acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

ReEnvision: Future-Guided Selective Action Repair for Long-Horizon Manipulation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Long-horizon robotic manipulation requires robust execution over sequences of interdependent actions. Existing methods typically handle execution deviations by replanning the remaining action chunk or correcting actions step by step as new observations arrive. However, a local deviation may affect only a few actions under distribution shift, yet replanning regenerates the entire chunk from an unfamiliar state, potentially introducing errors into otherwise valid actions. Step-wise correction may react too late, as it does not explicitly anticipate how the deviation affects subsequent actions. We propose ReEnvision, a future-guided selective action repair framework that updates a joint future-action belief using execution feedback. It then learns how the resulting belief revision affects each unexecuted action. The resulting belief revision enables selective repair of only the affected actions within a cached action chunk, preserving valid actions and reserving full replanning for severe deviations. On CALVIN, L-CALVIN, and RLBench, ReEnvision achieves 86.6% 5-step success, improves 10-step success from 56% to 63%, and reaches an average success rate of 88.8%, respectively. On five real-world manipulation tasks, it achieves an average success rate of 82.8%. Controlled repair experiments further demonstrate the benefits of localizing affected actions and preserving valid ones during execution.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Robot Manipulation, Long-Horizon Planning, Action Chunking

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_iNScOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ReEnvision to improve execution error correction in long-horizon robotic manipulation. The method jointly represents the anticipated future and action intent, updates this representation based on execution feedback, and predicts which parts of the remaining action sequence are affected. The system then chooses whether to retain the actions, apply local repairs, or perform full replanning. The authors evaluate the method on CALVIN, L-CALVIN, RLBench, and real-world robotic tasks, and analyze the contributions of individual components through ablation studies and controlled experiments on repair locations.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper asks which remaining actions actually need to change after an execution deviation. Selectively repairing affected actions while preserving valid ones is a sensible approach to limiting error propagation in long-horizon manipulation. The distinction between expected belief evolution and observation-induced revision also provides a clear basis for deciding when to intervene.
  2. The gains are most apparent at longer horizons, which fits the paper’s motivation. On L-CALVIN, ReEnvision achieves 63% ten-task success compared with 56% for Long-VLA. The ablation replacing selective repair with full replanning reaches 51%, supporting the value of preserving useful actions in this setting.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The fairness of the baseline comparisons requires clarification. The gap between the reproduced and originally reported BridgeVLA results is insufficiently explained, and the evaluation settings for some baselines in Table 2 are unclear, making the reported gains difficult to assess.
  2. Validation and training details of the core method are insufficient. Direct comparisons with FFDC and A2C2 are missing, and the generation and selection of training data for the repair model are not clearly described, limiting both assessment of its contribution and reproducibility.
Questions for authors
  1. The reproduced BridgeVLA achieves a success rate of 85.7%, below the 88.2% reported in its original paper, while ReEnvision achieves 88.8%. The authors should detail the baseline reproduction settings and explain whether this 2.5 percentage-point gap arises from training configurations or other factors.
  2. Table 2 specifies the ABC→D evaluation setting. However, the entire row of Long-VLA results, including the ten-task success rate of 0.56 and average sequence length of 8.24, matches the results reported under ABCD→D in Table 8 of the original paper’s appendix. The RoboVLMs results also match that table. These settings differ in whether the training data include the target environment D, so directly comparing them may compromise fairness. The authors should verify the table caption and result sources, clarify whether these results were taken from the original papers or obtained through re-evaluation, and ensure that all methods follow the same evaluation protocol.
  3. The paper repeatedly emphasizes its advantages over FFDC and A2C2, but the experiments lack direct comparisons with these two methods.
  4. The differences between high-return and low-return action sequences are used as training targets for the repair model, but the procedures for generating and selecting these sequences are insufficiently described.
Reviewer_EogLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a future-guided selective action repair framework for long-horizon robotic manipulation. Instead of replanning entire action chunks or applying step-wise corrections, ReEnvision identifies and repairs only actions affected by execution deviations. The method constructs a joint future-action belief combining predicted visual futures and action intent, updates this belief, and estimates action-level corrections, validity, and uncertainty. A structured optimization mechanism determines whether to preserve, selectively repair, or replan cached actions. Experiments demonstrate performance improvements on CALVIN, L-CALVIN, RLBench, and five real-world manipulation tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework is well-motivated and intuitive. Selectively repairing affected actions addresses potential unnecessary modifications introduced by full replanning. Joint future-action belief modeling provides a principled representation for incorporating anticipated future evolution and action intent.
  2. The experimental evaluation is comprehensive, including benchmark comparisons, real-world experiments, and controlled studies demonstrating the importance of repair localization.
  3. Ablations demonstrate the complementary benefits of future representations, action intent, and belief revision. Controlled perturbation experiments also demonstrate adaptive intervention across different deviation severities.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Action validity is defined through the magnitude of differences between policy-generated action sequences rather than actual task success. Consequently, the reference affected-action mask may reflect policy sensitivity rather than genuinely necessary corrections.
  2. Statistical significance is not established. Improvements over certain baselines are relatively small, such as the average sequence length of 8.36 versus 8.24 on L-CALVIN in Table 2. Although results are averaged across three seeds, uncertainty estimates are not reported.
  3. Computational efficiency is non-negligible. Inference latency increases by approximately 32%; extra training is also needed. Moreover, the breakdown in Table 9 does NOT fully explain the end-to-end overhead; the entries don’t even add up.
  4. Limited robustness is demonstrated. The uncertainty target is based on distance to a heuristic threshold rather than calibrated prediction uncertainty (see Appendix B.1 and Eq. (12)). Sensitivity analysis covers selected thresholds but not all mask optimization weights. Controlled perturbation evaluations are only in simulations; real-world recovery robustness is not shown.
Questions for authors

