- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies target counting and physical spacing estimation for underwater multispectral LiDAR when closely spaced targets produce overlapping, effectively single-peaked echoes. Water-induced temporal broadening further hides the second peak, so counting visible peaks does not determine the number of targets.
The authors build an underwater multispectral LiDAR system at four wavelengths and collect two measured full-waveform datasets in a 60 m water tank. One is a single-target reference library. The other is a multiband multi-target library with physical spacing labels.
They propose AquaSR. Its core PC-JMD module shares target count and physical spacing across bands while keeping echo shape, amplitude, first-target delay, and background band-specific. A frozen MMD-WAE decoder pretrained on single-target echoes supplies a continuous single-echo shape prior. Target count is chosen by comparing reliability-weighted reconstruction residuals under one- and two-target hypotheses, and six physical-attribute experts then refine the spacing.
Validation on a range-disjoint test set compares AquaSR with five classical decomposition methods and one learning baseline (AFD-Net), together with multi-seed module ablations, six backbones, and runtime analysis. AquaSR reports single-target and dual-target counting with the lowest conditional spacing MAE (0.48 cm) and bias (0.25 cm).
Critical strengths
-
A real measurement system with a physically grounded and internally consistent method. The authors build a four-wavelength underwater multispectral LiDAR and collect two real full-waveform datasets. The PC-JMD factorization, which shares target count and physical spacing while keeping shapes band-specific, is supported by a curvature analysis and an independent frozen-template BIC study.
-
Counting from competing generative explanations rather than a standalone classifier, with cross-architecture evidence. Deciding the target count from one- versus two-target reconstruction residuals under a frozen single-echo prior is more principled than a feature classifier. The module ablations and six backbones substantiate both the design choices and the claimed backbone agnosticism.
Critical weaknesses
1.Limited external validity. All results use static targets in one tank under a single water condition on a small held-out set whose single/dual counts are not reported. The headline challenge of water-induced broadening is never varied along the turbidity or broadening axis, even though a new water condition would push the frozen single-echo shape prior out of distribution, and that prior directly drives the one-versus-two decision.
2.An application-driven integration of established techniques with a new dataset, whose two sources of value are not yet secured. The cross-band geometric-consistency idea is already the basis of MSWD and Rclonte, and the WAE prior, competing-hypothesis model selection, and physics-guided experts are also established. The novelty is their non-trivial combination for underwater multispectral LiDAR rather than a new mechanism.
Questions for authors
1.Robustness to water-induced broadening. What are the optical properties of the tank water (attenuation/scattering coefficients), and are training and test data taken from the same water body? Because the frozen single-echo prior drives the one-versus-two decision, can you report counting and spacing results over two or three turbidity levels, or a synthetic sweep of the broadening-kernel width, separating zero-shot transfer from recalibration?
2.Isolating the cross-band sharing gain. The ablations only remove components within AquaSR. Can you add a controlled comparison that aligns hard sharing of count and spacing with the soft cross-channel consistency of MSWD and the cross-wavelength matching of Rclonte under the same data and backbone, to isolate the gain attributable to the proposed factorization?
3.Test-set composition. Please state the single/dual event counts and distance distribution of the main test set in Table 1 (the percentages imply roughly 44 single and 57 dual events) and list the ranges used for training, validation, and test.
Thank you for your valuable time and constructive feedback. Due to time constraints, we have temporarily placed the new experiments and analyses in the Appendix (highlighted in blue, starting from page 23), and will integrate the key results into the main text in the final revision. We hope our responses address your concerns, and we appreciate your understanding.
Q1 Water conditions and zero-shot transfer
The tank contained tap water, with a recorded attenuation coefficient of 0.1 m⁻¹ at 500 nm; the scattering coefficient was not measured separately. Training and testing largely used this water, although different ranges were sometimes acquired on different days (Appendix F.1).
Archived single-target data acquired after three days without water replacement provide a transfer check. The water appeared more turbid, but turbidity was not quantified. At 532 nm, pulse width narrowed from 2.312 to 2.173 ns (about 6%). Without retraining or recalibration, AquaSR correctly identified the cases as single-target; dual-target spacing was not evaluated under this condition (Appendix F.2–F.3).
Spatial variation along the long water path prevented a reproducible quantitative turbidity sweep. The apparatus has been dismantled for miniaturization; marine measurements at different depths are planned for early next year (Appendix F.4).
Q2 Controlled cross-band comparison
We compared independent decomposition (I), soft consistency (S), MSWD-style (M), Rclonte-style (R), and native AquaSR using identical splits, backbone, and frozen single-echo decoder. AquaSR includes reliability fusion, consensus, and correction.
S penalizes count-probability (Jensen–Shannon) and spacing (Smooth-L1) disagreement, with validation-tuned weights and a spacing penalty during refinement. M retains energy ranking, completion, and shared-center fitting (zero offsets for aligned inputs). R retains center ranking, correspondence screening, completion, and per-band fitting with adjustable spacings.
M and R use a shared decoder in place of Gaussian components, matched initialization, one-/two-target hypotheses, residual count selection, and fitting budgets, while retaining distinct cross-band mechanisms. Event-level MAE counts each synchronized multiband event once; the main comparison aggregates valid bands. Across three seeds, AquaSR has the lowest mean MAE (0.505 ± 0.026 cm) and smallest standard deviation. All five methods reach 100% counting accuracy, isolating spacing differences (Appendix G.2; Table G.2).
Q3 Independent events and held-out spacings
The 10 m test set comprises 26 independent events (11 single-target, 15 dual-target). The 44 and 57 entries in band-weighted metrics are valid single- and dual-target band waveforms (101 total), not independent events. Each measured split contains one dual-target event at each of 15 nominal spacings (Appendix H.1; Table H.1).
Training, validation, and testing use 8, 12, and 10 m data, respectively. For each configuration, 1,000 technical repetitions are screened and averaged; excluded channels are listed in Table H.2 (rationale in Appendix H.2). Training and validation also use superpositions of measured single-target echoes. The test set is measured-only, and no 10 m data enter prior learning, synthetic-data construction, or fine-tuning.
In ten leave-one-measured-spacing-out evaluations, each selected spacing's measured training/validation examples were removed while its 10 m test event was retained. Absolute errors improved at 13, 23, 28, and 35 cm (0.21→0.16, 0.85→0.40, 1.48→1.02, and 0.29→0.03 cm). Nine of ten full-test MAEs were below 1 cm; their mean was 0.681 cm versus the 0.48 cm reference, with the 28 cm exclusion improving to 0.46 cm. Other folds worsened (Appendix I.1–I.3; Table I.1). Appendix J.3 sets out our plan to release the dataset and core code upon acceptance and extend the dataset through future marine trials.
Others: Clarification on Critical Weaknesses 2
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the application-driven contribution and new dataset. Aligned with our Primary Area (Applications to Physical Sciences). The methodological contribution is a coupled, physics-guided inference formulation for multiband underwater LiDAR: shared physical-coordinate consensus before wavelength-specific synthesis, a frozen measured single-echo prior coupled to reconstruction-based count selection, and count-preserving geometric correction. Appendix G.4 explains these mechanisms relative to MSWD/Rclonte, with controlled comparisons (G.2–G.3) and the main-text ablations (Table 2).