acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Structured Composition of Verifiable Atomic Insights for Table-to-Report Generation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Table-to-report generation refers to the task of automatically generating article-level analyt- ical reports from relational tables and is an essential capability for automated data science and decision support. Its central challenge lies in systematically discovering verifiable com- posite insights across tables, attributes, and analytical perspectives, and organizing them into coherent, complete, and traceable evidence chains. Existing methods primarily rely on sequential, reactive data agents or direct Large Language Model(LLM) generation. They suffer from exploration bias: early local observations constrain subsequent actions, causing models to focus prematurely on local analyzes and miss cross-table or cross-dimensional evidence. We propose ComInsight, which reformulates insight discovery as the composition of atomic evidences. We first define an atomic insight as the smallest executable analytical unit conforming to a predefined analysis pattern and enumerate all valid atomic insights from database schema and content. These atoms are then organized into a multi-relational insight graph, where nodes represent verified data facts and edges encode logical, temporal, or hierarchical relations. Finally, a set of composition operators systematically fuses atomic nodes into higher-order composite conclusions. Every composite output is accompanied by executable SQL and fine-grained provenance, ensuring full verifiability. Across three benchmarks InsightBench, DDR-Bench, and T2R-Bench, ComInsight consistently outperforms strong baselines in factual correctness, novelty, and structural completeness. We believe ComInsight offers a reliable, efficient, and explainable path toward table-to-report generation. Source code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ci-report.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Composite Insights, Table-to-report Generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_PdTLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ComInsight for table-to-report generation. It enumerates candidate atomic findings using analytical patterns and SQL templates, filters them using statistical tests and a learned interestingness judge, and organizes them into a multi-relational graph. Composition procedures generate higher-order findings, which are synthesized into reports with SQL provenance. Evaluation covers InsightBench, DDR-Bench, and T2R-Bench.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation goes beyond generating fluent reports: an analysis should discover related findings across tables and organize them into traceable evidence chains. The example of sequential exploration becoming anchored on early local findings makes structured composition a relevant direction.

  2. Explicit SQL provenance and the separation of atomic evidence from report synthesis are promising design choices. The reported gains across three benchmarks and the included ablations suggest that the integrated pipeline has practical potential.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The distinctive contribution of structured composition is not sufficiently established. Atomic finding enumeration, insight filtering, relation graphs, and LLM synthesis each have precedents. Their integration could still be a contribution, but the paper needs to demonstrate what new analytical capability the composition framework enables and why it remedies exploration bias. The current comparison with simple LLM concatenation does not adequately isolate structured composition from the availability of more candidate findings, intermediate organization, or additional computation. A graph-free composer supplied with the same verified atoms and a comparable budget would be a more informative test. This is more important than claiming that the individual components must themselves be new.

  2. The evidence does not yet support the central claim of fully verifiable composite conclusions. Executing the SQL for constituent atoms establishes those observations, but not necessarily the relationships or explanatory statements synthesized from them. The main text appropriately calls causal composites hypotheses, whereas the abstract and appendix use stronger language about full verifiability and causal verification. Granger tests and an LLM plausibility judgment do not alone establish a causal explanation. The evaluation should distinguish reproduction of atomic values, correctness of composed relational claims, and support for causal interpretations. The mentioned manual auditing does not provide enough quantitative evidence to resolve this gap.

  3. The learned filtering stage introduces an important evaluation uncertainty. Training examples for the interestingness judge and calibration are drawn from the same named benchmarks used in evaluation. This does not establish leakage by itself, but the exact separation of training, calibration, and test tables/tasks needs to be explicit. An independent evaluation of the judge is also needed to support the claim that filtering approximately 85% of candidate atoms preserves valuable discoveries. Otherwise, the completeness and accuracy gains cannot be interpreted confidently.

Questions for authors
  1. What analytical capability is enabled specifically by the proposed graph and composition operators, compared with a graph-free composer given the same atoms, provenance, and budget?
  2. Can the authors report a claim-level audit separating correct atomic evidence from correctly supported composite relationships? How are causal hypotheses distinguished from verified factual conclusions in the output and evaluation?
  3. What exact table/task-level split separates judge training and threshold calibration from benchmark testing, and how well does the filtering stage retain important findings on held-out data?
Reviewer_NuNzOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ComInsight, a framework for table-to-report generation that systematically discovers Atomic Insights, organizes them into a multi-relational graph, and synthesizes higher-level Composite Insights. Experiments on three benchmarks demonstrate improvements over existing baselines.

Critical strengths
  • The paper is well-organized and easy to follow, with a clear motivation and an intuitive explanation of the proposed framework.
  • The method demonstrates consistent improvements across three benchmarks, suggesting the effectiveness of the overall framework.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Overstated novelty of the problem formulation. The paper presents the formalization of Composite Insight discovery as a key contribution (§1, §3). However, the underlying challenge of synthesizing higher-level conclusions from evidence across multiple tables has already been explored in prior work. In particular, MT-RAIG [1] studies multi-table insight generation, while MMQA [2] investigates multi-table multi-hop reasoning (Neither of these closely related works is cited or discussed in the paper.). Although ComInsight introduces its own formulation and taxonomy, it does not sufficiently clarify how this framing differs from these established research settings.
  2. Limited methodological novelty. The core idea of organizing individual evidence units through explicit relationships and synthesizing them into higher-level conclusions has been widely explored in both graph-based reasoning approaches and table-oriented insight generation. For example, GraphRAG [3] and DualGraph [4] leverage graph-structured evidence for information synthesis, while Pérez et al. [5] explore SQL-based insight generation from multi-table databases. ComInsight primarily combines these established ideas through predefined relational structures, community detection, and LLM-based composition, without demonstrating a sufficiently distinct methodological contribution.
  3. Insufficient evaluation of composite insight discovery. The central claim is that ComInsight discovers novel, higher-order insights by integrating evidence across tables and dimensions. However, the experiments (§5.2, Table 1, Figures 4–5) primarily measure overall insight and report quality, without directly evaluating whether the generated conclusions involve genuinely novel, multi-evidence reasoning. A more targeted evaluation of composite insight correctness, novelty, and cross-table evidence coverage is needed to substantiate the claimed advantage over existing approaches.
  4. Lack of efficiency and scalability analysis. ComInsight relies on systematic enumeration of predefined analytical patterns (§4.1), which may become increasingly expensive as the number of tables, attributes, and candidate insights grows. Although §5.3.1 reports an average runtime of 102.3 seconds, the paper does not evaluate scalability with database complexity or compare performance under matched computational budgets.

