acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Spatial Relations Are Not Geometry Alone

Abstract

3D spatial reasoning requires effective representations of inter-object spatial relations. Existing methods typically construct spatial relations from predefined geometric schemes, while incorporating query semantics and reference frames at stages outside relation formation. This separation leads to two fundamental limitations: geometric measurements are fixed before the model knows what spatial evidence the query requires, while directional semantics are not defined directly under the relevant reference frame. Consequently, query-critical geometric cues can be irreversibly omitted, while the mapping from reference frames to directional semantics is poorly constrained and must be learned implicitly. Downstream reasoning is forced to operate on incomplete and ambiguous spatial representations, directly degrading reasoning performance. We therefore propose FROG, a unified relation-centric framework for 3D spatial reasoning, built on the principle that spatial relations should be formed jointly from reFerence fRames, geOmetry, and lanGuage. An order-aware geometry controller captures the relational semantics of the query and drives language-adaptive spatial measurement, adapting measurement directions and relative weights across spatial scales according to the query. In parallel, a relation-centric reference-frame mechanism uses observer orientation to define frame-dependent directional semantics directly during object-object relation formation, without modifying the underlying object or scene representations. By jointly integrating geometry, language, and reference frames into relation formation, FROG effectively mitigates the omission of query-critical geometric cues and the ambiguity of directional semantics, providing downstream reasoning with more complete and context-consistent spatial relation representations. Extensive experiments across multiple 3D LLM backbones, object settings, and spatial reasoning benchmarks demonstrate performance gains and validate the complementary roles of language-adaptive relation modeling and lightweight reference-frame integration within a unified relation-formation framework.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
3D Spatial Reasoning, Spatial Relation Modeling, 3D Vision-Language Models, Reference Frame Reasoning, Language-Conditioned Geometry, Multimodal Reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_5ZxjOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes FROG, a method for enhancing spatial reasoning in 3D LLMs built on object-centric 3D representations. By adding reference-frame-aware positional encodings to object tokens and introducing language-adaptive enhancement at an early stage, FROG enriches object tokens with information relevant to spatial reasoning, helping improve the model’s spatial reasoning capabilities.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main gains of the proposed method come from incorporating reference-frame-based relative positional encodings. Adding explicit 3D positional encodings to object tokens has already been explored in QuatRoPE, and this component does not appear fundamentally different from that approach, despite implementation differences such as constructing an additional 32-dimensional Q/K branch and applying positional encodings to it. This suggests that the paper’s novelty is insufficient.
  2. The paper’s central claim is that spatial reasoning involves more than geometry, as reflected in its title. It devotes substantial discussion and relatively complex architectural designs to incorporating language-described spatial relations into object tokens, including rotation and scaling controls. However, the ablation results show limited incremental gains from these designs. More broadly, I find this mechanism somewhat ad hoc and insufficiently motivated. Since 3D LLMs are built on LLMs that already possess substantial language understanding and reasoning capabilities, the rationale for introducing an additional language-enhancement mechanism for object tokens remains unclear.
Questions for authors
  1. How does QuatRoPE with reference-frame-aware positional encoding perform compared with FROG’s RB + RF variant?
6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (1/3)

Weaknesses

  1. The main gains of the proposed method come from incorporating reference-frame-based relative positional encodings. Adding explicit 3D positional encodings to object tokens has already been explored in QuatRoPE, and this component does not appear fundamentally different from that approach, despite implementation differences such as constructing an additional 32-dimensional Q/K branch and applying positional encodings to it. This suggests that the paper’s novelty is insufficient.

Explicitly incorporating 3D positional encoding can directly introduce three-dimensional geometric information into the model, enabling it to more effectively understand spatial relations between objects and thereby improving its spatial reasoning capabilities.

Nevertheless, QuatRoPE [1] has several implementation-level issues that make it difficult to adapt to complex 3D scenes:

  • Due to the non-commutativity of 3D rotations, QuatRoPE only approximately satisfies the relative positional encoding property, allowing attention scores to vary with absolute positions even when relative displacements remain unchanged (as acknowledged in Appendix B.2 of the original paper).
  • QuatRoPE uses a fixed basis vector (1,0,0)(1,0,0), causing the rotation Rx(x)R_x(x) around the xx-axis to be completely canceled out, thereby preventing it from capturing coordinate information along the xx-axis.

Therefore, we propose the Static Relation Branch (RB). By combining multiple linear measurement directions spanning the full three-dimensional space with two-dimensional rotary encoding, RB strictly preserves the relative positional property while avoiding the non-commutativity of 3D rotations and spatial dimensional degeneracy induced by fixed basis vectors.

In addition, the contribution of this work lies in:

  • Many methods [1, 2] overlook the importance of reference frames for directional semantics or employ complex mechanisms to incorporate reference-frame information [3, 4, 5]. Many methods [1, 2, 6, 7, 8] typically form fixed geometric relations first and then select or combine these relations according to the query requirements, omitting some geometric information at the outset.
  • We propose that spatial relation formation should involve not only geometry but also reference frames and language. Reference frames determine how directional geometry should be interpreted, while language determines how geometric information should be adaptively measured according to the query.
  • Building upon RB, we further develop the Relation-Centric Reference Frame (RF) to address the ambiguity of frame-dependent directional semantics, and Language-Adaptive Spatial Measurement (LA) to mitigate the omission of query-critical geometric information caused by fixed geometric measurements.

