- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Referring Operation Anomaly Detection, where a normal reference video is used to detect frame-level procedural anomalies in a query video without retraining the detector for each target scenario. It presents a dataset containing 569 videos and 335,850 frames from four operation scenarios, covering wrong order, wrong placement, omitted step, and wrong component anomalies. The paper further proposes CSDM, which combines a Reference Temporal Memory, a Shared Prototype Memory, and aligned reconstruction-based anomaly scoring. Experiments evaluate the method under three leave-one-scenario-out settings and an additional packaging scenario.
Critical strengths
- The reference-conditioned formulation is an interesting idea. Using a normal demonstration to specify the expected operation allows the same detector to handle different procedures without target-specific retraining. This provides a practical direction for operation anomaly detection when abnormal training videos are difficult to collect.
- The dataset provides a useful setting for studying procedural anomalies. It contains continuous multi-step recordings from four operation scenarios and covers four types of errors: wrong order, wrong placement, omitted step, and wrong component. These annotations support the study of temporal and procedural errors that cannot always be identified from appearance alone.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited effectiveness of SPM. In Table 3, the full model improves the mean LOSO AUROC by only 0.25 points over RTM-only (91.63% vs. 91.38%) and performs slightly worse in two of the three settings. Multiple-run results or further analysis would help clarify SPM’s contribution.
- Insufficient loss ablation. The paper lacks ablation studies on the three loss terms in Eq. (4). Evaluating their individual contributions would better justify the training objective.
- Limited cross-scene generalization evaluation. The evaluation covers only four fixed-viewpoint scenarios, including three controlled tabletop settings. Experiments under more diverse viewpoints, lighting conditions, and complex industrial environments would strengthen the generalization claims.
Questions for authors
Pleas see weaknesses.