acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Deformable Energy Landscapes for Dexterous Grasp Generation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Dexterous grasp synthesis is typically formulated as conditional generation: a model samples hand configurations given an object, while separate stages rank, refine, or physically verify the results. In contrast, we learn a conditional energy field, a differentiable scalar over the hand's configuration space whose landscape is deformed by the target object, and synthesize grasps via gradient descent. Operating on a learned manifold of hand articulations, the field guides the hand entirely through its gradient. Since descent can start from any configuration, a single field can serve as a generator from uninformative initializations, as an operator to evaluate and refine the outputs or failures of other methods, and as a teacher for a motion prior. We instantiate this framework across graphics and robotics tasks, including static grasp synthesis and reach-and-grasp motion for the human hand, as well as grasp generation and cross-embodiment retargeting for robot hands. Our approach demonstrates competitive performance on all these distinct tasks.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Dexterous grasp, hand-object interaction

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_39WGOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes to learn an energy field conditioned on the object, and use optimization over the hand parameters to synthesize dexterous grasps. However, their experiments do not support their motivation for the method: 1. performance gains are marginal and inconsistent; 2. a key limitation of test-time-optimization-based method, efficiency, has not been discussed; 3. as a learning based method, there is no clear seen/unseen data split in the main paper to study generalization.

Critical strengths

Strengths

  1. Multiple applications are demonstrated.
Critical weaknesses

Weaknesses

  1. As a learning-based algorithm, generalization to the unseen has not been thoroughly validated. It is extremely important to split the object set into seen and unseen set and verify performance on the unseen split.
  2. Hand-object collision avoidance and hand-hand self-penetration avoidance is very crucial for dexterous grasp synthesis. But the learned energy landscape does not support penetration-avoidance on its own, and has to rely on an analytic point-cloud based penetration penalty during test time. Without this additional penalty, PenVol becomes very bad according to Table 1.
  3. The performance improvement demonstrated in Table 1 is not satisfying.
  4. As an iterative pipeline that requires test-time gradient-based optimization, efficiency is a very big concern, but it has not been explicitly reported in the main paper. How much slower is this algorithm compared to purely generative methods?
  5. No real-robot experiments
Questions for authors

Questions:

  1. How is the energy field actually learned? How is ground truth training data collected?
  2. Since the authors already require test-time optimization and point cloud based penetration penalty, it is reasonable to compare with completely optimization-based methods (in other words, methods that do not rely on a training set nor a learned model, but might require iterative optimization to synthesize grasps). How do their method compare with these type of methods, like DexGraspNet?
Reviewer_R38fOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents a conditional energy-field framework for dexterous grasp generation and refinement. The model predicts a continuous energy from object geometry and hand configuration, and synthesizes grasps by optimizing wrist pose and a learned articulation latent variable through gradient descent. Its training targets combine geometric guidance with local quality evaluation, and its training corpus incorporates relabeled endpoints of the model’s own optimization trajectories. The framework is evaluated on static human-hand grasp synthesis, reach-and-grasp motion, robot-hand grasp generation, and cross-embodiment retargeting.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework offers useful flexibility. Configuration-space energy models can support both generation and refinement through different initializations, and can be incorporated into motion-generation and retargeting systems. Experiments across four tasks demonstrate the practical scope of this formulation.

  2. Several results are competitive. The method performs well on robot grasp stability, refinement of existing grasps, and some retargeting directions. Graded quality supervision and relabeling the model’s own optimization endpoints are also reasonable design choices for addressing prediction errors in learned optimization.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Gradient effectiveness, convergence behavior, and initialization sensitivity are insufficiently validated. The energy is trained through value regression but used through its gradients to generate and refine grasps; accurate values do not guarantee directions that improve actual grasp quality. Final results combine multiple initializations, latent constraints, and candidate selection, without directly tracking predicted energy against actual quality along optimization trajectories. The effects of initialization range, iteration count, and restart budget are also not systematically reported. Consequently, the central claims about reliable descent directions lack direct evidence.