Thank you for your question about the clarity of the model components, which helps us to explain our work more accurately.

References:

[1] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[2] Chen et al. Language Conditioned Spatial Relation Reasoning for 3D Object Grounding. NeurIPS, 2022.

[3] Huang et al. Multi-View Transformer for 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2022.

[4] Guo et al. ViewRefer: Grasp the Multi-view Knowledge for 3D Visual Grounding. ICCV, 2023.

[5] Zhao et al. SpaceMind: Camera-Guided Modality Fusion for Spatial Reasoning in Vision-Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[6] Chang et al. MiKASA: Multi-Key-Anchor & Scene-Aware Transformer for 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2024.

[7] Zhang et al. Multi-Object 3D Grounding with Dynamic Modules and Language-Informed Spatial Attention. NeurIPS, 2024.

[8] Huang et al. ORD: Object-Relation Decoupling for Generalized 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (2/3)

  1. The paper’s central claim is that spatial reasoning involves more than geometry, as reflected in its title. It devotes substantial discussion and relatively complex architectural designs to incorporating language-described spatial relations into object tokens, including rotation and scaling controls. However, the ablation results show limited incremental gains from these designs. More broadly, I find this mechanism somewhat ad hoc and insufficiently motivated. Since 3D LLMs are built on LLMs that already possess substantial language understanding and reasoning capabilities, the rationale for introducing an additional language-enhancement mechanism for object tokens remains unclear.

Table R1: Static vs. Language-Adaptive Spatial Relation Modeling on Viewpoint-Free Benchmarks.

VariantMulti3DRefer [email protected] ↑Multi3DRefer [email protected] ↑ASR [email protected] ↑ASR [email protected] ↑
Static RB54.49 ± 0.2454.33 ± 0.2425.69 ± 1.5025.50 ± 1.64
Strong Static RB55.16 ± 0.2454.99 ± 0.2524.31 ± 1.2424.11 ± 1.07
RB + LA (Ours)62.04 ± 0.8661.91 ± 0.9031.05 ± 2.4230.85 ± 2.25
Δ (LA − Strong Static)+6.88 ± 0.88+6.91 ± 0.88+6.75 ± 3.48+6.75 ± 3.18

First, on ScanRefer [1], the Overall and Multiple [email protected] scores improve by 1.9/2.2 percentage points from RB to RB+LA and by 1.3/1.4 percentage points from RB+RF to FROG. Compared with ScanRefer, larger improvements of 8.6 and 8.9 percentage points are achieved on Multi3DRefer [2] [email protected] and ASR [3] [email protected], respectively. Neither dataset provides reference-frame information, and these improvements are achieved through language-adaptive relation modeling alone, demonstrating that LA can effectively capture query-critical geometric cues by adapting spatial measurements to query semantics, thereby enhancing the model's fine-grained spatial reasoning capabilities.

Second, we further analyze why LA achieves greater improvements on Multi3DRefer and ASR than on ScanRefer based on the inherent characteristics of these datasets.

  • Multi3DRefer shifts from single-object grounding to target object set selection and involves more diverse linguistic expressions. LA can effectively capture diverse geometric relations associated with different relational semantics.
  • ASR removes target attribute cues, making spatial relations crucial for target grounding. LA improves spatial relation modeling by capturing query-relevant geometric information.

Therefore, LA performs better on datasets with more complex linguistic expressions and higher demands on spatial reasoning capabilities. To further investigate whether the benefits of LA arise from a more complex architecture, we conduct further ablation studies, as shown in Table R1. We report the mean and standard deviation across three random seeds. The experimental results indicate that the performance gains of LA stem from the language-adaptive selection of geometric information.

Finally, LLMs indeed possess language understanding and logical reasoning capabilities, but these are not equivalent to reliable, scene-grounded 3D spatial reasoning capabilities. Existing studies [4, 5, 6, 7] have shown that the language understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs do not directly translate into reliable 3D spatial reasoning capabilities.

  • Real-3DQA [4] finds that 3D-LLMs can achieve relatively high accuracy through linguistic shortcuts even without relying on 3D scene information, but their performance drops significantly when these shortcuts are eliminated.
  • 3DSRBench [5] shows that even when models understand spatial questions, they struggle to maintain correct geometric judgments across viewpoint changes.
  • What'sUp [6] and VSR [7] further demonstrate that understanding spatial concepts such as “left of” and “above” does not imply the ability to accurately identify the corresponding spatial relations in a scene.

We propose LA precisely to fully leverage the language understanding capabilities of LLMs. Although LLMs can understand what geometric evidence a query requires, they may not be able to effectively extract and combine such information from fixed geometric representations. Therefore, LA allows the query to directly guide the measurement and formation of geometric relations, enabling LLMs to reason based on more relevant geometric evidence.

