset-specific overfitting and raising doubts about its generalizability. Furthermore, the design fails to address the mechanism of high-density collapse inherent in diffusion models, and the authors make several overblown claims.
-
The reliability and stability of the experiments are questionable. The paper fails to report results from repeated trials or provide error analyses for the segmentation stage; clearly quantifying the errors and uncertainty associated with the segmentation process is essential to establishing the paper's robustness.
Questions for authors
Two issues require a direct response from the authors:
-
Regarding methodology, is there a theoretical mechanism supporting the initialization of ? Given that one of the primary goals of synthesizing lesions (pathologies) is to address the long-tailed distribution problem, the current mechanism appears to facilitate easy exploration of mask regions associated with high probability density; meanwhile, the deformations and similar features incorporated into the design seem to stem largely from the authors' subjective intent. The authors need to clearly distinguish between their motivations, assumptions, and theoretical evidence.
-
The experiments lack corresponding error analysis and an assessment of uncertainty regarding the downstream segmentation model; it remains unclear to what extent the intrinsic uncertainty of the downstream segmentation model affects the evaluation of the proposed method's effectiveness.