- Insufficient justification of the adaptive timestep prediction mechanism:
My biggest concern is the motivation and supervised training of the adaptive timestep mechanism, which is presented as a central contribution. The method generates training examples by sampling a timestep and producing reference and target images from a shared noisy latent. The prediction network is then supervised to match the noise magnitude associated with this sampled timestep.
The paper explains intuitively that the noise level is generally proportional to the level of semantic divergence in generation. The paper further suggests that for each edit, there is an appropriate noise level at which to corrupt the original image and continue the generation with the target prompt. An edit that modifies structure might need a high noise level, while one that modifies fine detail might need a lower noise level.
However, my concern is with how the model is trained to predict the appropriate timestep. During training, the timestep is sampled randomly, and the source and target images are then generated from the same noisy latent using different text prompts. The predictor is trained to match the noise level that was used to generate this pair. I understand the intuition: since the sampled timestep influences how different the two images can be, learning to predict it might help the model associate larger edits with higher noise levels.
The problem is that the timestep used to generate a training pair is not necessarily the best timestep for performing that edit. For example, an edit that only requires changing the color of an object could still be generated using a high noise level, even though a lower noise level might be more appropriate for preserving the original image. Similarly, an edit that requires a substantial structural change could be generated using a noise level that is too low. In both cases, the predictor is supervised to match the sampled timestep, even though we don't know whether that timestep is appropriate for the edit.
While I understand why this might work as an approximation, I don't think the paper sufficiently explains why learning to predict the timestep used to generate a training pair should lead the model to select an appropriate timestep during inference. Even if the predictor learns to estimate the generating timestep accurately, it is not clear why that estimate should be close to the best timestep for performing the edit.
Figure 6 does show the expected relationship between the predicted noise level and the amount of semantic change required by the edit, which is encouraging. However, I don't think this is enough to validate the supervision strategy. It shows that the model has learned to associate larger edits with higher noise levels, but does not establish whether this supervision actually improves editing performance. I would like to see a stronger justification for why this training strategy should lead to the desired behavior. Additionally, there are critical ablation experiments that are missing. What would happen if we omitted the timestep supervision entirely? Would the predictor network learn on its own the optimal noise level for each edit, or would the training collapse? A comparison with a fixed-timestep baseline would also help establish whether the adaptive timestep mechanism is actually contributing to the reported improvements.
Moreover, the sensitivity to the timestep-sampling distribution is not studied. Since the training target depends directly on the sampled timestep, the choice of sampling distribution could significantly affect the learned behavior. For example, perhaps most edits require moderate noise levels, and therefore a logit-normal distribution that focuses more mass around intermediate timesteps would lead to a better approximation of the optimal timestep for each edit.
I consider these missing controls particularly important because they concern the central mechanism of the proposed method. The ablations provided on the mask generation method and distribution matching loss are secondary.
Bottom line: I would like to see two things:
a. An ablation removing the timestep supervision loss, to establish whether this supervision is actually necessary for the method to work. A fixed-timestep baseline would also be valuable for showing whether adapting the timestep actually helps.
b. A stronger justification for why supervising the randomly sampled timestep should lead the model to select a timestep suitable for the required edit.
Without these, I don't think the paper sufficiently justifies one of its central contributions.
- Missing relevant prior work and incomplete comparisons
ChordEdit (CVPR 2026 - feb 2026) also addresses one-step text-guided image editing and evaluates with SD-Turbo, making it an especially relevant method for comparison. I would like to see a comparison with ChordEdit, or at least an explanation of why it was not included.
- Insufficient reporting of the user study
The user study involves only 13 participants. I would like to see the study extended to include more participants. Additionally, there is little to no information about the study itself beyond stating that participants were asked to select the best image among five outputs. The authors should provide the number of evaluated editing examples, how the examples were selected, and a representative subset of the questions or editing examples.
Official Comment to Rebuttal Response
I thank the authors for providing the response. My main concerns about novelty and technical contributions have not been well addressed. Specifically, the rationale of predicting a noisy latents share the same idea with SwiftEdit with minor adjustment of predicting a noisy latent at particular time-step. However, there is no theoretical justification or empirical analysis to show that the inverted noise can match well with the target given that the network receives no information that reveals about the timestep (source latent, mask, and target prompt).
Also claiming one-step editing again is incorrect as the editing process is fundamentally multi-step denoising starting at a particular noisy latent timestep on the sampling trajectory.
In summary, the presentation and notation is minor and fixable; the author did well in actively refining and updating the manuscript. However, my biggest concern is still the paper's soundness and its key contribution in the context of one-step image editing. Hence, I maintain my original score as Clear rejection. I hope my feedback and comments would be useful for the authors to further improve the clarity as well as paper's soundness for future submission.
Best Regards,
Reviewer Gq3Y.