- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CellBridge, a source-conditioned Schrödinger bridge framework for Cellular Morphology Perturbation Prediction (CMPP). The model generates perturbed cellular morphologies from same-plate control images through a stochastic bridge, explicitly conditioning on the observed control image at every reverse step. It further incorporates perturbation embeddings based on Morgan fingerprints or Gene2Vec, together with a structured compound–target–pathway prior, to model chemical and genetic perturbation responses.
Critical strengths
1. A well-motivated generative formulation. Cellular Morphology Perturbation Prediction (CMPP) is an important task in virtual-cell modeling. Formulating perturbation-induced morphological changes as source-conditioned Schrödinger bridge transport provides an interesting approach to modeling heterogeneous cellular responses from unpaired control and treated populations.
2. Promising empirical results across multiple benchmarks. CellBridge achieves improvements in FID, KID, and perturbation recovery on BBBC021, RxRx1, and JUMP. These results demonstrate the potential of the framework for generating perturbation-specific cellular morphologies.
Critical weaknesses
1. The claim of biologically faithful perturbation prediction is insufficiently substantiated. Despite emphasizing biologically faithful prediction in the title, the evaluation primarily relies on FID, KID, perturbation recovery, MoA classification, and DINOv2-based EffectSim. While these metrics assess image fidelity and perturbation-specific phenotypic similarity, they do not directly establish whether the generated morphological changes faithfully reflect the underlying biological mechanisms. Moreover, the structured compound–target–pathway prior on BBBC021 closely aligns with the MoA classes, and all five held-out compounds used to demonstrate novel-scaffold generalization have targets represented in training. Thus, the improvements in MoA accuracy primarily support the effectiveness of transferring known target/pathway information, rather than demonstrating that the model captures biologically faithful, mechanism-driven morphological responses. Overall, the current evidence supports knowledge-guided phenotype generation, but does not sufficiently substantiate the stronger claim of biological faithfulness.
2. The central claim of source-conditioned cellular transitions lacks direct validation. A key contribution of CellBridge is to model source-dependent morphological transitions by conditioning on the observed control image at every reverse step. However, Section 3.2 states that each treated image is randomly paired with a control image from the same plate, without any true cell-level correspondence. Under this independent endpoint coupling, the training data cannot identify the actual transition of an individual control cell under perturbation. The model may primarily exploit plate-level technical variation carried by the source image rather than learning biologically meaningful cell-specific responses.
Questions for authors
What evidence supports the claim that CellBridge generates mechanistically faithful morphological responses, beyond perturbation recovery and image-level similarity metrics?
Response to reviewers
Dear Reviewers,
Thank you again for your time and constructive feedback. We have now posted responses to all of your comments, together with the additional analyses and results. As the discussion period is drawing to a close, we would be grateful if you could take a look at our responses at your convenience and let us know whether they address your concerns, or whether any points would benefit from further clarification.