- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents HSA, a method for quantizing embodied models using a 4 bit AWQ backbone with selected BF16 residual blocks. It combines reconstruction error with action output sensitivity and allocates residuals through a layer, channel, and block hierarchy. Experiments cover three models on LIBERO and a real robot pickup task.
Critical strengths
-
HSA recovers most of the quantization loss with little additional memory. Across three simulated models, it improves success over AWQ by 2.55 to 2.90 percentage points while preserving substantial memory savings.
-
The experiments separate residual capacity from selection quality. Comparisons with random selection, reconstruction error selection, and global selection under the same residual budget help isolate the benefit of the proposed hierarchy. The paper also clearly acknowledges that the current implementation reduces memory rather than latency.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method differs only modestly from existing quantization approaches. It retains the AWQ backbone and combines action sensitivity with hierarchical residual selection. Action sensitivity has already been explored in QVLA, but comparisons with QVLA and QuantVLA are missing, leaving the benefit of the proposed formulation insufficiently established.
-
The evidence for the specific selection strategy is limited. Under the same residual budget, HSA improves over reconstruction error selection by only 0.60 percentage points, without reported uncertainty. The real robot test includes only 20 trials per policy and no AWQ baseline, so it does not establish the practical benefit of the residual correction.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors compare HSA with QVLA and QuantVLA under matched memory budgets and quantization scopes?
-
Is the 0.60 percentage point gain over reconstruction error selection consistent across independent runs and other backbones?
-
Could the real robot evaluation include AWQ and more challenging tasks to demonstrate when the proposed correction is necessary?