  2. The empirical advantages involve substantial trade-offs, and the comparisons do not adequately control supervision resources and failure-identification information. Shadow-hand six-direction success is essentially tied with EvolvingGrasp, while some other metrics are worse; human-hand results also exhibit penetration–stability trade-offs. Matching the number of successful grasps does not account for the additional geometric labels, failed examples, and simulation supervision used by this method. Furthermore, the refinement experiments identify failures through simulation beforehand, which does not establish performance without ground-truth failure labels. These factors limit conclusions about the practical advantage and its source.

  3. The methodological advance and practical value of the unified framework remain insufficiently established. Configuration-space energy optimization, latent pose constraints, and hard-example relabeling have precedents. Applying these mechanisms across tasks is valuable, but the four tasks use different targets and auxiliary components, including sequential fields, geometric penalties, motion priors, and candidate selection. Although the authors appropriately limit their unification claim to a methodological framework, the contributions of shared mechanisms versus task-specific designs remain unclear. The ablations also do not substantiate the stronger general claims linking continuous regression and training coverage to reliable gradients.

Questions for authors
  1. Do the gradients actually improve grasps? On unseen objects, how often does a negative-gradient update improve the true geometric objective or quality estimated through repeated simulation? Can the authors track predicted energy and actual quality throughout optimization and compare against local search from identical initializations under matched computational budgets?

  2. How sensitive is optimization to initialization and budget? How do initial distance, orientation, articulation, iteration count, and restart count affect success and runtime? What fraction of trajectories converge to low-energy but invalid grasps?

  3. What is the independent contribution of endpoint relabeling? Under the same labeling budget, how much does relabeling the model’s own optimization endpoints improve over adding randomly perturbed examples? Do classification or alternative scoring objectives trained on the same data demonstrably produce worse optimization outcomes?

  4. How effective is refinement without ground-truth failure labels? Does performance still improve when refining all grasps or using predicted energy to decide whether to refine? What fractions of grasps change from failure to success and from success to failure?

  5. Can the comparison resources and test-time information be clarified? Please report complete data-construction, simulation, and inference costs, and explain how demonstration-contact information and per-object termination thresholds are obtained at test time for motion generation. Which gains can be attributed to the shared energy mechanism rather than these task-specific components?

Reviewer_v9xXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Deformable Energy Landscapes, a framework for dexterous grasp generation using learned conditional energy fields. The method learns a scalar field from geometric or simulation-based grasp quality targets, then generates grasps through gradient descent over the wrist pose and a learned hand articulation space. It can also refine existing grasps and guide motion generation. Experiments on four tasks show performance competitive with existing methods and improvements on several metrics.

Critical strengths
  • The experiments cover four distinct tasks involving both human and robotic hands.
  • Separating geometric guidance from grasp quality is intuitive, and the ablations support this choice.
  • Refining existing grasps makes the framework useful beyond generating grasps from scratch.
Critical weaknesses
  • It is not fully justified to choose an energy-based formulation over modern generative methods. The paper discusses the limitations of diffusion and flow-based methods, but the EBM's need for millions of labeled configurations (with negative examples) and iterative inference makes computational scalability especially important. The experiments show that the approach works, but do not establish a better efficiency-quality-diversity tradeoff.
  • The novelty over prior optimization-based grasp synthesis is also limited. Optimization in low-dimensional hand spaces has a long history (e.g., https://doi.org/10.1109/IROS.2007.4399227), and more recent work directly optimizes differentiable grasp-quality objectives or physical simulation (e.g., https://doi.org/10.1109/LRA.2021.3129138 and https://doi.org/10.1109/ICRA48891.2023.10160314). Since the field learns a surrogate for geometric or simulation-based objectives, a direct optimization baseline is needed to show what learning the field adds.
  • The empirical improvement seems moderate. The authors also admit that the performance is competitive rather than better. A detailed comparison of inference time and training costs is also missing.
Questions for authors
  • Could the authors report a temporal smoothness metric for reach-and-grasp motion, especially near the boundaries between motion primitives?
  • Could the authors show a few representative failure cases?
  • For the retargeting task, is there a way to evaluate whether the resultant target grasp actually resembles the source grasp?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.