- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a near-one-bit post-training quantization framework for VLA models. It allocates capacity among fixed one- and two-bit trellis reconstruction candidates using randomized response-sensitivity estimation, cross-component calibration to a common action-discrepancy scale, and budget-constrained policy-level correction. Experiments cover π0.5, OpenVLA-OFT, and CogACT on LIBERO and SIMPLER.
Critical strengths
Experiments in this paper cover diverse VLA architectures, which is good. At 1.09 BPW over executed linear weights, CARE-VLA maintains high closed-loop success across flow-based , regression-based OpenVLA-OFT, and diffusion-based CogACT.
Critical weaknesses
- Despite targeting resource-constrained robotic platforms, all speedup tests rely on a desktop RTX 4090 GPU rather than actual edge devices and lack comparisons with lightweight VLA baselines, failing to validate real-world deployment performance.
- Stage 3 introduces complex heuristic losses, CVaR penalties, and tolerance gates, yet only improves average success by 0.3% over static allocation while degrading Spatial performance.
Questions for authors
- Since CARE-VLA targets resource-constrained robotic platforms, can you provide latency and memory evaluations on actual edge devices rather than a desktop RTX 4090 GPU, and compare the model against natively lightweight VLA baselines under comparable resource budgets?
- Given that Policy-Level Correction relies on complex heuristic losses and multiple tolerance gates for only a 0.3% average gain on (91.1% to 91.4%) while degrading Spatial performance (97.6% to 96.8%), what are its exact closed-loop gains over static allocation on OpenVLA-OFT and CogACT to justify this complexity?
- CARE-VLA slightly outperforms HB-VLA on for LIBERO-Long but falls behind HB-VLA by 9.6 percentage points on OpenVLA-OFT for LIBERO-Long. What causes this significant degradation on long-horizon tasks under a direct action-regression architecture?
Invitation to Discuss Any Remaining Concerns
Dear Reviewer 81Yw,
Thank you again for taking the time to read our rebuttal and for engaging thoughtfully with our responses. We deeply appreciate your feedback and the opportunity to address your concerns.
If there are any remaining concerns, uncertainties, or points you'd like to further discuss, we would be more than happy to engage in additional discussion during the author–reviewer discussion phase.
We sincerely hope to have the opportunity to clarify any aspects that may still be unresolved. Your feedback is valuable to us.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards, The authors