- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes OSD-IRF, a diffusion-based model for unsupervised image anomaly detection. It trains an unconditional DDPM on normal image features and uses its predicted noise, with inverse residual field (IRF), to detect and localize anomalies. It has a one-step inference by evaluating the network on a scaled input. The paper also proposes selecting the inference timestep from SNR statistics of the training data. Experiments on MVTec-AD, VisA, and MPDD show competitive detection and localization performance with fast inference.
Critical strengths
- The method proposes as simple and practical inference process. A model provides detection and localization scores with one network evaluation, without additional distillation. This is useful for applications where inference speed matters.
- The results are competitive on three industrial benchmarks, with particularly strong improvements on MPDD. The ablation also shows that the method is useful. It achieves comparable or better performance than averaging 16 stochastic passes.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty of the method is weak. The paper presents the IRF as the main contribution, and it uses the standard noise as a predictor, proportional to the learned score, and its Gaussian negative log-likelihood reduces to a squared score norm. There are already a few anomaly detection methods that use score norms as anomaly scores, in image anomaly detection [1, 2], in tabular anomaly detection with single-scale DSM [3, 4]. In particular, these tabular anomaly methods are relevant because they could also be applied to pretrained vision embeddings, just like how it is done in this paper’s method. The paper does not discuss or compare against any of these methods. The paper also incorrectly states that DTE requires iterative reverse diffusion, which is false, as it predicts the timestep distribution directly in one inference pass. It is therefore unclear what the method contributes beyond its SNR selection rule and application to industrial features.
- The empirical comparison omits substantially stronger multi-class methods. As examples, Dinomaly reports image AUROC of 99.6/98.7 and pixel AP of 69.3/53.2 on MVTec-AD/VisA [5], and RAD also reports substantially stronger localization performance [6]. Backbone and resolution can influence comparisons, but these omissions do put in question the state-of-the-art claim. As briefly mentioned in the previous point, since the method works on pretrained image embeddings, comparisons with tabular anomaly detectors on the same features are also relevant.
References
-
Mahmood, A., Oliva, J., & Styner, M. (2021). Multiscale Score Matching for Out-of-Distribution Detection. ICLR.
-
Tebbe, J., & Tayyub, J. (2024). Dynamic Addition of Noise in a Diffusion Model for Anomaly Detection. CVPR Workshops, 3940–3949.
-
Livernoche, V., Zan, J., & Rabbany, R. (2026). Kurtosis-Guided Denoising Score Matching for Tabular Anomaly Detection. arXiv:2605.06955.
-
Hirth, M., Koberg, L., Jazdi, N., & Kasneci, E. (2026). Denoising without Diffusion: Fixed-Noise Denoiser Anomaly Detection in Tabular Data. ICML.
-
Guo, J., Lu, S., Zhang, W., Chen, F., Li, H., & Liao, H. (2025). Dinomaly: The Less Is More Philosophy in Multi-Class Unsupervised Anomaly Detection. CVPR, 20405–20415.
-
Zhang, X., Li, G., Henderson, P., Aragon-Camarasa, G., & Long, Z. (2026). Is Task-Specific Training Necessary for Anomaly Detection? ICML.
Questions for authors
- What is the main difference between the evaluation of IRF and the usual noise-normalized score evaluated at a clean input? What components differentiate the contribution beyond the score principle of [1] and the input construction in [2]?
- Can you compare with the baselines mentioned in the weaknesses?
- How does SNR-based timestep selection compare with a common fixed timestep across datasets? Can you also compare against a DSM model, with the same architecture, trained only at the selected noise scale, to establish whether multi-timestep training is useful?
7 comments
Response to Reviewer stgJ
W2: Comparison with Stronger Multi-Class Anomaly Detection Methods.
We thank the reviewer for highlighting these strong multi-class anomaly detection methods. We would like to clarify that, as stated in our Abstract, our primary objective is to achieve competitive anomaly detection and localization performance while substantially reducing the inference cost of diffusion-based methods. We do not claim state-of-the-art performance over all existing industrial anomaly detection methods, including discriminative and retrieval-based approaches.
(1) Comparison with Dinomaly[5]. We acknowledge the strong performance of Dinomaly and agree that including it provides a more comprehensive evaluation. Accordingly, we conduct additional experiments comparing Dinomaly and OSD-IRF on the VisA and MPDD datasets, using the same input image resolution of 256 × 256. As reported in Table R4, OSD-IRF achieves competitive performance compared with Dinomaly, further demonstrating the effectiveness of our one-step, reconstruction-free diffusion framework.
