- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This is mainly a data-centric approach for 3D-aware image editing. The authors want to turn existing real-world multi-view videos into useful editing pairs, and use these pairs to adapt a pretrained editor. The final output is still an edited 2D image. So the main motivation seems to be making geometric editing easier to train at scale. The main contribution is the training pair construction. They put the source foreground onto the completed target-view background, while keeping the real target image as supervision. And This approach can be easily scaled up.
Critical strengths
-
There is some useful evidence here. The real-versus-UE comparison supports the proposed data pipeline as a whole, and increasing the training set from 10k to 40k improves performance. I would not say the data construction is completely unvalidated.
-
The method gives promising rotation and translation results against the evaluated baselines, and the scaling examples also look reasonable, although scaling is mainly evaluated qualitatively. The category-disjoint rotation test and the fixed-step data-scaling study are positive points.
-
The overall formulation is relatively simple, and using a pretrained model with lightweight adaptation seems practical. It may also be adaptable to newer backbones, but that is a possibility rather than something demonstrated in this paper. The writing is generally organized and easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
-
Compared with pipelines involving mesh reconstruction, rendering and harmonization, this could reduce some preprocessing steps and avoid errors in synthesized targets. But I did not find a direct comparison that clearly shows the advantage over closely related approaches such as Ctrl&Shift, 3D-Fixup or ObjectMover (Already mentioned in main paper but not compared).
-
Current ablations mostly remove geometry conditioning or the reference image. They do not directly isolate the main data-construction idea. Another important detail from the supplementary code(this is pointed out by LLM tools): the actual base model is Wan2.1-VACE-14B, with LoRA on the VACE branch. Comparing against VACE-1.3B does not really convince me in ablation part. The paper does not establish a clear cost advantage over previous methods. Data preparation cost and inference latency are still missing.
-
Learning editing from videos, keeping real frames as targets, and separating object changes from background/camera changes all have related precedents, especially in Magic Fixup, 3D-Fixup and BlenderFusion. The particular combination here may still be useful. But the architectural novelty looks limited, and the main additional contribution seems to be a simpler data pipeline. With the current evidence, it reads somewhat more like a practical pipeline report.
-
(Minor) In Figure 2, the x-axis already uses labels like “10k” and “40k”, while the axis title also says “×1k”. This looks redundant and should be fixed. The appendix contents also omit Section D and its subsections.
Questions for authors
-
Where the improvement comes from? (scene alignment/real target images/the object/viewpoint coverage/pretrained model ...)
-
It would help to explain exactly what is improved comparing with previous work: data quality(already done part of), preparation cost, downstream model performance, or some combination of these.
-
A VACE-14B baseline and a controlled comparison using the same backbone would be quite important.