- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Causal-Diff aims to unify anomaly generation and detection in a latent diffusion model. It contrasts attention to defect and normal reference images to guide generation and produce anomaly maps, with boundary-aware mask supervision. The paper evaluates generation on MVTec, VisA, Polyp, and Floor Dirty; detection on MVTec and VisA; and synthetic-data training of downstream detectors. It reports gains over Anomagic and several detection baselines, including lower average FID on MVTec (186.93 to 53.11) and improved downstream results on multiple datasets.
Critical strengths
- Unifying anomaly generation and detection through reference-conditioned diffusion is a worthwhile direction with potential practical value.
- Experiments span industrial, medical, and indoor datasets, including downstream detection using synthetic data.
Critical weaknesses
- The attention difference in Eqs. 4–7 is not shown to estimate the causal effect defined in Eq. 1. The two attention maps use different key sets and softmax normalizations, so their difference does not isolate a causal effect. The experiments do not directly validate this mechanism.
- The experimental evidence for generation is limited: the comparison is largely against Anomagic, with too few competing methods to establish a comprehensive state-of-the-art advantage. The reported per-category FID scores are also difficult to interpret with the small number of real anomaly samples available in MVTec AD and VisA. The paper should report the real/generated sample counts and protocol, and quantify variability (e.g., repeated estimates or confidence intervals); otherwise the FID ranking may be unstable.
- Detection training uses pixel-level anomaly-mask supervision, but the training data, splits, reference-image protocol, and baseline settings are not sufficiently specified. The appendix also describes different UNet initializations for the reference and generation branches without clarifying whether their parameters are shared. These gaps prevent assessing the central claims and reproducing the comparisons.
Questions for authors
- What causal estimand do Eqs. 4–7 compute, given the different softmax key sets? If this is a heuristic attention contrast, what controlled ablation demonstrates its benefit over matched-normalization or single-reference alternatives?
- Please specify the detection training data and mask sources, train/test splits, reference-image selection, and baseline protocols. Are the reference and generation UNet parameters tied, copied, or independently updated?