- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the Base–New Trade-off in vision-language prompt learning and attributes it to the limitations of using a single global prompt to represent heterogeneous class semantics. The authors propose Latent Domain Prompt (LDP), which clusters frozen class-text representations into semantic anchors and synthesizes class-adaptive prompts through affinity-weighted combinations of learnable domain bases. A validation-based procedure selects the number of latent domains. The paper also presents theoretical approximation-error analyses and evaluates LDP as a plug-in extension to CoOp, MaPLe, PromptSRC, and MMRL++ across base-to-new, cross-dataset, and cross-domain generalization benchmarks.
Critical strengths
S1. Simple and modular design. LDP introduces class-adaptive prompting through semantic anchors and affinity-weighted domain bases without requiring novel-class images. Its modularity facilitates integration with existing prompt-learning frameworks.
S2. Broad empirical evaluation. The paper evaluates four prompt-learning baselines across 15 datasets and three generalization settings. Positive aggregate improvements are observed, particularly for CoOp.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Limited gains on stronger baselines and insufficient experimental validation. As a plug-in method, LDP achieves only +0.54, +0.75, and +0.34 H improvements over MaPLe, PromptSRC, and MMRL++, respectively. The integrated baselines do not include methods newer than 2025, despite relevant 2026 advances such as Promise (ICLR), ManiPT, and NeRP (ICML). Although several 2026 methods are included as reference results, the paper lacks matched comparisons with recent strong approaches, paired uncertainty estimates, and computational overhead analysis. Moreover, Table 4 reports LDP results that differ from Table 1 even under the stated default temperature, without explaining the experimental differences.
W2. Insufficient evidence for the proposed semantic mechanism and theoretical interpretation. The cross-dataset anchor construction and validation-based selection of (K) are not sufficiently specified. Existing ablations do not isolate semantic decomposition from additional prompt capacity or generic routing. The claimed second-order geometric advantage depends on Assumption 4, which is not implied by the proposed affinities or empirically verified. Furthermore, the approximation bounds are not connected to classification performance, and Figures 1 and 5 do not provide sufficiently controlled evidence of semantic preservation.
Questions for authors
Q1. Transfer protocol. How are anchors and (K) determined in cross-dataset evaluation? Are target class vocabularies or validation samples involved? How is the validation loss in Eq. (13) computed for ImageNet, whose validation split is marked N/A in Table 5?
Q2. Recent methods. Why are the plug-in experiments restricted to baselines no newer than 2025? Can the authors provide matched comparisons with recent approaches such as Promise, ManiPT, or NeRP, where applicable? How does LDP differ substantively from TAC (CVPR 2025)?
Q3. Practical significance. Given the +0.34 H gain over MMRL++, can the authors report paired confidence intervals, trainable parameter counts, training/search costs, and inference overhead to establish whether the improvement justifies the additional complexity?
Q4. Contribution attribution. How does LDP compare with parameter-matched global prompts, random/uniform routing, and simple learned gating? Why are the routing and (K) ablations not extended to MMRL++, the strongest integrated baseline?
Q5. Theoretical relevance. Can the authors empirically validate Assumption 4 across different anchor resolutions and establish a connection between the approximation bounds and classification performance?
Q6. Geometric evidence. Can Figures 1 and 5 be evaluated using consistent class sets, centroid definitions, ordering, and distance scales? Do quantitative neighborhood-preservation metrics support the claimed reduction in semantic distortion?
Q7. Result consistency. Table 1 reports LDP H scores of 77.73, 78.89, and 80.01 for CoOp, MaPLe, and PromptSRC, whereas Table 4 reports 76.26, 78.41, and 79.91 at the stated default (\lambda=0.1). Since the original baseline scores match exactly across the two tables, what experimental differences explain these discrepancies? Was (K), the training protocol, or another setting changed?