- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents FinerSplat, a feed-forward framework for refining and compacting sparse-view 3D Gaussian Splatting representations without per-scene optimization. The method uses a frozen diffusion model to restore renderings from under-constrained target views, lifts the resulting image-space residuals into Gaussian-level feedback through differentiable rendering contributions, and employs an entropy-aware KNN Transformer to iteratively update Gaussian attributes while predicting primitive keep scores for pruning. 16873 The approach is evaluated on DL3DV and Waymo against feed-forward, optimization-based, and diffusion-based baselines. The reported results show improved rendering quality and efficient reconstruction, while pruning about 30% of the initialized Gaussians with little degradation in rendering performance.
Critical strengths
-
FinerSplat introduces a meaningful diffusion-guided refinement strategy for feed-forward 3DGS. It lifts target-view restoration residuals to Gaussian-level feedback, helping improve under-constrained regions without per-scene optimization.
-
The method achieves a strong quality–efficiency trade-off. It improves rendering quality with 0.61 s reconstruction time while pruning about 30% of the initialized Gaussians, with ablations supporting the effectiveness of its main components.
Critical weaknesses
Critical Weaknesses
-
The reported ablation results contain a clear internal inconsistency that weakens confidence in the empirical evidence. Table 3 reports the Full Model as 23.12 / 0.717 / 0.202 (PSNR/SSIM/LPIPS), whereas Table 4 reports 22.71 / 0.717 / 0.243 for the default pruning ratio . Since the default pruning configuration should correspond to the reported full model, these values should be consistent, yet both PSNR and LPIPS differ substantially and the manuscript provides no explanation. This directly affects the reliability of the ablation and pruning conclusions.
-
Several central components of the proposed refinement pipeline are insufficiently specified, making both the method and its efficiency claims difficult to verify. Eq. (4) concatenates a ResNet-derived feature residual with an RGB residual without defining how their spatial resolutions are aligned; Eq. (9) introduces without specifying how operates on the different constrained Gaussian parameters; and Eq. (12) does not clearly define the keep-score range or the deletion prior. In addition, the four target views used for diffusion-based refinement are not selected by a clearly specified protocol, even though their poses directly determine the information available to the method. Finally, the reported 0.61 s runtime is presented without a breakdown despite the additional rendering, diffusion restoration, residual propagation, and recurrent refinement stages. Together, these omissions make it difficult to reproduce the method precisely or determine whether the reported efficiency is directly comparable to feed-forward baselines.
Questions for authors
-
The reported ablation results contain a clear internal inconsistency. Table 3 reports the Full Model as 23.12 / 0.717 / 0.202 (PSNR/SSIM/LPIPS), while Table 4 reports 22.71 / 0.717 / 0.243 for the default pruning ratio . These values do not match, and the discrepancy is not addressed in the manuscript. This raises concerns about the reliability of the reported ablation and pruning results.
-
Several core operations of the method are mathematically under-specified. In Eq. (4), the ResNet-derived feature residual is concatenated with an RGB residual without defining how their spatial resolutions are aligned. Eq. (9) introduces the update , but the operator is not specified for different Gaussian parameters. Eq. (12) also does not explicitly define the range of the keep score or the computation of the deletion prior . These omissions concern central parts of the proposed refinement and pruning mechanism and make the formulation difficult to verify precisely.
-
The target-view refinement protocol is insufficiently specified. The method uses four additional target views for diffusion-based restoration after initializing the scene from four context images, but the paper does not clearly define how these target camera poses are selected. Since the proposed refinement explicitly depends on feedback from these additional viewpoints, their selection directly affects the amount and difficulty of information available to the method, making the experimental protocol difficult to assess and reproduce.
-
The reported efficiency is insufficiently substantiated given the additional diffusion-based processing required by the method. FinerSplat reports a reconstruction time of 0.61 s, comparable to conventional feed-forward baselines, despite additionally rendering target views, running a diffusion restoration model, propagating residuals to Gaussians, and performing recurrent refinement. The paper does not provide a runtime breakdown for these components, making it difficult to assess whether the reported timing is directly comparable to the baselines.