- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ClimLoRA, a Dual-LoRA framework that separates fine-scale reconstruction and physical consistency optimization for climate downscaling. The method uses frequency-aware constraints for reconstruction and physical diagnostics for structural correction. Experiments on ERA5 and MPI-ESM datasets demonstrate improvements in reconstruction accuracy and physical diagnostic metrics over existing baselines. Ablation studies further support the effectiveness of the proposed components and sequential optimization strategy.
Critical strengths
This paper addresses the potential optimization interference between data reconstruction and physical constraints in global climate downscaling. It proposes a decoupled optimization strategy using separate parameter spaces, which is an interesting and relevant research direction.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient justification and analysis of the Dual-LoRA design
Although the authors experimentally demonstrate some advantages of decoupled optimization, they do not directly show whether significant gradient conflicts exist between the two learning objectives. Moreover, the current experiments do not clearly distinguish whether the performance improvements come from parameter-space decoupling or sequential training. In particular, the results do not sufficiently explain why two independent LoRA modules are necessary for optimizing different loss functions.
For example, could similar improvements be achieved by using a single LoRA module trained sequentially with and ? Alternatively, what would happen if two LoRA modules were trained jointly rather than sequentially?
I suggest including additional ablation studies, such as single-LoRA sequential training and dual-LoRA joint training. An analysis of gradient similarity or gradient conflicts between the two objectives would also provide stronger evidence for the proposed design.
- Limited evaluation of physical consistency and extreme weather events
The authors evaluate improvements in several physical diagnostics, including divergence and vorticity. However, these quantities are also directly included in the training objectives of Physics-LoRA. Therefore, the current results mainly demonstrate that Physics-LoRA can better reconstruct the physical quantities used in its training loss, rather than establishing that the predicted fields satisfy independent physical laws. I suggest including at least one physical consistency evaluation that is independent of the training losses to provide stronger evidence for the claimed physical consistency.
In addition, the Introduction highlights extreme-weather analysis as an important motivation, but the experiments mainly report overall RMSE, MB, and LFD, without specific evaluations of extreme weather events. Global average error metrics alone provide limited insight into the model's performance across different regions, climate conditions, and spatial scales, potentially masking substantial regional errors and poor reconstruction of local-scale features and extreme events.
For example, high-frequency reconstruction may smooth extreme temperatures, underestimate strong winds, or introduce errors in the spatial structures of extreme events. I suggest evaluating the model on extreme heat and strong wind events, using metrics such as extreme percentiles (P95/P99), peak errors, and spatial reconstruction accuracy.
- Limited comparisons with physics-guided downscaling methods
Physical consistency is highlighted as one of the main contributions of this paper. However, the current baselines mainly focus on general super-resolution and data-driven climate downscaling methods.
I suggest including comparisons with relevant physics-guided downscaling methods, where applicable, or implementing physics-constrained baselines using the same backbone architecture.
Such comparisons would help clarify the advantages of Dual-LoRA over existing physics-guided approaches in terms of reconstruction accuracy, physical consistency, and optimization efficiency, thereby strengthening the experimental evidence for the paper's contributions.
Questions for authors
Please see Weakness
4 comments
I appreciate the authors' efforts in addressing my concerns and providing additional experimental results. The new ablation studies, physical diagnostics, and extreme-weather evaluations strengthen the empirical evidence for ClimLoRA's effectiveness.
However, several concerns remain:
-
While the additional ablations demonstrate empirical improvements, they do not provide sufficient insights into why the Dual-LoRA design is necessary or how it actually mitigates optimization interference. The main contribution remains largely empirical rather than mechanistic.
-
The performance improvements over Single and Joint are relatively marginal for several variables. Without results from multiple random seeds or confidence intervals, it is difficult to determine whether these improvements are statistically robust.
-
Although horizontal temperature advection is excluded from the training loss, it is directly derived from the predicted wind and temperature fields. Therefore, improvements in this metric may simply result from lower prediction errors in these variables, rather than demonstrating improved physical consistency or adherence to physical laws.
Overall, I acknowledge that the rebuttal has strengthened the experimental validation of the proposed approach. However, my primary concern regarding the limited methodological novelty and mechanistic understanding remains unresolved. Therefore, I will maintain my original score.
Thank you for your comments.
1. Performance and Seed Robustness
We have added results from three independent random seeds. For MSL, the mean RMSE reduction relative to Joint is 0.552, approximately 15.35 times the larger standard deviation of the two methods. Even for U10, which shows the smallest improvement, the mean reduction of 0.0004 is approximately 3.25 times the corresponding larger standard deviation. These mean improvements exceed the reported seed-level standard deviations, supporting their reproducibility across seeds.
The gains vary across variables, with particularly clear improvements in MSL: RMSE decreases by 1.62% and 3.34% relative to Single and Joint, respectively. T2M RMSE also decreases by 1.73% relative to Single. Meanwhile, our method further reduces physical diagnostic errors while maintaining strong reconstruction performance, which is another important benefit of the design.