[1] Seo et al., MT-RAIG: Novel Benchmark and Evaluation Framework for Retrieval-Augmented Insight Generation over Multiple Tables, ACL 2025.

[2] Wu et al., MMQA: Evaluating LLMs with Multi-Table Multi-Hop Complex Questions, ICLR 2025.

[3] Edge et al., From Local to Global: A Graph RAG Approach to Query-Focused Summarization, arXiv 2024.

[4] Shi et al., A Tale of Two Graphs: Separating Knowledge Exploration from Outline Structure for Open-Ended Deep Research, ICML 2026.

[5] Pérez et al., An LLM-Based Approach for Insight Generation in Data Analysis, NAACL 2025.

Questions for authors

See the weakness section

Reviewer_cxhsOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper tries to address the potential for LLM-based data analysis agents to “latch on” to the first discovered insight instead of first thoroughly exploring the breadth of the available data. They propose ComInsight, a table-to-report generator that uses predefined query templates and filters them based on statistical significance and semantic “interestingness” before filtering them into a graph. These relationships are then used to construct higher-order “composite insights” which are then incorporated into reports. Main claims are verifiability through executable SQL and evidence provenance. These claims are validated through benchmarks on InsightBench/DDR-Bench/T2R-Bench against LLM and agent baselines, and ablation experiments support the contribution of the three major pipeline stages.

Critical strengths

This is a potentially useful approach to systematic analytical exploration and by its construction helps illustrate the pitfalls of unstructured data exploration. Identify atomic insights as a separate step before composing them is a logical way to improve exploration depth, and this appears to be backed up in experiments. The structured intermediate representations are also potentially a useful foundation for future systems with more interpretability.

Evidence provenance that works across multiple benchmarks. This is a useful design choice that appears to be agnostic to the exact tabular data format and would allow a user to confirm which part of a dataset were explored as well as tracing the path of reasoning from data -> atomic claims -> LLM synthesis. This appears to improve performance on all tested datasets in the presented ablations.

Critical weaknesses

The central claim of full verifiability is not sufficiently supported. Although atomic insights are linked to executable SQL queries, this establishes only the reproducibility of the underlying computation/query rather than verifying the actual correctness of the resulting claim. The agent could be provided with a true numerical statement (e.g. mean_sleep_time = 7.2 h) but synthesize it into an incorrect claim (e.g. the population barely sleeps at all). This is a made up example, but hopefully illustrative. Appendix B does distinguish between directly vs indirectly verified composites, but it doesn’t specify a systematic mechanism for checking if the conclusions follow from these observations and confidence calculations don’t seem to incorporate the direct vs indirect verification distinction. The paper does refer to causal composites as hypotheses rather than ground truth facts, but this is inherently at odds with broader claims of causal verification and full verifiability. This matters because verifiability is central to the paper’s stated contribution.

Experiments are insufficient to substantiate and isolate the impact of the proposed contribution. The interestingness filter is calibrated using training instances drawn from the same benchmarks used for evaluation. While the authors state the training instances are excluded from testing, these instances still likely have the same overall distribution and features as the test set entries. This matters, since in the real world, an agent would not necessarily have a large, fully-known set to calibrate thresholds and interestingness on. It is therefore difficult to assess how well this actually generalizes.

The ablation removing the Composite Insight Generation reports the exact same score as the GPT-5.5 baseline (64.61%, Table 2, figure 5). This ablation should still benefit from the systematically generated atomic insights, making the identical results relative to the GPT-5.5 baseline surprising and calling into question the actual mechanisms at play here. With this in mind, the score improvements in Table 1 suggest that perhaps ComInsight merely produces format(s) that are more amenable to the LLM judge as opposed to truly identifying better/more truthful/more foundational insights. We really need to see information such as how many distinct findings are there, what fraction of composite conclusions are actually supported by their constituent evidence, how many dataset dimensions contribute to conclusions, and some sort of analysis of if variations in input data results in truly different types of findings (e.g. is ComInsight simply always analyzing a few specific variables for each dataset that happen to be highly rated).

Questions for authors

What mechanism verifies that the natural-language conclusion of a composite insight follows logically from its constituent SQL results? In particular, how is this done for indirectly verified composites?

Why does “w/o composite insight generation (Simple LLM Concatenation) ” in Table 2 achieve the exact same score (64.61%) as the standalone GPT-5.5 baseline in the figure? Is the baseline actually the model baseline or is the llm concatenation configuration used as the baseline in the figures? This matters because GPT-5.5 is also the model used in ComInsight.

The linked repository appears to omit several components, such as the causal verification pipeline, community-based composite generation procedure, and crucially, prompts used for ablations and baselines. Can these implementation and evaluation artifacts used to produce the benchmark results be released? These seem to be the key pieces needed to verify the core contribution and claims of the work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.