We hope that these clarifications and analyses help address your concerns. Further discussion is highly welcomed.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (3/3)

References:

[1] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.

[2] Zhang et al. Multi3DRefer: Grounding Text Description to Multiple 3D Objects. ICCV, 2023.

[3] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[4] Ma et al. Do 3D Large Language Models Really Understand 3D Spatial Relationships? ICLR, 2026.

[5] Ma et al. 3DSRBench: A Comprehensive 3D Spatial Reasoning Benchmark. ICCV, 2025.

[6] Kamath et al. What’s “up” with vision-language models? Investigating their struggle with spatial reasoning. EMNLP, 2023.

[7] Liu et al. Visual Spatial Reasoning. TACL, 2023.

Questions

  1. How does QuatRoPE with reference-frame-aware positional encoding perform compared with FROG’s RB + RF variant?

Table R2: Comparison of QuatRoPE [1] and FROG's Relation Branch (RB) with Reference Frame (RF) on ScanRefer [2].

MethodRFOverall [email protected] ↑Multiple [email protected] ↑
QuatRoPE✗55.047.4
QuatRoPE + RF✓59.152.5
FROG (RB)✗53.945.7
FROG (RB + RF)✓63.857.3

Thank you for this suggestion.

To further validate the effectiveness of the RF module across different frameworks, we conduct additional experiments, as shown in Table R2.

The experimental results show that RF still yields performance gains when applied to QuatRoPE [1], further demonstrating its generalizability and effectiveness.

Meanwhile, FROG's RB+RF substantially outperforms QuatRoPE+RF, demonstrating the complementary roles of the two modules: RB strictly preserves the relative positional property while avoiding spatial dimensional degeneracy (as detailed in our response to Weakness 1), and RF mitigates the ambiguity of directional semantics by directly incorporating reference-frame information into relation formation.

References:

[1] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[2] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.

Reviewer_yL4TOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes FROG, a framework for 3D spatial reasoning that jointly incorporates language, geometry, and reference frames into spatial relation modeling. The method uses a language-conditioned geometry controller to adapt spatial measurements to different queries, and integrates observer orientation directly into the attention-based relation representation. Experiments on several 3D grounding and QA benchmarks show consistent improvements across different backbones.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies an important limitation of fixed geometric relation encoding. Making spatial measurements query-dependent and incorporating reference frames directly into relation formation is a reasonable and effective design.

  2. FROG achieves substantial improvements on ScanRefer and Multi3DRefer across different backbones and object settings. The ablations are fairly comprehensive, and the additional results on ASR and Real-3DQA further support the generalization of the method. The improvements also come with relatively small parameter and inference overhead.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The contribution of language-adaptive measurement seems relatively limited compared to reference-frame modeling. In Table 5, adding language adaptation improves [email protected] from 53.9 to 55.8, while adding the reference-frame module improves it to 63.8. It would be useful to better understand when language adaptation provides the most benefit.

  2. The method relies on object centers and observer yaw to construct spatial relations. This is reasonable for the evaluated benchmarks, but it is unclear how well the approach handles more complex spatial relations involving object orientation, shape, or dynamic scenes.

Questions for authors
  1. In Table 5, the reference-frame module contributes most of the improvement. Could the authors provide a more detailed analysis of which types of spatial queries benefit specifically from language-adaptive measurement?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #yL4T (1/3)

Thank you for your careful review and positive assessment of our work.

Weaknesses and Questions

Weakness 1.1. The contribution of language-adaptive measurement seems relatively limited compared to reference-frame modeling. In Table 5, adding language adaptation improves [email protected] from 53.9 to 55.8, while adding the reference-frame module improves it to 63.8.

As shown in Tables 1 and 4, the contribution of LA is more pronounced on Multi3DRefer [1] and ASR [2], where FROG achieves improvements of 8.6 and 8.9 percentage points in [email protected] and [email protected], respectively, without incorporating reference-frame information.

The larger performance gains from LA on Multi3DRefer and ASR can be attributed to the characteristics of these datasets.

  • Multi3DRefer extends single-object grounding to target object set selection and contains more diverse linguistic expressions. LA can effectively adapt geometric measurements to different relational semantics.
  • ASR removes target attribute cues, requiring better modeling of spatial relations. LA addresses this requirement by adapting geometric measurements to query semantics.

Therefore, LA yields greater performance gains on datasets with more complex linguistic expressions and higher demands on spatial reasoning capabilities.

These observations further validate the motivation behind LA: different queries require different geometric evidence. By allowing language to directly guide geometric measurement during relation formation, LA can effectively mitigate the omission of query-critical geometric information, thereby enhancing the model's fine-grained spatial reasoning capabilities.

Further discussion would be most welcome.

References:

[1] Zhang et al. Multi3DRefer: Grounding Text Description to Multiple 3D Objects. ICCV, 2023.

[2] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

Weakness 1.2. It would be useful to better understand when language adaptation provides the most benefit.

Question 1: In Table 5, the reference-frame module contributes most of the improvement. Could the authors provide a more detailed analysis of which types of spatial queries benefit specifically from language-adaptive measurement?

