- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper formalizes the two roles of linear CF encoders during training (representation construction and gradient propagation to embeddings) while showing that they serve only the former role during inference. It demonstrates that reusing the training encoder for inference may not be optimal. Building on this observation, the paper proposes PEAR, a post-training method that refines user representations along two user-specific directions derived from item-side and user-side information, while keeping the learned embeddings and final item matrix fixed.
Critical strengths
[S1] The paper offers an insightful theoretical perspective on CF representation learning. Its proposition and counterexample clarify why reusing the training encoder at inference may be suboptimal, making the contribution well aligned with ICLR.
[S2] BPR, DirectAU, and SCCF are representative approaches in collaborative filtering. The paper achieves noteworthy performance improvements by applying the proposed method to these approaches. Furthermore, the paper reports results over multiple independent runs, which makes the experimental results reliable.
Critical weaknesses
[W1] The main text lacks self-containment and relies excessively on the appendix. Furthermore, the overall presentation lacks clarity, making it difficult to fully understand the paper's key ideas from the main text alone.
[W2] The theoretical analysis relies on the assumption that the encoder is fixed and linear throughout training. Although many representative collaborative filtering methods satisfy this assumption, it may limit the generalizability of the proposed approach to more diverse encoder architectures.
[W3] Although framed as "encoder adaptation", the proposed method merely adjusts user representations along two predefined directions, making the encoder adaptation narrative somewhat overstated.
[W4] Three of the four evaluation datasets are book-related, while the gains on Beauty are relatively modest. This raises the concern that the method may work well primarily in the book domain.
Questions for authors
[Q1] I believe the main text requires substantial revision for the camera-ready version. Too many essential details (including the definitions of key symbols) are deferred to the appendix, while the explanations in the main text are insufficient to provide an intuitive understanding of the proposed method. Furthermore, some symbols are presented in ways that suggest overlapping meanings despite serving distinct purposes. For instance, and play fundamentally different roles, yet their notation and presentation may cause confusion. What are the authors' thoughts on these concerns?
[Q2] The proposed method appears to modify only the user-side encoder, whereas Figure 1 seems to modify the entire encoder, including the item side. If so, could the authors explain this discrepancy and the rationale behind PEAR's design? Can Figure 1 still be considered a valid motivation for the proposed method?
[Q3] Could the authors also report Recall@k? Since Recall@k can be more important than ranking metrics in practical recommendation systems, this comparison would be valuable.
Dear Reviewer UhiQ,
Thank you again for your review. We would be grateful if you could revisit our responses and revised manuscript, including the additional comparisons and clarified scope of PEAR. Please let us know if any concerns remain—we would be happy to provide further explanations and discuss them with you.
Best regards,
The authors