- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tries to address the issues of excessive smoothing of intratumoral heterogeneity and the tendency for false-positive enhancement in normal tissues during multi-phase breast DCE-MRI synthesis. To tackle these challenges, a frequency-decoupling approach for DCE-MRI is proposed; specifically, a progressive 3D network architecture is constructed, and the method is validated through downstream clinical tasks.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
This paper is highly engineering-oriented and targets specific clinical problems, which is a strength; however, the specific clinical issues need to be clearly defined and elucidated using corresponding clinical data, and potential ethical risks should be addressed. I also have reservations regarding the reproducibility of the experimental results, as there are no evaluation experiments conducted specifically on public datasets. For a methodology-focused paper like those at ICLR, I would prefer to see a clearer emphasis on the advantages of the proposed method itself.
-
The proposed method appears to involve a large number of hyperparameters and pipeline components—such as those listed in the appendix—whose selection process is unclear and seems to have been meticulously tuned. I question whether the baseline methods underwent similar careful tuning, which raises concerns about the fairness of the comparison.
Questions for authors
-
Please clarify the rationale behind the parameter choices and the corresponding ablation studies; experiments on public datasets and detailed preprocessing procedures should also be provided.
-
Suggestion: The font size in Figure 1(c) is too small; it is recommended to adjust it appropriately
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the valuable feedback. We acknowledge that the current manuscript could better explain our methodological motivation and experimental details. Our key contribution lies in frequency-specific modeling of tumor enhancement, where each stage of the hierarchical architecture is designed to capture distinct scale-dependent features. We believe this provides a meaningful approach to preserving heterogeneous enhancement patterns. We appreciate the concerns regarding parameter selection, reproducibility, and experimental fairness, and will further clarify these aspects in the revised manuscript. We are grateful for the constructive suggestions, which will help us better communicate the contributions of our work.