Table R1: Analysis of Spatial Queries Benefiting from Language-Adaptive Measurement.

Spatial Query TypeTotalImprovedRegressedNetNet Gain ↑
Vertical4,665601439+162+3.47%
Proximity5,327687550+137+2.57%
Configuration/Support10,1011,2351,003+232+2.30%
Directional17,8222,2781,954+324+1.82%
Comparative/Ordinal4,697587523+64+1.36%

Table R2: Analysis of Fine-grained Spatial Expressions.

Spatial ExpressionTotalImprovedRegressedNet Gain ↑
Above / Below / Under4,490571431+3.12%
Near / Next to / Beside4,860627497+2.67%
Front / Behind4,276558450+2.53%
Left / Right13,2881,6781,450+1.72%

Thank you for raising this thought-provoking question.

To further investigate which types of spatial queries benefit from Language-Adaptive Spatial Measurement (LA), we conduct a fine-grained query-level delta analysis on ScanRefer [1], Multi3DRefer [2], and ASR [3]. We collect paired prediction results with and without LA while keeping all other experimental settings unchanged. We then categorize queries according to their spatial relations and calculate the normalized net improvement rate (Net Gain) for each category:

NetGain(c)=Nimproved(c)−Nregressed(c)Ntotal(c)×100\mathrm{NetGain}(c)=\frac{N_{\mathrm{improved}}(c)-N_{\mathrm{regressed}}(c)}{N_{\mathrm{total}}(c)}\times 100\\%.

First, as shown in Table R1, LA achieves positive net improvements across all five spatial query categories, with particularly pronounced gains in Vertical, Proximity, and Configuration/Support relations.

  • Vertical (+3.47%): These queries primarily rely on vertical displacements and height differences between objects. Through query-conditioned measurement basis rotation δ(Q)\delta(Q) and direction–frequency weights ρ(Q)\rho(Q), LA can selectively emphasize geometric information along query-relevant directions.
  • Proximity (+2.57%): Different proximity relations require geometric information at different spatial scales. By adaptively adjusting spatial-frequency weights, LA can more effectively capture the multi-scale geometric information required by the query.
  • Configuration/Support (+2.30%): These queries involve relative object layouts and support relations, often requiring geometric information across different directions and scales. LA allows language to directly guide relation formation, alleviating the burden on downstream models to extract and combine relevant information from fixed geometric representations.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #yL4T (2/3)

  • Directional (+1.82%) and Comparative/Ordinal (+1.36%): Both categories also achieve positive net improvements, further demonstrating the adaptability of LA to diverse relational semantics.

Second, the fine-grained spatial expression analysis (Table R2) further confirms that LA benefits diverse spatial relations, with particularly pronounced gains in vertical and proximity relations. These results highlight the complementary roles of LA and RF.

RF resolves ambiguity in horizontal directional relations using observer yaw, while LA better captures vertical and proximity relations by adapting measurement directions and spatial scales to query semantics.

Finally, we find that LA also benefits queries involving multiple spatial constraints. For example:

  • Multi-anchor directional reasoning: “the chair is to the left of one chair, and to the right of the other chair.” This query requires integrating directional relations involving multiple reference objects. Introducing LA corrects the erroneous predictions of Objects 4 and 1 to the correct Object 17 in the settings without and with RF, respectively.
  • Mixed proximity-directional reasoning: “it is closest to the door on the left.” This query requires jointly considering directional and distance information. Introducing LA corrects the erroneous predictions of Objects 25 and 27 to the correct Object 14 in the respective settings.

These examples demonstrate that even when the reference frame is established, models can further benefit from query-adaptive geometric measurement.

The above results further support our core motivation for introducing LA: different spatial queries require different geometric evidence. By allowing language to directly control measurement directions, direction–frequency weights, and overall geometric contribution strength (δ(Q)\delta(Q), ρ(Q)\rho(Q), and β(Q)\beta(Q)), LA emphasizes query-critical geometric evidence from the outset of relation formation, thereby improving spatial reasoning across diverse relational semantics and compositional spatial constraints.

Further opportunities for discussion would be warmly welcomed.

References:

[1] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.

[2] Zhang et al. Multi3DRefer: Grounding Text Description to Multiple 3D Objects. ICCV, 2023.

[3] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

Weakness 2. The method relies on object centers and observer yaw to construct spatial relations. This is reasonable for the evaluated benchmarks, but it is unclear how well the approach handles more complex spatial relations involving object orientation, shape, or dynamic scenes.

Thank you for raising this insightful question.

Many existing object-centric 3D spatial reasoning methods [1, 2, 3] primarily rely on object-level visual features and center-based geometric relations, without explicitly modeling intrinsic object orientations, fine-grained shape-dependent relations, or temporal relation evolution. FROG follows this object-level representation paradigm and focuses on how to form spatial relations more effectively.

Furthermore, FROG not only uses object centers to construct explicit geometric relations but also preserves the original backbone's point-cloud and image features, jointly modeling geometric and content interactions within attention (Appendix A.1 and Eqs. 9–10). Therefore, shape and orientation cues encoded in the original object features can still contribute to spatial reasoning.

