- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Planned Test-Time Scaling (PTTS), a framework that improves inference-time reasoning by coordinating multiple solution attempts through a planner-executor architecture. Instead of independently sampling solutions, PTTS jointly generates diverse solution outlines and uses a fixed reasoning model to execute each outline. The authors introduce two variants: PTTS-ZS, which relies on zero-shot planning, and PTTS-RL, which optimizes the planner using GRPO with a pass@k reward. The paper also provides theoretical analyses of reasoning-mode coverage and evaluates the proposed approach on five mathematical reasoning benchmarks using Qwen3-1.7B and Qwen3-4B models.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed planner-executor decomposition provides a straightforward way to introduce structured diversity into test-time scaling without modifying the underlying reasoning model. The ability to use a relatively small planner with a stronger executor is particularly appealing from a practical perspective.
-
The experiments demonstrate improvements over repeated sampling across multiple mathematical reasoning benchmarks. The ablations on branching factors, truncated execution, and planner-executor configurations provide useful insights into the behavior of the proposed framework.
Critical weaknesses
-
the method uses a branching factor of only four and independently repeats the planning procedure for larger budgets. Consequently, the experiments do not demonstrate joint coordination across all 64 reasoning attempts, despite the broader motivation of coordinated test-time scaling. The computational efficiency claims are also insufficiently substantiated, as the additional planning overhead is not clearly accounted for in the comparison against repeated sampling.
-
The central idea of generating diverse solution plans to guide multiple reasoning attempts is closely related to existing methods such as Guided Sampling and other plan-based exploration approaches. The main distinction appears to be the joint generation of outlines and the use of GRPO to optimize the planner. However, the current experiments do not convincingly isolate the benefits of these individual components. In particular, the paper lacks a comparison against a planner trained with conventional per-branch or average-accuracy rewards under the same training budget. Without such a baseline, it remains unclear whether the improvements of PTTS-RL primarily originate from the proposed joint pass@k objective or simply from additional reinforcement learning.
-
the analysis of useful diversity is not entirely convincing. The proposed metric normalizes the number of distinct successful reasoning clusters by the total number of correct responses, making it sensitive to the number of successful samples. Therefore, a higher value does not necessarily demonstrate better coverage of complementary successful reasoning strategies. The reliance on LLM-based clustering without further validation also makes the interpretation of these results less conclusive.
Questions for authors
Could the authors compare PTTS-RL against a planner trained using conventional GRPO with per-branch accuracy or average correctness as the reward, while keeping the planner architecture, executor, training data, and computational budget identical? This comparison would help establish whether the proposed joint pass@k objective provides a substantial benefit beyond simply training the planner.
2 comments
Dear Reviewer BSCN, thank you again for your time and feedback. We would appreciate hearing whether our responses and additional results have addressed your concerns. Please let us know if you have any remaining questions.
The main results (Figure 4 and 5) are measured with k=4, demonstrating coordination among four branches rather than all 64. The pass@64 results show that coordination within small groups of reasoning attempts still yields substantial gains at larger inference budgets.
Our ablations (Figure 7) evaluate larger k for PTTS-ZS. We further extend the experiments to k=24, 32 and 64, directly coordinating up to 64 branches, with pass@64 results averaged on AIME2024~2026 datasets as follows:
We observe that small branching factors (k=4) already yield substantial gains, with further improvements saturating around k=10~20 and declining at $k\ge$32, as zero-shot planners struggle to generate long lists of outlines. This shows that PTTS is a general algorithm that can scale to larger k to coordinate a larger number of attempts. Due to limited computational resources, we leave extending PTTS-RL to larger k for future work.
PTTS incurs negligible inference overhead when accounting for the planning stage, as shown in the table below. Planning accounts for only 1.3~2.2% of the total cost, as outlines are designed to be short, high-level reasoning strategies.
Token cost per branch, averaged across datasets:
We replot the main results (Figure 4 and 5) with inference cost measured by total generated tokens (planner + executor) at here and here. The overall trend remains unchanged: with matched inference budget, PTTS-RL consistently performs the best, followed by PTTS-ZS.
We add a baseline where the planner generates a single outline for the executor and is trained with a pass@1 reward. We train the planner from Qwen3-1.7B-Base and use Qwen3-1.7B as the executor, keeping all other training configurations unchanged.
The pass@1-trained planner achieves an average pass@64 of 60.2 across five benchmarks, outperforming PTTS-ZS (58.8) but falling short of PTTS-RL (62.2). Full results are shown at here. These results demonstrate that PTTS-RL's gains stem not only from planner training but also from optimizing the joint pass@k objective.
Useful diversity measures whether increased diversity contributes to successful reasoning rather than merely producing more distinct but incorrect solutions. We thus count distinct reasoning clusters only among correct responses. However, as the reviewer notes, this raw count is sensitive to the number of correct responses. To address this sensitivity, we normalize by the total number of correct responses, measuring the proportion of distinct successful reasoning paths rather than their absolute count.
We further validate the two stages of the LLM-based diversity analysis pipeline, concept extraction and concept clustering, against human annotations on AIME2024~2026 outputs. Concept extraction achieves 93.3% agreement with human annotations across 300 responses, while concept clustering achieves 81.1% agreement across 60 groups of 64 responses, supporting the reliability of the pipeline.