- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Product-Spherical Shape Dissimilarity (PSSD), a framework for comparing trajectories embedded in spheres or product spheres while accounting for spherical scaling and reference-based translation. It constructs spherical pre-shapes, extends the framework to rotational alignment through Spherical Procrustes Dissimilarity (SPD), and develops a smoothing estimator with a uniform convergence guarantee. The authors evaluate the proposed measures on synthetic and real-world datasets using k-nearest-neighbor classification and comparisons with geometric and neural-network baselines. The results show consistent gains on the designed synthetic settings, while improvements on real-world datasets are more mixed.
Critical strengths
(1) A potentially valuable geometric formulation. The paper introduces PSSD to compare trajectories on spheres and product spheres while accounting for specific scaling and reference-based alignment invariances. This provides a mathematically explicit framework for a class of non-Euclidean shape analysis problems and represents a potentially meaningful methodological contribution.
(2) Theoretical analysis beyond a standalone distance definition. The paper extends the proposed framework to rotational alignment and develops a smoothing estimator with a uniform convergence guarantee. The combination of geometric formulation, theoretical analysis, and evaluation on synthetic and real-world datasets gives the work a coherent methodological foundation.
Critical weaknesses
(1) Insufficient justification for the proposed invariance. The paper does not adequately explain why the reference-based spherical alignment and scaling invariance are appropriate for the target applications, or how the choice of reference center affects PSSD.
(2) Limited evidence of generalization. The synthetic experiments closely match the invariance that PSSD is designed to capture, while the improvements on real-world datasets are mixed. Comparisons with closely related manifold-based shape analysis methods are also missing, making it difficult to assess the practical advantage of PSSD over existing approaches.
Questions for authors
(1) How sensitive is PSSD to the choice of reference center? Can the authors explain how the reference center is estimated during evaluation and whether changing the reference set affects pairwise dissimilarities?
(2) Can the authors compare PSSD with more closely related manifold-based trajectory or shape-analysis methods, and evaluate settings where class differences are not primarily driven by the scaling transformations that PSSD is designed to remove?
2 comments
3. Relationship to manifold-based trajectory analysis
The closest related literature concerns elastic shape analysis of manifold-valued trajectories. These approaches, however, address a different topic on the temporal registration. Our method is developed in the spirit of Procrustes shape analysis. In 2. Relationship to existing elastic shape analysis methods of our response to Reviewer Zq28, we discuss these differences in detail and provide an analytical example in which the proposed measure gives zero dissimilarity while the existing measures give positive dissimilarity. This illustrates that the methods impose different notions of shape equivalence.
To the best of our knowledge, this specific Procrustes-type formulation for product-spherical trajectory shapes has not previously been developed.
In 3 Additional synthetic experiments of our response to Reviewer yWNV, we provide additional experiments on the comparison with the existing elastic shape analysis methods of manifold-valued trajectories in Su et al. (2014) and Zhang et al. (2018). In both the single- and product-sphere settings, PSSD gives zero within-group dissimilarity and positive between-group dissimilarity, with classification accuracy. The two elastic dissimilarities have similar average within-group and between-group values and lower classification accuracy in this controlled example. These results suggest that the two measures do not fully capture the notion of spherical shape considered in this work. The analytical comparison in 2. Relationship to existing elastic shape analysis methods of our response to Reviewer Zq28 explains this distinction.
4. Data-generation procedure
We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. Our primary objective is to quantify spherical trajectory shape under the specified equivalence with respect to spherical translation and uniform scaling. The synthetic study therefore requires known shape classes. Generating trajectories from a common underlying shape within each group, while varying the centers and scales, which are treated as nuisance, provides interpretable ground truth for this evaluation. Classification serves as a downstream assessment of whether the dissimilarity measures could recover the structure. The synthetic results should be interpreted as a controlled assessment of recovery under the specified shape equivalence, which is a common experimental design in the shape analysis literature.
References
- Dryden, I. L. and Mardia, K. V. (2016). Statistical Shape Analysis: With Applications in R. 2nd edition. John Wiley & Sons.
- Su, J., Kurtek, S., Klassen, E., and Srivastava, A. (2014). Statistical analysis of trajectories on Riemannian manifolds: Bird migration, hurricane tracking and video surveillance. The Annals of Applied Statistics, 8(1), 530–552.
- Trosset, M. W., Priebe, C. E., Park, Y., and Miller, M. I. (2008). Semisupervised learning from dissimilarity data. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 52(10), 4643–4657.
- Zhang, Z., Klassen, E., and Srivastava, A. (2018). Phase-amplitude separation and modeling of spherical trajectories. Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics, 27(1), 85–97.
We thank the reviewer for these comments. We address the concerns below.
1. Motivation for spherical alignment and scaling invariance
The proposed invariances target applications in which the geometric pattern of a trajectory is of interest, while the location and scale are treated as nuisance. Besides the shape classification considered in the paper, data alignment is also an important application in the literature (see, e.g., Dryden and Mardia, 2016). Moreover, other real-data examples also motivate spherical shape analysis, such as flight trajectories. For regional flight segments represented by geographical positions on a sphere, one may wish to identify recurring looping or bending patterns across different locations. The proposed method enables comparison of these patterns irrespective of location and size.
2. Reference point and dissimilarity matrix calculation
The common reference is part of the definition of PSSD and is estimated as the Fréchet mean of the individual trajectory centers. The PSSD measure depends on the reference point, but when the common reference point is fixed, the zero-dissimilarity relation is transitive for different spherical trajectories; see 5. Reference point sensitivity analysis of our response to Reviewer Zq28 for details.
In our reported evaluation, the reference is estimated once from the full data collection, and the resulting dissimilarity matrix is held fixed across the classification splits. Classifier fitting and tuning use training labels only. This is a classical procedure for semi-supervised tasks in the multidimensional scaling literature, where the full dissimilarity matrix is obtained first; see, e.g., Section 3 of Trosset et al. (2008).
The sensitivity experiment in 5. Reference point sensitivity analysis of our response to Reviewer Zq28 quantifies the effect of perturbing the reference. Over the range 0–0.20 radians, the mean within-group dissimilarity increases from 0.00 to 0.02, while classification remains at 100. These results indicate classification stability in the simulation setting examined.