Specifically, we analyze FROG's ability to handle these more complex spatial relations:

  • Object orientation: For a chair facing a desk, FROG can model their relative direction and combine it with orientation cues encoded in the original object features. However, rotating the chair in place leaves the center-based geometric relation operator unchanged. Reasoning about whether the chair faces toward or away from the desk therefore still relies on the backbone's ability to interpret intrinsic object orientations.
  • Object shape: For a cabinet next to a wall, FROG can adapt geometric measurements to capture the relevant direction and distance. However, two cabinets with identical center positions but different widths may either touch the wall or leave a gap. FROG's explicit geometric relation operator cannot distinguish these conditions, leaving such shape-dependent reasoning to the original object features and the backbone.
  • Dynamic scenes: When an observer turns 180°, FROG can update the relation of a chair from left to right without reconstructing object features. Similarly, when the chair is moved closer to a table, FROG can capture the changed spatial relation given updated object positions. However, determining whether the chair is moving toward or away from the table requires temporal information, which the current formulation does not explicitly model.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #yL4T (3/3)

Object orientation and dynamic spatial reasoning remain challenging research problems [4, 5]. While the above analysis illustrates FROG's potential and current limitations, dedicated evaluations of these complex relations remain future work. We plan to extend FROG's unified relation formation framework to intrinsic object reference frames, language-adaptive surface geometry measurements, and spatiotemporal relation modeling.

We look forward to the opportunity for further discussion.

References:

[1] Huang et al. Chat-Scene: Bridging 3D Scene and Large Language Models with Object Identifiers. NeurIPS, 2024.

[2] Chen et al. Language Conditioned Spatial Relation Reasoning for 3D Object Grounding. NeurIPS, 2022.

[3] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[4] Ma et al. 3DSRBench: A Comprehensive 3D Spatial Reasoning Benchmark. ICCV, 2025.

[5] Zhang et al. DSI-Bench: A Benchmark for Dynamic Spatial Intelligence. arXiv:2510.18873, 2025.

Reviewer_8txsOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes FROG, which integrates query-dependent geometry and observer reference frames into object-level 3D language models through spectral geometric attention in the decoder’s latter half. An order-aware query encoder modulates this attention, while eight discrete yaw orientations map object displacements into observer-relative coordinates. Evaluations with Chat-Scene and 3DGraphLLM across grounding and QA benchmarks, using ground-truth instances and predicted proposals, show substantial grounding improvements and transfer gains on evaluation-only benchmarks. The paper argues that jointly modeling geometry, language, and reference frames improves on fixed geometry and conventional viewpoint conditioning.

Critical strengths

1.FROG improves grounding across two backbones using both ground-truth instances and Mask3D proposals (Table 1). Without viewpoint inputs, ASR [email protected] also rises from 22.92 to 31.85 (Table 4), supporting its utility beyond viewpoint-equipped settings. 2.Tokenwise spectral rotations model pairwise geometry without a dense relation tensor, with approximately 3.99M added parameters in the 1B configuration. Three-seed results for the main configurations (Appendix C) show variation substantially smaller than the larger grounding gains.

Critical weaknesses

1.FROG lacks comparisons against the same backbone receiving identical yaw through conventional coordinate alignment or pose conditioning. Table 5 shows that reference frames raise [email protected] from 53.9 to 63.8, while language adaptation further increases it to 65.1, leaving the comparative advantage of the relation-centric formulation unclear. Table 3 does not control key experimental conditions, and Tables 3–4 do not quantify the costs of the view-specified methods labeled “higher cost” in Figure 1. 2.Insufficient evidence for the representation-level explanation: Query-independent encodings can preserve displacements, and the paper does not establish what essential information competitors lose or how FROG’s object-center geometry and four fixed frequencies recover it. Ablations are limited to ground-truth ScanRefer, with no capacity-matched static branch on viewpoint-free Multi3DRefer or ASR to distinguish the proposed mechanism from useful inductive bias or added capacity. Figure 3(c)’s averaged routing weights show layerwise frequency preferences rather than query-specific selection, supporting architectural usefulness more clearly than the claimed solution to geometric information loss.

Questions for authors
  1. Do Chat-Scene and QuatRoPE receive the same official yaw as FROG, and how does FROG compare with coordinate alignment or pose conditioning under matched backbones, data, object proposals, and viewpoint inputs?
  2. Please identify Figure 1’s “higher cost” methods and compare their latency, peak memory, and preprocessing costs with FROG, stating whether viewpoint estimation and view-specific feature construction are included.
  3. Please compare static and language-adaptive branches on viewpoint-free Multi3DRefer and ASR under matched geometric capacity and training budgets, preferably with uncertainty estimates.
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #8txs (1/4)

Weaknesses and Questions

Weakness 1.1. FROG lacks comparisons against the same backbone receiving identical yaw through conventional coordinate alignment or pose conditioning.

Question 1: Do Chat-Scene and QuatRoPE receive the same official yaw as FROG, and how does FROG compare with coordinate alignment or pose conditioning under matched backbones, data, object proposals, and viewpoint inputs?

Table R1: Reference-Frame Integration Strategies within FROG.

