1. Poor presentation and insufficient explanation of results
The paper is very difficult to follow. My main concern is not the technical complexity itself, but the lack of clear motivation, intuitive explanations, and interpretation of the results throughout the manuscript.
The Introduction immediately introduces specialized concepts such as differential labels, horizon-order errors, diagonal gains, and material transport, without adequately explaining their meaning or importance. The main contributions are mentioned, but are not clearly motivated or synthesized, making it difficult to understand the overall scientific message.
The presentation problems continue in Section 3, where even central mathematical objects and training objectives are introduced with very limited explanation. For example, the meaning and motivation of the student-dependent label in Eqs. (2), (3), which is fundamental to the paper, are not sufficiently explained. Section 4 follows a similar pattern: the authors introduce mathematical constructions and derive their properties without adequately motivating why these particular quantities are studied. In particular, Theorem 1 introduces formal jets and their spectrum, but the discussion provides limited intuition about why this mathematical characterization is important.
Finally, Section 6 contain many experiments, figures, and numerical measurements. Although the authors discuss individual findings and their immediate implications, I find the broader interpretation and synthesis insufficient. It remains difficult to understand what generalizable knowledge we should extract from the many technical results. The very short Conclusion largely restates the main findings without sufficiently discussing their broader significance.
Overall, the manuscript places too much emphasis on presenting technical calculations and measurements and too little on explaining their motivation, interpretation, and scientific significance. The reader is repeatedly left to reconstruct the scientific argument independently.
2. Unclear novelty and scientific significance
I have serious concerns about the novelty and significance of the contribution. The general observation that different training objectives can share the same desired solution while inducing different learning dynamics is already well known. Previous works have investigated closely related optimization difficulties. In particular, CMT (Hu et al., 2026) analyzes gradient discrepancies between practical consistency-training objectives and oracle regression, while AlphaFlow (Zhang et al., 2026) identifies gradient conflicts in MeanFlow training. The authors briefly discuss these studies in Related Work, but do not sufficiently explain what important questions remain unanswered or how the present paper advances existing understanding.
The main distinctive contribution appears to be the horizon-order characterization of error feedback, including the resulting stability analysis and the role of material transport. However, I do not find its broader significance convincingly established. The main theoretical result is mathematically rather straightforward: the spectral characterization in Theorem 1 follows directly from the triangular structure of the horizon-order operator. Its stability condition applies to an idealized target-space relaxation, rather than directly to practical neural network optimization. Although the authors investigate how the network and optimizer modify the predicted gains, it remains unclear what general or predictive conclusions about practical training dynamics follow from this analysis.
The empirical results are extensive and demonstrate substantial differences between the two supervision methods. The authors also provide gradient diagnostics supporting their proposed mechanism. Nevertheless, it is not clear to what extent the horizon-order analysis explains the observed performance differences, or what important new understanding it provides beyond existing analyses of optimization instability and gradient conflicts. The advantage of endpoint supervision is demonstrated in the studied settings, but the conditions under which this advantage should be expected more generally remain unclear.
Overall, despite the substantial technical effort and empirical evidence, I find the scientific significance of the specific theoretical contribution insufficiently justified. The paper would benefit from a much clearer explanation of what new conceptual understanding its analysis provides, how it advances previous work, and which conclusions extend beyond the particular settings studied.