Furthermore, this experiment uses 4× downscaling from 1° to 0.25°. The input grid is already relatively fine, and the reconstruction baselines are strong, leaving relatively limited room for further reductions in overall RMSE. Coarser input grids would provide greater room for improvement.
| Method | U10 RMSE ↓ | V10 RMSE ↓ | T2M RMSE ↓ | MSL RMSE ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single | 0.2692 ± 0.000063 | 0.2631 ± 0.000101 | 0.3866 ± 0.000025 | 16.220 ± 0.011255 |
| Joint | 0.2681 ± 0.000123 | 0.2626 ± 0.000158 | 0.3844 ± 0.000203 | 16.509 ± 0.035960 |
| ClimLoRA | 0.2677 ± 0.000090 | 0.2599 ± 0.000261 | 0.3799 ± 0.000019 | 15.957 ± 0.035416 |
2. Temperature advection
Temperature advection depends on wind velocity, temperature gradients, and their spatial correspondence. Lower errors in individual variables therefore do not necessarily guarantee lower advection errors. Compared with FSR-LoRA, ClimLoRA with physical constraints improves both prediction accuracy and the advection diagnostic excluded from training, supporting its role in reconstructing wind–temperature coupling. Even if part of the improvement arises from more accurate wind and temperature predictions, it still represents a benefit of the physical constraints.
Thank you for your detail suggestions. Our previous presentation did not sufficiently clarify physical consistency. We clarify these points below.
We introduce physical structural constraints based on kinetic energy, divergence, and vorticity to improve downscaling accuracy and physical structural consistency.
- Our definition follows Saccardi et al. [1]: diagnostic quantities such as kinetic energy, divergence, and vorticity are used to assess how accurately predictions recover the physical structures of the reference fields.
- Regarding independent evaluation metrics, Physics-Informed Diffusion Models [2] likewise evaluates generated samples using the physical residuals constrained during training.
- Using the same physical diagnostics for training and evaluation does not, by itself, imply insufficient validation. We evaluate physical consistency on held-out test samples to assess generalization beyond the training data.
References:
[1] Saccardi et al. Assessing the Geographic Generalization and Physical Consistency of Generative Models for Climate Downscaling. NeurIPS 2025 AI for Science Workshop.
[2] Bastek, Sun, and Kochmann. Physics-Informed Diffusion Models. ICLR, 2025.
Thank you for your detailed comments. We add adapter ablations, independent physical and extreme-weather evaluations, and a physics-guided baseline comparison, and clarify the Dual-LoRA design.
Q1. Effectiveness of Sequential Dual-LoRA
We compare sequential single-LoRA training (Single), jointly trained Dual-LoRA (Joint), and sequential Dual-LoRA (ClimLoRA) under matched parameter and training budgets. ClimLoRA achieves the lowest RMSE and LFD across all variables. For V10, T2M, and MSL, ClimLoRA reduces RMSE by 1.22%, 1.73%, and 1.62% relative to Single, and by 1.03%, 1.17%, and 3.34% relative to Joint, respectively.
Single updates previously learned reconstruction parameters during the second stage, while Joint may introduce interference between objectives. These results suggest that sequential training with parameter freezing helps preserve reconstruction and reduce interference. Our focus is potential optimization interference during shared-parameter updates; we do not assume that the two objectives necessarily have strongly conflicting gradients.
Q2. Physical Consistency and Extreme Weather
Independent Physical Evaluation
We additionally evaluate the horizontal temperature advection error, A_T, which is excluded from the training loss and measures wind–temperature coupling. ClimLoRA reduces A_T by 11.93% relative to Base and 7.02% relative to FSR-LoRA, and outperforms Single, Joint, and GeoFAR. These results suggest that the physics branch improves physical structures beyond the training constraints.
Extreme Weather Evaluation
We evaluate extreme heat (T2M) and strong winds (W10 = √(U10² + V10²)) across all 1,464 six-hourly timestamps from 2020, using shared grid-point-wise P95/P99 thresholds from ground truth. Metrics include RMSE over exceedance regions, peak MAE, CSI, and FSS (5×5 neighborhood).
Compared with FSR-LoRA, ClimLoRA reduces P99 RMSE by 5.59% and 5.63% and peak MAE by 9.72% and 21.01% for T2M and W10, respectively, while achieving higher CSI and FSS. These results indicate more accurate reconstruction of the intensity, peaks, and spatial distributions of extreme heat and strong winds. Details have been added to Appendix A.5.5.
T2M
W10
Q3. Comparison with Physics-Guided Methods
We add PhyDL [1] as a physics-guided downscaling baseline. PhyDL combines physical equations with latent-force parameterization and guides prediction through physics-constrained losses. ClimLoRA achieves lower RMSE and LFD across all variables, reducing RMSE by approximately 13.0%–25.8% relative to PhyDL. This comparison supports ClimLoRA’s advantages in reconstruction accuracy and spectral recovery.
References
[1] Physics-Guided Learning of Meteorological Dynamics for Weather Downscaling and Forecasting, KDD, 2025.