Method[email protected][email protected][email protected][email protected]
RB + LA (w/o RCRF)56.055.848.247.9
+ World Positional Encoding55.955.748.348.1
+ Coordinate Alignment61.861.654.954.6
+ Pose Conditioning60.660.253.853.3
+ Relation-Centric Reference Frame (Full FROG)65.365.158.858.7

Table R2: Reference-Frame Integration across Backbone Architectures.

Method[email protected][email protected][email protected][email protected]
Chat-Scene50.750.342.742.3
+ World Positional Encoding51.951.743.643.3
+ Coordinate Alignment58.057.751.150.8
+ Pose Conditioning56.055.748.848.5
Chat-Scene + QuatRoPE55.455.047.847.4
+ World Positional Encoding55.855.748.147.9
+ Coordinate Alignment59.959.653.553.1
+ Pose Conditioning58.958.651.951.4
Chat-Scene + FROG (w/o LA)64.063.857.657.3
Chat-Scene + FROG65.365.158.858.7

Thank you for your constructive suggestion.

First, we clarify that Chat-Scene [1] and QuatRoPE [2] did not receive the same official yaw information as FROG. In fact, we introduce viewpoint information precisely because existing methods [1, 2, 3] overlook the importance of viewpoints in defining directional semantics, making it difficult for models to correctly interpret directional relations under different reference frames.

To further validate the importance of reference frames and the advantages of the Relation-Centric Reference Frame (RCRF) over other methods for incorporating reference-frame information, we conduct additional comparative experiments following the designs of PoseAlign [4] and CAPE [5], as shown in Tables R1 and R2. All these experiments are conducted under matched backbones, data, object proposals, and viewpoint inputs.

In Experiment R1, we use exactly the same underlying framework and vary only the mechanism for incorporating reference-frame information. Our proposed RCRF outperforms Coordinate Alignment and Pose Conditioning by 3.5 and 4.9 points, respectively. In Experiment R2, we provide the baselines with exactly the same viewpoint information, and all baselines achieve varying degrees of improvement. However, FROG still substantially outperforms the strongest baseline variant (QuatRoPE + Coordinate Alignment) by 5.5 points in [email protected] and maintains a 4.2-point advantage even without Language Adaptation.

These results demonstrate that the performance advantage of FROG stems from the effectiveness of RCRF in directly integrating reference-frame information into spatial relation formation.

References:

[1] Huang et al. Chat-Scene: Bridging 3D Scene and Large Language Models with Object Identifiers. NeurIPS, 2024.

[2] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[3] Chen et al. Language Conditioned Spatial Relation Reasoning for 3D Object Grounding. NeurIPS, 2022.

[4] Liu et al. Direction-aware 3D Large Multimodal Models. CVPR, 2026.

[5] Xiong et al. CAPE: Camera View Position Embedding for Multi-View 3D Object Detection. CVPR, 2023.

Weakness 1.2. Table 5 shows that reference frames raise [email protected] from 53.9 to 63.8, while language adaptation further increases it to 65.1, leaving the comparative advantage of the relation-centric formulation unclear.

First, regarding reference frames, existing methods either completely overlook this critical information for defining directional semantics or employ complex mechanisms to incorporate it into the model. We propose directly incorporating reference-frame information during relation formation, achieving greater performance gains at a lower cost (see Table R3).

Next, regarding the language adaptation module, existing methods typically form fixed geometric relations first and then select or combine these relations according to the query requirements, omitting some geometric information at the outset. Therefore, forming query-required relations from the outset can both facilitate downstream LLM reasoning and reduce the number of redundant relation tokens fed into the LLM (as detailed in our response to Weakness 2.1).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #8txs (2/4)

Finally, without reference-frame information (see Tables 1 and 4), FROG achieves improvements of 8.6 and 8.9 percentage points on Multi3DRefer [1] [email protected] and ASR [2] [email protected], respectively, through language-adaptive relation modeling, demonstrating its effectiveness in mitigating the omission of query-critical geometric information. The relatively smaller gains of LA on ScanRefer [3] can be attributed to its less diverse linguistic expressions and greater availability of target attribute cues, which reduce the need for query-adaptive geometric measurements.

Further discussion would be most welcome.

References:

[1] Zhang et al. Multi3DRefer: Grounding Text Description to Multiple 3D Objects. ICCV, 2023.

[2] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

[3] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.

Weakness 1.3. Table 3 does not control key experimental conditions.

Regarding Table 3, we would like to further clarify the scope of the comparisons.

Multi-view methods such as MVT [1], ViewRefer [2], and ViewSRD [3] primarily focus on modeling and fusing information across viewpoints, rather than explicitly modeling reference-frame-dependent directional semantics as FROG does.

For the more closely related representation-level integration approaches, we have included representative strategies such as Coordinate Alignment and Pose Conditioning in the new Tables R1 and R2, enabling direct comparisons under matched experimental conditions.

Thus, Table 3 provides an overall performance comparison across different viewpoint-aware approaches, while the new experiments offer more rigorous controlled comparisons that further validate the effectiveness and advantages of directly integrating reference-frame information into spatial relation formation through RCRF.

