- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes LSP, a coarse-to-refined latent framework for seismic forward modeling. It uses an attention-guided sine–cosine residual module to refine predicted seismic responses and incorporates symbolic relationships extracted from real earthquake records as training-time regularization. Experiments on OpenFWI, Marmousi, Overthrust, and GlobalTomo report improvements over U-Net, FNO, and DeepONet.
Critical strengths
Interesting use of real seismic data. Extracting waveform trends from unpaired earthquake records offers a potentially useful direction for incorporating real observations into synthetic-data-trained forward models.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient methodological justification and unclear physical interpretation. The paper assigns specific physical meanings to learned representations, such as the geological latent (z_v), coarse response latent (z_c), and multi-level velocity features (f_v^{(1)},f_v^{(2)},f_v^{(3)}), without sufficiently demonstrating that these features actually capture the claimed geological structures or propagation characteristics. The paper also does not explain how the feature extraction and coarse transport modules are implemented, which raises serious concerns about the soundness of the paper. Furthermore, the motivation for applying sine–cosine functions to latent features is unclear, since these features have no explicit correspondence to physical frequencies. The claim that this refinement specifically recovers oscillatory waveform details requires stronger empirical evidence.
-
Insufficient experimental comparisons and validation of real-data guidance. The method is compared only against standard architectures (U-Net, FNO, and DeepONet), without stronger recent or domain-specific approaches. Additionally, although removing symbolic regularization degrades performance, the paper does not establish whether the improvement comes specifically from real-data-derived relationships rather than generic waveform regularization. Comparisons against conventional physics-based constraints or synthetic-data-derived templates would be important to substantiate this contribution.
Questions for authors
-
How are the three velocity feature representations and the coarse transport module implemented? What evidence supports their claimed physical interpretations, particularly that (z_c) represents dominant arrivals and the residual captures finer waveform details?
-
Why are sine–cosine functions applied to learned latent features rather than physically meaningful frequency representations? Can the authors provide frequency-resolved analyses or comparisons with alternative refinement mechanisms?
-
Can the authors compare their symbolic regularization against standard analytical physics-based constraints or waveform statistics derived directly from synthetic data to isolate the contribution of real earthquake observations?
-
How does LSP compare against recent neural-operator or seismic forward-modeling methods beyond the three standard baselines