- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a frequency-aware conditional flow matching method for offline multiple appropriate facial reaction generation. It introduces two components: frequency flow matching, which treats different frequency bands separately, and frequency loss optimization, which adds frequency-based supervision. The experiments compare the method with existing approaches in terms of reaction quality, diversity, synchrony, and inference speed.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well organized. The introduction gives a clear explanation of the task and its challenges, and describing FFM and FLO separately makes the method easier to follow.
- The inference speed is a practical advantage: Table 2 reports a reduction from 17.46 s to 3.44 s compared with PerFRDiff. Table 1 also shows the best FRDist among the compared methods and competitive FRCorr. These results make conditional flow matching worth considering for this task, although the benefit of the frequency-aware components is less clear.
Critical weaknesses
- I am not fully convinced by the novelty of FFM and FLO. FFM divides the spectrum into predefined frequency bands with manually chosen coefficients, while FLO adds frequency-weighted velocity supervision and high-frequency energy regularization. Given the existing work on frequency-aware modeling, I would like a clearer explanation of what is new here and why these particular choices are needed for facial reaction generation. The paper also does not test how sensitive the results are to the band boundaries and noise coefficients, so it is hard to judge how well these choices generalize.
- The ablation results leave me unsure whether FFM and FLO offer a clear advantage over plain CFM. In Table 3, plain CFM actually has a better FRDist than the full model, at 136.69 versus 137.78. Adding FFM worsens it to 141.94, and FLO recovers only part of that gap while reducing FRDiv from 0.1404 to 0.1324. The FRCorr improvement from 0.60 to 0.70 is encouraging, but the results show a trade-off rather than consistent gains. Separate ablations of FLO’s two loss terms and results across multiple runs would help establish whether the added complexity is worthwhile.
Questions for authors
- What is the main technical difference between FFM/FLO and existing frequency-aware methods, beyond applying them to MAFRG?
- How did you choose the frequency-band boundaries and noise coefficients? How much do the results change with different choices?
- Since plain CFM achieves a better FRDist in Table 3, where do you see the clearest benefit of adding FFM and FLO?
- Could you separate the effects of FLO’s two loss terms and report results across multiple random seeds?
- Could you show more comparisons with strong baselines, including failure cases, to help readers see when the frequency-aware components help and when they do not?
- Please also check the citation formatting for consistency with the conference style.