acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

State Flow Credit Assignment: Improving Credit Assignment with Generative Modeling

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Credit assignment is a fundamental challenge in reinforcement learning and is critical for both learning stability and policy optimality. Prior work has explored counterfactual and hindsight approaches, which typically adopt a retrospective perspective, modeling influence factors from future trajectories. As a result, the credit assigned to individual actions can be entangled with the effects of subsequent actions, making it difficult to isolate their true contributions. To address this challenge, we propose State Flow Credit Assignment (SFCA), a novel framework that integrates generative modeling into the credit assignment process. SFCA explicitly models the influence of individual actions on future states. It represents an action’s effect as the induced difference between future states and quantifies this difference to assign credit to the action. Experimental results demonstrate that SFCA leads to consistent improvements over baselines across diverse environments and achieves particularly significant gains in tasks where baseline performance plateaus.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Reinforcement Learning, Credit Assignment

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_uCheOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes State Flow Credit Assignment (SFCA), an auxiliary method added to PPO and A2C. It uses predictions of future states to construct policy-learning signals.

A deterministic encoder maps observations to latent states. A vector field is trained on consecutive latent states through flow matching: it predicts their difference along an interpolated path. Training uses Gaussian noise, a replay buffer of recent rollouts, and a periodically updated target encoder.

For each observed transition, the method predicts future latent states from the current state and its observed successor. SFCA-Adv uses predicted rewards and values to construct an auxiliary advantage. Appendix A relates this signal to an advantage decomposition under conditional distribution approximations. SFCA-Reward adds a difference of predicted future values to the reward.

Experiments compare the augmented methods with PPO and A2C on classic control, Box2D, Atari RAM, and MiniGrid tasks, averaging over five seeds. The authors report improvements on several tasks, including Kangaroo and Gopher, alongside smaller gains or regressions elsewhere. CartPole ablations examine prediction horizon, replay size, and encoder synchronization. The advantage interpretation depends on the modeling assumptions.

Critical strengths
  1. Learning state evolution to construct auxiliary policy signals is an interesting empirical direction. Both variants can be incorporated into PPO and A2C, and the evaluation covers 24 tasks across several environment families with five seeds. The reported PPO gains on Kangaroo and Gopher are substantial. The appendices include per-task results and full training curves, including cases with little improvement or lower returns.

  2. SFCA-Reward has a useful interpretation independent of the accuracy of the learned transition model. For frozen networks and consistent time indexing, the mean value predicted after m steps defines a state potential, and Eq. (17) has the standard potential-difference form. This interpretation requires the usual discount conditions; a bounded potential and consistent handling of terminal terms are sufficient. Poor predictions alone do not invalidate it. This gives the reward variant a clearer justification than the general advantage claim.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The objective in Eq. (13), without noise augmentation, does not establish the conditional rollout laws used in Appendix A.2. With an identity encoder and independent standard-normal successive states, integrating the population-optimal field from a fixed state xx returns xx. It therefore generates δx\delta_x rather than the true reset law N(0,1)\mathcal{N}(0,1), despite matching the marginals. The source-noise description in Eq. (14) and the interpolant-noise description in Algorithms 2-3 are different objectives; neither description establishes the conditional transition law required by Appendix A.2. Appendix A.2 explicitly assumes a conditional-law identity before Eq. (23). The concern is how training justifies that premise, not a contradiction of the derivation when correct rollouts are assumed. Also, a deterministic encoder alone does not ensure the latent sufficiency needed in Eq. (21). No error bound links the learned field to the claimed advantage approximation.

  2. The reward model in Section 3.1 is more general than the state-pair predictor used in Eq. (15). Consider one state, two actions with identical transitions, rewards 0 and 1, and a uniform policy. The true advantages are −1/2-1/2 and +1/2+1/2. With fixed predictors and action-independent noise, both actions give the same signal distribution because their state-pair inputs are identical. Its conditional mean must therefore have absolute error at least 1/21/2 for one action. The advantage interpretation needs a restriction on the reward function, or use of the observed reward or action in the forced branch. This does not show that the augmented PPO/A2C algorithms cannot learn: they retain a standard learning signal. It also does not refute the potential-based interpretation of SFCA-Reward.

Questions for authors
  1. Please state the assumptions behind Eqs. (21)-(23) and explain which are guaranteed by training. Please distinguish latent sufficiency and conditional-kernel assumptions from consequences of flow matching, and reconcile the two noise descriptions. Does the RL-time input advance during the repeated integrations in Algorithm 1?

  2. Does the first term in Eq. (15) use the observed reward or action in the implementation? If not, what reward assumption excludes the one-state example? For SFCA-Reward, how are terminal potentials and truncations handled?

  3. Please compare with TD-Flow (ICML 2025) and InFOM (ICLR 2026), which use flow matching to model future states for value estimation or policy learning. Their settings differ from SFCA. Also, please qualify the general criticism of HCA/CCA, which give exact identities or unbiased estimators under their stated conditions.

