- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FROG, a method for enhancing spatial reasoning in 3D LLMs built on object-centric 3D representations. By adding reference-frame-aware positional encodings to object tokens and introducing language-adaptive enhancement at an early stage, FROG enriches object tokens with information relevant to spatial reasoning, helping improve the model’s spatial reasoning capabilities.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- The main gains of the proposed method come from incorporating reference-frame-based relative positional encodings. Adding explicit 3D positional encodings to object tokens has already been explored in QuatRoPE, and this component does not appear fundamentally different from that approach, despite implementation differences such as constructing an additional 32-dimensional Q/K branch and applying positional encodings to it. This suggests that the paper’s novelty is insufficient.
- The paper’s central claim is that spatial reasoning involves more than geometry, as reflected in its title. It devotes substantial discussion and relatively complex architectural designs to incorporating language-described spatial relations into object tokens, including rotation and scaling controls. However, the ablation results show limited incremental gains from these designs. More broadly, I find this mechanism somewhat ad hoc and insufficiently motivated. Since 3D LLMs are built on LLMs that already possess substantial language understanding and reasoning capabilities, the rationale for introducing an additional language-enhancement mechanism for object tokens remains unclear.
Questions for authors
- How does QuatRoPE with reference-frame-aware positional encoding perform compared with FROG’s RB + RF variant?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (2/3)
- The paper’s central claim is that spatial reasoning involves more than geometry, as reflected in its title. It devotes substantial discussion and relatively complex architectural designs to incorporating language-described spatial relations into object tokens, including rotation and scaling controls. However, the ablation results show limited incremental gains from these designs. More broadly, I find this mechanism somewhat ad hoc and insufficiently motivated. Since 3D LLMs are built on LLMs that already possess substantial language understanding and reasoning capabilities, the rationale for introducing an additional language-enhancement mechanism for object tokens remains unclear.
Table R1: Static vs. Language-Adaptive Spatial Relation Modeling on Viewpoint-Free Benchmarks.
| Variant | Multi3DRefer [email protected] ↑ | Multi3DRefer [email protected] ↑ | ASR [email protected] ↑ | ASR [email protected] ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Static RB | 54.49 ± 0.24 | 54.33 ± 0.24 | 25.69 ± 1.50 | 25.50 ± 1.64 |
| Strong Static RB | 55.16 ± 0.24 | 54.99 ± 0.25 | 24.31 ± 1.24 | 24.11 ± 1.07 |
| RB + LA (Ours) | 62.04 ± 0.86 | 61.91 ± 0.90 | 31.05 ± 2.42 | 30.85 ± 2.25 |
| Δ (LA − Strong Static) | +6.88 ± 0.88 | +6.91 ± 0.88 | +6.75 ± 3.48 | +6.75 ± 3.18 |
First, on ScanRefer [1], the Overall and Multiple [email protected] scores improve by 1.9/2.2 percentage points from RB to RB+LA and by 1.3/1.4 percentage points from RB+RF to FROG. Compared with ScanRefer, larger improvements of 8.6 and 8.9 percentage points are achieved on Multi3DRefer [2] [email protected] and ASR [3] [email protected], respectively. Neither dataset provides reference-frame information, and these improvements are achieved through language-adaptive relation modeling alone, demonstrating that LA can effectively capture query-critical geometric cues by adapting spatial measurements to query semantics, thereby enhancing the model's fine-grained spatial reasoning capabilities.
Second, we further analyze why LA achieves greater improvements on Multi3DRefer and ASR than on ScanRefer based on the inherent characteristics of these datasets.
- Multi3DRefer shifts from single-object grounding to target object set selection and involves more diverse linguistic expressions. LA can effectively capture diverse geometric relations associated with different relational semantics.
- ASR removes target attribute cues, making spatial relations crucial for target grounding. LA improves spatial relation modeling by capturing query-relevant geometric information.
Therefore, LA performs better on datasets with more complex linguistic expressions and higher demands on spatial reasoning capabilities. To further investigate whether the benefits of LA arise from a more complex architecture, we conduct further ablation studies, as shown in Table R1. We report the mean and standard deviation across three random seeds. The experimental results indicate that the performance gains of LA stem from the language-adaptive selection of geometric information.
Finally, LLMs indeed possess language understanding and logical reasoning capabilities, but these are not equivalent to reliable, scene-grounded 3D spatial reasoning capabilities. Existing studies [4, 5, 6, 7] have shown that the language understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs do not directly translate into reliable 3D spatial reasoning capabilities.
- Real-3DQA [4] finds that 3D-LLMs can achieve relatively high accuracy through linguistic shortcuts even without relying on 3D scene information, but their performance drops significantly when these shortcuts are eliminated.