Table R4. Performance (%) comparison between Dinomaly and OSD-IRF on VisA and MPDD.
| Dataset | Method | I-AUROC ↑ | P-AUROC ↑ | P-AP ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VisA | Dinomaly | 96.70 | 98.82 | 42.90 |
| OSD-IRF (Ours) | 96.89 | 98.96 | 43.73 | |
| MPDD | Dinomaly | 94.68 | 98.53 | 52.76 |
| OSD-IRF (Ours) | 97.65 | 98.83 | 48.53 |
(2) Comparison with RAD [6]. We acknowledge that RAD achieves stronger anomaly localization performance. However, RAD follows a substantially different retrieval-based paradigm, leveraging multi-layer visual features, global semantic context, and test-sample-adaptive reference retrieval to construct spatially conditioned anomaly scores. In contrast, OSD-IRF directly derives anomaly scores from a learned diffusion response without test-time memory-bank retrieval. We recognize that RAD's multi-level and context-aware representations may contribute to its strong fine-grained anomaly localization, while such information is not fully exploited by our current framework. Incorporating complementary multi-scale or context-aware information into OSD-IRF represents a promising direction for future research.
Overall, these comparisons help clarify the scope of our contribution: OSD-IRF aims to provide an efficient diffusion-based anomaly detection framework with competitive performance, rather than outperforming all discriminative or retrieval-based methods. We will revise the experimental discussion to make this distinction explicit and include the additional comparison with Dinomaly.
Q1. Difference between IRF and conventional noise-normalized score evaluation
See W1.
Q2. Comparison with the baselines mentioned in the weaknesses
See W1 and W2.
Q3. SNR-based timestep selection and single-noise-scale DSM training
(1) SNR-based timestep selection vs. fixed timesteps. As shown in Fig. 3 of the original manuscript, detection performance is sensitive to the probing timestep, with high performance observed near logSNR = 0. Although a common fixed timestep can be used, selecting it based on detection performance would require anomalous validation data. In contrast, our SNR-guided strategy automatically identifies effective probing timesteps using only normal-data statistics.
(2) Single-noise-scale DSM vs. multi-timestep training. Following the reviewer's suggestion, we trained a single-noise-scale DSM model at , using the same architecture and noise-prediction objective as OSD-IRF. Both models use identical deterministic inference and IRF-based anomaly scoring at , differing only in their training noise scales. On MPDD, single-timestep training achieves 82.59 mAD, compared with 83.52 mAD for multi-timestep training, demonstrating its empirical benefit while retaining inference with only one network evaluation.
References
- Mahmood, A., Oliva, J., & Styner, M. (2021). Multiscale Score Matching for Out-of-Distribution Detection. ICLR.
- Tebbe, J., & Tayyub, J. (2024). Dynamic Addition of Noise in a Diffusion Model for Anomaly Detection. CVPR Workshops, 3940–3949.
- Livernoche, V., Zan, J., & Rabbany, R. (2026). Kurtosis-Guided Denoising Score Matching for Tabular Anomaly Detection. arXiv:2605.06955.
- Hirth, M., Koberg, L., Jazdi, N., & Kasneci, E. (2026). Denoising without Diffusion: Fixed-Noise Denoiser Anomaly Detection in Tabular Data. ICML.
- Guo, J., Lu, S., Zhang, W., Chen, F., Li, H., & Liao, H. (2025). Dinomaly: The Less Is More Philosophy in Multi-Class Unsupervised Anomaly Detection. CVPR, 20405–20415.
- Zhang, X., Li, G., Henderson, P., Aragon-Camarasa, G., & Long, Z. (2026). Is Task-Specific Training Necessary for Anomaly Detection? ICML.
Thank you for the rebuttal and the extra experiments. I appreciate the DTE correction, the reimplemented baselines, and the single-noise-scale ablation, and I'm retracting the request for K-DSM.
However, my main concerns still remain:
-
Novelty (Q1): The rebuttal doesn't address this. With , we have . This means the input-aggregated IRF is the noise-normalized score evaluated at the clean input, as in prior score-norm methods. "Mean-input evaluation" is a reparametrization, not a new estimator. Your single-noise-scale DSM ablation is only marginally below the full method and is only reported on one dataset. It would be better to show it on all three datasets and report the variance over seeds.