  4. Please clarify how the reported standard deviations are aggregated and provide results by seed. Under the default CartPole cap of 500, 499.30±18.39499.30\pm18.39 cannot describe the mean and standard deviation of five final run means. An episode-level or other aggregation may explain this. Please also specify the ODE step, Monte Carlo sample count, auxiliary-loss weights, and relative compute cost.

Reviewer_vdvAOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes State Flow Credit Assignment (SFCA). A flow-matching vector field, trained on consecutive latent states from the agent's rollouts, models how states evolve under the current policy, independently of any single action. The credit of an action ata_t is then the discrepancy between rolling this field mm steps from ztz_t and m−1m-1 steps from the observed zt+1z_{t+1}, turned either into an advantage, with a learned reward and the value function (SFCA-Adv), or into an auxiliary reward of potential-based form (SFCA-Reward). SFCA is added to PPO and A2C and evaluated on 24 environments (Classic Control and Box2D, Atari-RAM, MiniGrid) over 5 seeds.

Critical strengths

Using flow matching is a very interesting perspective on credit assignment and should be explored. Doing this in a way that the credit of a state is the difference between two terms, one depending on the state-action and one on the state only, mirrors the advantage but into a latent space different than the state and state-action values is very interesting.

Critical weaknesses

Despite the interesting idea, the study presents major weaknesses.

Major

1. Methods

  • It is not clear how the agent is trained. Fig. 2 marks the encoders as frozen and Section 4.1 starts from "a fixed policy π" (l. 252), yet Alg. 2–3 initialise all parameters randomly and train online? Please describe what is trained, when, on which data and with which loss, and whether the flow loss also trains the shared encoder.
  • SFCA appears to use the same number of environment steps as PPO (Fig. 5, Fig. 9), but more passes over the data (a replay of the last 16–32 rollouts, l. 396–398), more parameters (the SFVF, a reward network and a target encoder) and more compute (two flow rollouts per transition). None of this is reported or matched against the baselines.

2. Claims

  • More accurate credit. "These gains primarily arise from its ability to infer more accurate credit for individual actions from interaction data" (l. 448–449). Every experiment reports returns only; credit is never measured, and no experiments verifies the accuracy of the quantity where the ground truth is known.
  • Generative modelling. "As a credit assignment method based on generative modeling, SFCA achieves performance improvements across a wide range of environments" (l. 447). What makes a credit assignment method generative is not defined, and it is not clear what's the advantage in credit assignment of using a generative method or no.
  • Future dependence as a limitation. The paper argues that future-dependent methods entangle the effect of an action with that of subsequent actions (l. 47–50). Every credit assignment method is theoretically future-dependent, because the value of a state or a state-action depends on the policy: I can make a great action, but if the policy acts terribly after it, the contribution of that action is not that great anymore. Most deep RL methods just do not model this dependency explicitly. Future-dependent methods address it by conditioning on samples of the policy (Harutyunyan et al., 2019); parameter-based methods by conditioning on the policy parameters themselves (Faccio et al., 2021). This is an advantage, not a problem (Pignatelli et al., 2024). Finally, CCA's point is exactly this: to disentangle the effects of the next immediate action from the future environment transitions and policy.
  • The state flow. "We assume that the transformation of the environment state is governed by an unknown function g(s, a)" (l. 51–52). How is this different from the state transition function, and how is f(s) different from its marginal over the policy's actions? What does the state flow add?

3. Evidence

  • Many baselines are missing. The paper states the limits of future-dependent methods (l. 47–50) and of distributional ones (l. 42–44), but compares against neither. I would like to see at least HCA, CCA and a distributional method, ideally in a setting where the entanglement the paper attributes to future-dependent methods can be seen.
  • GAE is criticised for not capturing causal structure (l. 124–125), but its λ is never tuned: PPO uses the RL Zoo values and A2C uses λ = 1.0 (Table 1).
  • Fig. 5 shows Gopher and Kangaroo, where SFCA does better than PPO, to support "particularly significant gains in tasks where baseline performance plateaus" (l. 22–23). However, most other results in the appendix (Fig. 9–13, Tables 2–4) show no advantage of SFCA over its baseline: of the 96 comparisons in Tables 2–4, only 3 differ by more than two standard errors (Kangaroo, both PPO variants; Pong, A2C-SFCA-Adv). For this reason, the results seem cherry-picked.
  • The main results should be in the main text: it shows only an aggregate (Fig. 4) and two environments (Fig. 5).
  • The normalised performance in Fig. 4 is unclear: the formula is defined for two methods but three bars are plotted, and each environment is normalised to the range of the methods being compared only (l. 430–431).

Minor

4. Writing

  • The paper is hard to read, as the flow is not very intuitive.
  • Parts of the related work are out of scope: temporal credit assignment and flow-based modelling belong to the preliminaries.
  • The related work should discuss distributional methods.

5. Inconsistencies and missing details

  • App. B finds prediction horizons of 2–8 better than 1 or 10 (l. 732–734), but Table 1 uses m=10m = 10 for CartPole, Acrobot and Pendulum, and m=1m = 1 for all Atari-RAM games.
  • How the three SFCA hyperparameters were chosen per environment, whether the baselines use the same core values, how the two policy losses of SFCA-Adv are combined, Δτ\Delta\tau, network sizes and the compute overhead are not reported.
  • HER is described as assuming that "actions within a trajectory lead to the final outcome" (l. 131–133); HER relabels goals.

