- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper investigates whether Gaussian representation can serve as a shared output for various image restoration tasks and downstream prediction, and proposes GSAioIR, a Gaussian-based framework for task-conditioned all-in-one image restoration. To handle larger images with reduced memory usage, the method combines global context with cropwise processing. It employs three parallel Gaussian fields with normalised rendering and content-guided weighting (CGW). Experiments demonstrate better performance than Gaussian-based baselines.
Critical strengths
- The paper extends Gaussian-based image restoration to a task-conditioned all-in-one setting, proposing a unified framework to handle multiple degradation types.
- The proposed method outperforms Gaussian-based IR baselines across multiple restoration tasks.
Critical weaknesses
- While the paper aims to investigate whether Gaussian outputs benefit image restoration and downstream tasks, it lacks comparison that isolates the contribution of Gaussian representations from other design choices. Given that the proposed method does not consistently outperform competitive dense-output methods in quantitative comparisons, the motivation for adopting Gaussian representations needs further justification.
- Several components show only marginal improvements in average performance, making their individual contributions somewhat unclear.
Questions for authors
- Could you compare the proposed Gaussian-based framework against dense RGB prediction while keeping all other components unchanged?
3 comments
Dear Reviewers,
Thank you again for your time and consideration of our submission.
We would like to kindly follow up on our previous responses to the reviewers' comments and concerns. We have made our best efforts to address the raised issues through detailed point-by-point responses and revisions to the manuscript.
We fully understand that this is a busy period and sincerely appreciate the time and effort you have devoted to the review process. If you have had an opportunity to look over our responses, we would be very grateful for any further feedback or guidance. Should any concerns remain or further clarification be helpful, we would be more than happy to provide additional explanations.
Thank you once again for your valuable time and consideration. We sincerely appreciate your efforts in handling our submission.
I appreciate the authors' detailed response and the matched dense RGB comparison I requested. Gaussian outputs appear feasible for all-in-one restoration. However, restoration is the paper's central focus, and even in the matched comparison the benefit is mixed. In my view, the downstream results do not fully explain why Gaussian outputs should be preferred for restoration itself, and I still find the rationale for adopting them insufficient. The ablation differences for several components also remain marginal. I therefore maintain my original score.
Response to Reviewer GF4S
Dear Reviewer GF4S,
Thank you for your careful review. We added output controls and a CGW capacity ablation. Manuscript revisions are marked in blue.
Weakness 1. Gaussian contribution and motivation
Response. Gaussian primitives combine explicit spatial supports and attributes in 3D reconstruction. We investigate whether this formulation can support accurate restoration across degradations and extend to semantic prediction and geometric estimation. Spatial supports describe where predictions contribute; task-specific attributes/readouts determine what is predicted.
We added a parameter-matched dense RGB control sharing features and task conditioning. GSAioIR gains 0.2512 dB on the five-task mean and remains competitive with strong dense methods. The control compares complete output systems, including C/M/F, rather than the kernel alone. Restoration and downstream results support the feasibility of this formulation and its potential as a common interface across low- and high-level vision.
Downstream control. With the same frozen Task3 base and attribute projection/readouts, we compare GSAioIR's Gaussian branch with static dense convolution. Four tasks train jointly for 12,000 updates, batch 32 per stream. Tests use CamVid233/Penn–Fudan25/NYUv2 654; each row uses one checkpoint. AP averages IoU 0.50–0.95; AP50 uses 0.50.
GSAioIR gains 4.77 AP points; normal error is 0.03° higher. Both retain restoration because the base is frozen. Sharing one learned geometry remains a research goal.
Manuscript: Abstract/Introduction, pp. 1–2; §4.4/Table 5, p. 9.
Weakness 2. Individual component contributions
Response. These controls retain the Gaussian reconstruction pipeline, with retraining allowing the remaining paths to adapt. CGW only adjusts fine-field aggregation through 648 parameters. Its original gain is 0.0330/0.1091 dB on mean/Rain100L; five-setting averaging makes task-specific gains less visible.
We added Expanded CGW to compare weighting capacity. Each query/key projection uses 80→192→192→80→64→32→4, with 150,888 parameters combined and four-dimensional matching retained.
The added run reports +0.0493 dB over Base, making gains and projection costs explicit. CGW remains a refinement. Original controls use 25 epochs, 111,275 updates, seed 3402; ‡ is the added capacity run. The mean weights SOTS, Rain100L and CBSD68 σ15/25/50 equally.
The original Progressive control omitted preceding-coarse conditioning. Its incorrect configuration is replaced by the updated 31.3074 dB result, not a full serial restoration comparison. Three fields gain 0.0913/0.2693 dB on mean/Rain100L over one Gaussian RGB field. Width 128 slightly exceeds Base at 31.9018 dB, so larger heads are not established as necessary.
Manuscript: §4.5, pp. 9–10; Table 6, p. 10 adds the capacity ablation. §3.4, p. 5 describes aggregation.
Question 1. Matched dense RGB comparison
Response. We retain local/global features and task conditioning, replacing Gaussian prediction/rendering with a width-336, seven-block RGB decoder. Gaussian/dense RGB have 27,847,797/27,846,723 parameters. PSNR is in dB; ΔPSNR is Gaussian minus dense RGB. The mean weights five tasks equally.
Manuscript: §4.1, pp. 7–8; Table 3, p. 8.