- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the instability of learnable spectral graph filters in collaborative filtering and attributes it to the low-frequency bias of conventional recommendation objectives. To address this issue, ASPIRE combines pre-filter normalization with a bi-level optimization framework to learn adaptive polynomial graph filters. Experiments across different graph settings and LLM-assisted recommendation tasks demonstrate improved training stability and competitive recommendation performance.
Critical strengths
- The theoretical analysis of low-frequency explosion provides useful insights into the instability of learnable graph filters under conventional recommendation objectives.
- The experiments cover diverse graph structures, filter initializations, and LLM-assisted recommendation settings, providing relatively comprehensive empirical evidence.
Critical weaknesses
- ASPIRE uses an additional 5% of observed interactions from the validation set to update filter parameters, whereas conventional baselines generally reserve validation data for model selection. I am concerned that this difference in supervision budgets may affect the fairness of the comparison, and the paper should further clarify potential information leakage and its impact on the reported performance gains.
- Although the paper compares ASPIRE with Naive-Learnable and handcrafted filters, the contributions of the learnable polynomial filter and the validation-guided bi-level optimization remain insufficiently disentangled. Further experiments incorporating alternative spectral filtering mechanisms, such as those used in JGCF [1] and SimGCF [2], would help assess whether the proposed optimization strategy generalizes across different filter designs.
[1] Guo et al. On manipulating signals of user-item graph: A jacobi polynomial-based graph collaborative filtering. SIGKDD'23.
[2] Liu et al. How do graph signals affect recommendation: Unveiling the mystery of low and high-frequency graph signals? SIGKDD'26.
Questions for authors
-
ASPIRE uses an additional 5% of validation interactions to update filter parameters. Could the authors clarify whether this introduces information leakage or affects the fairness of comparisons with baselines?
-
Would the proposed bi-level optimization remain effective when combined with spectral filtering mechanisms from JGCF or SimGCF? I would like to see this ablation to clarify whether the improvements mainly come from the filter design or the optimization strategy.