References

  • Faccio, F., Kirsch, L., and Schmidhuber, J. Parameter-based value functions. In Proc. of ICLR, 2021.
  • Harutyunyan, A., et al. Hindsight credit assignment. In Proc. of NeurIPS, 2019.
  • Mesnard, T., Weber, T., Viola, F., Thakoor, S., Saade, A., Harutyunyan, A., Dabney, W., Stepleton, T., Heess, N., Guez, A., Moulines, E., Hutter, M., Buesing, L., and Munos, R. Counterfactual credit assignment in model-free reinforcement learning. In Proc. of ICML, 2021.
  • Pignatelli, E., Ferret, J., Geist, M., Mesnard, T., van Hasselt, H., and Toni, L. A survey of temporal credit assignment in deep reinforcement learning. Trans. Mach. Learn. Res., 2024.
Questions for authors

Additionally to the questions in the weaknesses section:

  • Why these 24 environments, and why are only Gopher and Kangaroo shown individually in the main text?
  • In an environment with known ground-truth credit, how does the error of AtSFA^{SF}_t compare with GAE's, and does SFCA's improvement over GAE grow with the delay between action and reward?
  • Is ± in Tables 2–4 the standard deviation across seeds, or across episodes and seeds? Can you report confidence intervals or interquartile means over more seeds?
  • Why does Table 1 use m=10m = 10 and m=1m = 1 when App. B finds both worse than 2–8?
  • Do SFCA and PPO have a comparable number of parameters? SFCA adds the SFVF, a reward network and a target encoder; if the counts are not matched, the gains may come from the extra capacity.
  • Does SFCA use more compute than the baselines? The paper reports only a maximum of 14 hours per run (l. 755), with no figure for PPO or A2C.
  • SFCA's three extra hyperparameters are set per environment (Table 1): how were they chosen, with what budget, and was GAE's λ tuned with a comparable budget for the baselines?
Reviewer_UopaOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes State Flow Credit Assignment (SFCA), a framework that uses flow-based generative modeling to improve temporal credit assignment in reinforcement learning. The method learns an action-independent state flow vector field in latent space and estimates the contribution of individual actions through discrepancies between generated future states. Two variants are introduced: SFCA-Adv, which constructs an approximate advantage signal, and SFCA-Reward, which introduces an auxiliary reward based on potential-based reward shaping.

Critical strengths
  • Temporal credit assignment is a fundamental challenge in reinforcement learning. Exploring generative modeling as a mechanism for estimating action contributions is an interesting research direction.
  • The proposed framework can be incorporated into both PPO and A2C through advantage estimation or reward shaping, demonstrating some flexibility across policy optimization methods.
  • SFCA achieves substantial performance improvements in certain Atari environments, particularly Gopher and Kangaroo. The experiments cover multiple environment categories and report results across five random seeds.
Critical weaknesses
  • The flow-matching objective primarily models transformations between distributions of consecutive latent states. However, the derivation in Appendix A.2 assumes that the learned flow approximates the conditional transition distribution (P(zt+1∣zt)P(z_{t+1}\mid z_t)), without establishing the necessary conditions. Furthermore, the deterministic encoder is not guaranteed to preserve the Markov property or provide a sufficient state representation. These assumptions are central to the claimed advantage approximation but remain insufficiently justified.
  • The approximation of the generalized advantage function relies on assumptions about latent transition distributions that are not independently validated. Moreover, the claimed optimal-policy invariance of SFCA-Reward follows from potential-based reward shaping only under appropriate conditions. Since the flow model and value function are updated during training, the applicability of this guarantee to the full online algorithm should be clarified.
  • Although SFCA achieves substantial gains on selected tasks, it underperforms the original algorithms in several environments. For example, both PPO-SFCA variants perform worse than PPO on Breakout and FourRooms, while improvements on several other tasks are relatively small compared with the reported standard deviations. Therefore, the claim of consistent improvements across diverse environments appears overstated.
  • The current ablations focus primarily on synchronization frequency, prediction horizon, and replay-buffer size, and are conducted only on CartPole. They do not demonstrate whether flow matching provides advantages over simpler dynamics prediction or value-based reward shaping. Moreover, the main comparisons are limited to PPO and A2C without the proposed modifications. Direct comparisons with alternative credit assignment approaches and compute-matched baselines are needed.
Questions for authors
  1. Under what assumptions does the learned state flow approximate the action-marginalized conditional transition distribution rather than only the marginal state distribution transformation?

  2. Can the authors evaluate SFCA's advantage estimates against ground-truth advantages in small MDPs with known transition dynamics?

  3. Does the optimal-policy invariance claim remain valid when the learned potential function changes during online training?

  4. How does the method distinguish the causal effect of an action from environmental randomness and flow-model approximation errors?

  5. How does SFCA compare with simpler learned dynamics models, standard potential-based shaping, and existing credit assignment methods under matched computational budgets?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.