-
Timestep selection (Q3): The SNR rule picks nearly the same timestep across all three datasets, so the current experiments can't distinguish it from a fixed common timestep. To show its benefit, you would need a setting where the selected timestep actually changes, such as features with a different scale from another backbone or layer set.
-
Dinomaly: The new comparison leaves out MVTec-AD and runs at a lower resolution than Dinomaly's default, where its performance falls well below published results. Since Section 4.5 and Table 1 frame this as a state-of-the-art comparison, these methods need to be included there.
Based on this, I'm maintaining my score for now.
Response to Reviewer stgJ
W1: Novelty and Comparison with Score-Based Anomaly Detection Methods.
We thank the reviewer for highlighting these relevant studies. We acknowledge that score-magnitude anomaly detection is not new and that our IRF is mathematically related to the learned score function. Yet a shared score function does not imply methodological equivalence: response estimation, noise-scale selection, and anomaly-scoring strategies can substantially affect performance. OSD-IRF's novelty lies in combining deterministic response estimation, SNR-guided timestep selection, and direct spatial anomaly scoring for fast, robust score-based anomaly detection at inference, rather than using score magnitude alone. Our training remains easy to implement without more elaborate design than prior methods.
(1) Comparison with MSMA [1] and K-DSM [3]. MSMA forms multiscale score-norm representations by evaluating the learned score function across noise scales and uses an additional density estimator for OOD detection. OSD-IRF instead detects and localizes anomalies from the learned score-related response at one automatically selected probing timestep, without an additional estimator. K-DSM is particularly relevant but methodologically distinct: it trains a single-scale DSM model with kurtosis-guided, feature-wise noise scales and evaluates the learned response on clean test features. OSD-IRF trains a time-conditioned DDPM and evaluates the noise-prediction response at the conditional mean of an SNR-selected noisy state. K-DSM is an arXiv preprint under ICLR 2027 review, not yet peer-reviewed. ICLR 2027 Reviewer Guidelines do not require comparisons with unpublished arXiv papers. Nevertheless, following the reviewer's suggestion, we compare image-level AUROC on MVTec-AD and VisA (Table R1), using results directly from K-DSM's appendix.
Table R1. Image-level AUROC (%) comparison between K-DSM and OSD-IRF on MVTec-AD and VisA.
(2) Comparison with dynamic noise addition [2]. Tebbe et al. [2] introduce dynamic implicit conditioning: KNN distances estimate anomaly severity and guide per-sample adaptive diffusion timestep selection, adding inference overhead. They also explore deterministic input scaling without stochastic noise, but their reconstruction-based method requires iterative denoising for anomaly-free reconstructions. OSD-IRF selects a shared probing timestep solely from normal-data SNR statistics and directly scores anomalies with one deterministic noise-prediction response, without iterative denoising or explicit reconstruction. Thus, they differ fundamentally in timestep selection and anomaly detection mechanisms. Table R2 compares both methods on MVTec-AD and VisA in image-level detection (I-AUROC) and localization (P-AUROC, PRO), using [2]'s results directly from the original paper. These results further support OSD-IRF's effectiveness and its computational advantage of one network evaluation.
Table R2. Performance (%) comparison between Dynamic Noise Addition [2] and OSD-IRF on MVTec-AD and VisA.
(3) Comparison with fixed-noise denoising [4]. Hirth et al. [4] estimate expected deviation using a fixed-noise denoiser and repeated stochastic perturbations. OSD-IRF instead uses deterministic mean-input evaluation without test-time sampling, requiring one network evaluation. On MVTec-AD, Fig. 5 reports 86.0 mAD for input-aggregated IRF (one evaluation), versus 85.3 with 16 stochastic evaluations and 57.4 with one stochastic evaluation. Although not a direct comparison with [4], these results demonstrate the advantage of deterministic response estimation over stochastic aggregation within our framework. We reproduce their method under the same experimental setup as OSD-IRF for a fair comparison on MPDD (Table R3).
Table R3. Performance (%) comparison between fixed-noise denoising [4] and OSD-IRF on MPDD.
(4) Correction and clarification of DTE's contributions. We thank the reviewer for noting this distinction. DTE directly estimates the diffusion-time distribution without iterative reverse diffusion. We will revise this description in the manuscript.