References:

[1] Huang et al. Multi-View Transformer for 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2022.

[2] Guo et al. ViewRefer: Grasp the Multi-view Knowledge for 3D Visual Grounding. ICCV, 2023.

[3] Huang et al. ViewSRD: 3D Visual Grounding via Structured Multi-View Decomposition. ICCV, 2025.

Weakness 1.4. Tables 3–4 do not quantify the costs of the view-specified methods labeled “higher cost” in Figure 1.

Question 2: Please identify Figure 1’s “higher cost” methods and compare their latency, peak memory, and preprocessing costs with FROG, stating whether viewpoint estimation and view-specific feature construction are included.

Table R3: Computational Cost of View-specified Methods.

MethodLatency (ms)Peak Mem. (GB)Preproc. (s/scene)Cache (MB)Viewpoint EstimationView-specific ConstructionScanRefer [email protected]
MVT (4-view, arch.-only)49.900.3940.02184.90None5.56 ms (included)33.3
MVT (1-view ablation)47.400.3940.02184.90None2.49 ms (included)31.1
ViewRefer (arch.-only)244.900.4042.67451.804 fixed viewsRotation: 0.91 ms (excluded), fusion: 0.54 ms (included)33.7
VPP-Net (arch.-only)185.700.7600.02394.905.70 ms (included)4.16 ms (included)43.3
ConcreteNet (1-view)290.501.962.452080Provided cameraFusion: 0.364 ms (included)43.8
ConcreteNet (5-view)2224.00 (7.66×)2.24 (+14.3%)2.452080Provided camera5-view inference (included)46.5
PoseAlign-T (generation-only)157.2012.96—368.41.40 ms (excluded)Alignment: 4.82 ms (excluded)58.7
Chat-Scene + PoseAlign-E1082.576.395—205Provided yaw0.17 ms (included)46.9
FROG w/o RCRF1416.246.404—205——55.8
FROG (+RCRF)1425.56 (+0.66%)6.404 (+0.00%)—205 (+0)Provided yawNone65.1

Thank you for your constructive suggestion regarding the experiments. We first clarify that “higher cost” in Fig. 1 primarily refers to costs at the methodological design level, including multi-view processing and view-specific feature construction.

To directly substantiate the claim of “higher cost,” we have added Table R3, which profiles representative viewpoint-aware methods. Their additional computational costs primarily arise from multi-view processing, view-specific feature construction, and explicit viewpoint estimation or pose alignment.

  • MVT [1] and ConcreteNet [2]: Multi-view processing increases MVT's view-specific computation from 2.49 ms to 5.56 ms when expanding from one to four views, while ConcreteNet's five-view inference incurs a 7.66× increase in latency.
  • ViewRefer [3]: Multi-view feature rotation and fusion introduce additional computational costs, alongside a preprocessing time of 2.67 s/scene and 451.80 MB of cached features.
  • VPP-Net [4]: Explicit viewpoint prediction and subsequent view-specific transformations introduce additional latency of 5.70 ms and 4.16 ms, respectively.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer #8txs (3/4)

  • PoseAlign [5]: PoseAlign-T requires additional pose selection (1.40 ms) and point-cloud alignment (4.82 ms), both excluded from its reported generation latency. PoseAlign-E introduces a learned pose residual to object tokens (264,960 additional parameters and 0.17 ms latency), yet yields only a marginal improvement in ScanRefer [6] [email protected] from 46.4 to 46.9.

In contrast, RCRF directly incorporates the provided observer yaw into spatial relation formation without reconstructing viewpoint-specific object features or introducing additional caches.

Under the same backbone, RCRF adds only 9.32 ms (0.66%) end-to-end latency, with no additional learnable parameters or observable increase in peak GPU memory.

Importantly, this lightweight integration improves ScanRefer [email protected] from 55.8% to 65.1% (+9.3 points), demonstrating that RCRF achieves substantial spatial reasoning gains with minimal computational overhead.

References:

[1] Huang et al. Multi-View Transformer for 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2022.

[2] Unal et al. Four Ways to Improve Verbo-visual Fusion for Dense 3D Visual Grounding. ECCV, 2024.

[3] Guo et al. ViewRefer: Grasp the Multi-view Knowledge for 3D Visual Grounding. ICCV, 2023.

[4] Shi et al. Viewpoint-Aware Visual Grounding in 3D Scenes. CVPR, 2024.

[5] Liu et al. Direction-aware 3D Large Multimodal Models. CVPR, 2026.

[6] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.

Weakness 2.1. Insufficient evidence for the representation-level explanation: Query-independent encodings can preserve displacements, and the paper does not establish what essential information competitors lose or how FROG’s object-center geometry and four fixed frequencies recover it.

Existing approaches to inter-object relation modeling in 3D-LLMs can be broadly divided into two paradigms.

  • Explicitly representing all pairwise relations requires O(N2)O(N^2) relation tokens, incurring substantial computational costs. To improve scalability, methods such as 3DGraphLLM [1] adopt kNN to retain only local relations. However, proximity does not necessarily imply query relevance, and such pruning may discard long-range geometric evidence required by queries such as farthest [2, 3].