- 3DSRBench [5] shows that even when models understand spatial questions, they struggle to maintain correct geometric judgments across viewpoint changes.
- What'sUp [6] and VSR [7] further demonstrate that understanding spatial concepts such as “left of” and “above” does not imply the ability to accurately identify the corresponding spatial relations in a scene.
We propose LA precisely to fully leverage the language understanding capabilities of LLMs. Although LLMs can understand what geometric evidence a query requires, they may not be able to effectively extract and combine such information from fixed geometric representations. Therefore, LA allows the query to directly guide the measurement and formation of geometric relations, enabling LLMs to reason based on more relevant geometric evidence.
We hope that these clarifications and analyses help address your concerns. Further discussion is highly welcomed.
Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (3/3)
References:
[1] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.
[2] Zhang et al. Multi3DRefer: Grounding Text Description to Multiple 3D Objects. ICCV, 2023.
[3] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.
[4] Ma et al. Do 3D Large Language Models Really Understand 3D Spatial Relationships? ICLR, 2026.
[5] Ma et al. 3DSRBench: A Comprehensive 3D Spatial Reasoning Benchmark. ICCV, 2025.
[6] Kamath et al. What’s “up” with vision-language models? Investigating their struggle with spatial reasoning. EMNLP, 2023.
[7] Liu et al. Visual Spatial Reasoning. TACL, 2023.
Questions
- How does QuatRoPE with reference-frame-aware positional encoding perform compared with FROG’s RB + RF variant?
Table R2: Comparison of QuatRoPE [1] and FROG's Relation Branch (RB) with Reference Frame (RF) on ScanRefer [2].
| Method | RF | Overall [email protected] ↑ | Multiple [email protected] ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| QuatRoPE | ✗ | 55.0 | 47.4 |
| QuatRoPE + RF | ✓ | 59.1 | 52.5 |
| FROG (RB) | ✗ | 53.9 | 45.7 |
| FROG (RB + RF) | ✓ | 63.8 | 57.3 |
Thank you for this suggestion.
To further validate the effectiveness of the RF module across different frameworks, we conduct additional experiments, as shown in Table R2.
The experimental results show that RF still yields performance gains when applied to QuatRoPE [1], further demonstrating its generalizability and effectiveness.
Meanwhile, FROG's RB+RF substantially outperforms QuatRoPE+RF, demonstrating the complementary roles of the two modules: RB strictly preserves the relative positional property while avoiding spatial dimensional degeneracy (as detailed in our response to Weakness 1), and RF mitigates the ambiguity of directional semantics by directly incorporating reference-frame information into relation formation.
References:
[1] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.
[2] Chen et al. ScanRefer: 3D Object Localization in RGB-D Scans Using Natural Language. ECCV, 2020.
Response to Reviewer #5Zxj (1/3)
Weaknesses
Explicitly incorporating 3D positional encoding can directly introduce three-dimensional geometric information into the model, enabling it to more effectively understand spatial relations between objects and thereby improving its spatial reasoning capabilities.
Nevertheless, QuatRoPE [1] has several implementation-level issues that make it difficult to adapt to complex 3D scenes:
Therefore, we propose the Static Relation Branch (RB). By combining multiple linear measurement directions spanning the full three-dimensional space with two-dimensional rotary encoding, RB strictly preserves the relative positional property while avoiding the non-commutativity of 3D rotations and spatial dimensional degeneracy induced by fixed basis vectors.
In addition, the contribution of this work lies in:
Thank you for your question about the clarity of the model components, which helps us to explain our work more accurately.
References:
[1] Zhou et al. Scalable Object Relation Encoding for Better 3D Spatial Reasoning in Large Language Models. CVPR, 2026.
[2] Chen et al. Language Conditioned Spatial Relation Reasoning for 3D Object Grounding. NeurIPS, 2022.
[3] Huang et al. Multi-View Transformer for 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2022.
[4] Guo et al. ViewRefer: Grasp the Multi-view Knowledge for 3D Visual Grounding. ICCV, 2023.
[5] Zhao et al. SpaceMind: Camera-Guided Modality Fusion for Spatial Reasoning in Vision-Language Models. CVPR, 2026.
[6] Chang et al. MiKASA: Multi-Key-Anchor & Scene-Aware Transformer for 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2024.
[7] Zhang et al. Multi-Object 3D Grounding with Dynamic Modules and Language-Informed Spatial Attention. NeurIPS, 2024.
[8] Huang et al. ORD: Object-Relation Decoupling for Generalized 3D Visual Grounding. CVPR, 2026.