See weaknesses.

Reviewer_xNH8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

ReEnvision proposes an intricate future-guided selective action repair framework, including a video generation model for future prediction, DP for action generation, and a combination of MLP, RSSM, and TCN to make selective adjustments to the generated actions. The work is mainly innovative in its selective repair of actions that are most affected.

ReEnvision works well on several benchmarks, such as CALVIN and L-CALVIN, and outperforms several baselines and its backbone (though it also significantly increases the latency). The real-world experiments also provide some evidence of ReEnvision's robustness in long-horizon robotic manipulation tasks. Generally, the authors offer a comprehensive evaluation and ablations to partly prove the robustness of the system and the effectiveness of the main design choices.

Critical strengths
  1. Appreciate the novel idea. The framework innovatively introduced a future-driven selective action repair framework, which selectively repairs action chunks based in their predicted validity and uncertainty through a structured mask optimiztion mechanism. This is quite different from related future-guided models.

  2. The extensive experiments on simulation benchmarks provide convincing evidence of the effectiveness of selective repair, while the real-world results offer additional, though less conclusive, support.

Critical weaknesses

The main concern is the insufficient explanation of several key training procedures. The missing details make it difficult to assess the reproductibility and soundness of the proposed repair mechanism. I would be willing to raise my raitng if the authors can clarify these issues.

Questions for authors

As mentioned above, despite the framework's good performance on various benchmarks, there remain several ambiguous points yet to be clarified. Further clarification and explanation would really help us better understand the mechanisms of the framework.

The specific definition and source of Return for A+A^+ and A−A^− are missing. A further explanation should be provided as Return is important for the TCN module. How is this info generated during training? Are the higher- and lower-return action chunks generated using the posterior and prior beliefs, respectively? If so, what justifies the assumption that actions conditioned on the posterior belief have higher returns? If not, how are the belief conditions for these paired action chunks constructed? How does the Stable Video Diffusion help to predict the future state? Is it fine-tuned on in-domain data? How are language instructions injected, and what is done to ensure that the SVD output to be physically consistent or at least semantically consistent? A minor issue: The current ablations do not fully isolate the contribution of explicit future prediction. Although the $ z_a $ -only experiment does not provide DP with future prediction directly, it is said in the paper that zaz_a is conditioned on the current observation, the base and target future representations. Therefore a comparison that replaces SVD-based future representations with current visual representations, while keeping the remaining framework as consistent as possible, would help isolate the contribution of explicit future prediction.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.