  • Methods such as QuatRoPE [3] encode object centers and model pairwise spatial relations within attention without introducing additional relation tokens. However, their geometric measurements remain query-independent, requiring the model to implicitly extract or compose query-critical geometric evidence from these predefined representations.

FROG allows language to directly control relation formation. LA aims to emphasize and construct query-critical geometric evidence at the very beginning of geometric relation formation. This avoids the need to explicitly construct a large number of pairwise relation tokens while alleviating the reasoning burden on the downstream model.

Further discussion is highly welcomed.

References:

[1] Zemskova and Yudin. 3DGraphLLM: Combining Semantic Graphs and Large Language Models for 3D Scene Understanding. ICCV, 2025.

[2] Chen et al. Language Conditioned Spatial Relation Reasoning for 3D Object Grounding. NeurIPS, 2022.

[3] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.

Weakness 2.2. Ablations are limited to ground-truth ScanRefer, with no capacity-matched static branch on viewpoint-free Multi3DRefer or ASR to distinguish the proposed mechanism from useful inductive bias or added capacity.

Question 3: Please compare static and language-adaptive branches on viewpoint-free Multi3DRefer and ASR under matched geometric capacity and training budgets, preferably with uncertainty estimates.

Table R4: Static vs. Language-Adaptive Spatial Relation Modeling on Viewpoint-Free Benchmarks.

VariantMulti3DRefer [email protected] ↑Multi3DRefer [email protected] ↑ASR [email protected] ↑ASR [email protected] ↑
Static RB54.49 ± 0.2454.33 ± 0.2425.69 ± 1.5025.50 ± 1.64
Strong Static RB55.16 ± 0.2454.99 ± 0.2524.31 ± 1.2424.11 ± 1.07
RB + LA (Ours)62.04 ± 0.8661.91 ± 0.9031.05 ± 2.4230.85 ± 2.25
Δ (LA − Strong Static)+6.88 ± 0.88+6.91 ± 0.88+6.75 ± 3.48+6.75 ± 3.18

Thank you for your constructive suggestions regarding the experiments.

To further verify that the performance gains of LA do not stem from additional model capacity, we conducted additional controlled experiments on the viewpoint-free Multi3DRefer [1] and ASR [2] benchmarks, comparing Static RB, the capacity-matched Strong Static RB, and the language-adaptive RB + LA.

All results are reported as the mean ± sample standard deviation over three random seeds, as shown in Table R4.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We thank all reviewers for their careful and constructive feedback. In response to their concerns regarding reference-frame integration, language-adaptive spatial measurement, and methodological novelty, we provide the following clarifications and additional analyses.

GR1. Effective and lightweight relation-centric reference-frame integration

We emphasize that the advantage of RCRF lies not merely in incorporating reference-frame information, but in directly defining directional semantics during spatial relation formation. Given identical viewpoint information, RCRF outperforms conventional reference-frame integration strategies by 3.5–4.9 points (see our Response to Reviewer #8txs (1/4)) and also yields substantial gains when applied to QuatRoPE, demonstrating its generalizability across different frameworks (see our Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (3/3)). Furthermore, without constructing viewpoint-specific object features, RCRF achieves a 9.3-point improvement with only 0.66% additional end-to-end latency (see our Response to Reviewer #8txs (2/4)).

Revised manuscript: Secs. 4.2–4.3, Appendices G–H, Tables 6 and 13–15.

GR2. Effective language-adaptive spatial measurement

We further clarify the motivation behind LA: different queries require different geometric evidence, whereas fixed geometric measurements fail to sufficiently emphasize query-critical information. Compared with ScanRefer, LA yields greater improvements on Multi3DRefer, which involves more diverse linguistic expressions, and ASR, which relies more heavily on spatial relations. Capacity-matched ablations show that LA yields improvements of approximately 7 points on both benchmarks (see our Responses to Reviewer #8txs (3/4) and Reviewer #5Zxj (2/3)). Fine-grained query-level analyses further show positive net improvements across all five spatial relation categories, validating the effectiveness of LA in adaptively capturing geometric evidence according to query semantics (see our Response to Reviewer #yL4T (1/3)).

Revised manuscript: Abstract, Secs. 1, 2, 3.2, 4.3 and 5, Appendices C and F, Tables 9–12.

GR3. Novelty and advantages of the relation-centric formulation

We further clarify the distinction between FROG and QuatRoPE: RB strictly preserves the relative positional property while avoiding spatial dimensional degeneracy, providing a principled geometric foundation for RF and LA (see our Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (1/3)).

More importantly, our core contribution lies not in introducing a new positional encoding scheme, but in rethinking how spatial relations should be formed. We propose making spatial relation formation itself jointly dependent on geometry, language, and reference frames, thereby emphasizing query-critical geometric evidence and mitigating directional ambiguity to provide more informative and context-consistent relation representations for downstream spatial reasoning.

Revised manuscript: Sec. 3.4.

We have revised the manuscript accordingly, with all revisions highlighted in blue. Detailed reviewer-specific responses are provided separately.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.