acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Translation as a Bridging Action: Transferring Manipulation Skills from Humans to Robots

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

We study whether we can learn novel manipulation skills from human actions to a bi-manual robot with parallel grippers. Benefiting from the robot-free setting, human action data becomes one of the most scalable sources for manipulation data. However, transferring manipulation skills from humans to robots remains hard: most prior work treats humans as just another bi-manual 6DoF embodiment, where hand-pose estimates are noisy and the contact patterns of human fingers differ fundamentally from those of a parallel gripper. We argue that learning rotation-inclusive action signals from human data is therefore sub-optimal and instead propose a bridging action representation, *i.e.*, the relative wrist translation within the head-camera frame, an action space shared by humans and robots. To handle the potential absence of the 6DoF end-effector action or gripper signal in human data, we build a -like vision-language-action model with interleaved action tokens. On a suite of bi-manual manipulation tasks seen only in human action data, our bridging action enables a superior success rate of 22.50% over naively adopting noisy 6DoF actions 12.50%, and can be further improved to 38.33% with large-scale human-only pre-training.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Multi-Modality, Vision-Language-Action Models, Robotics

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_CMWwOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates how manipulation skills learned from human action data can be transferred to a dual-arm robot equipped with parallel grippers. To address noise in human wrist-pose estimation and differences in human–robot contact patterns, the authors propose a Bridging Action based on relative 3D wrist translation as a shared action representation. They also introduce an Interleaved Action Sequence within a π₀-like VLA architecture to accommodate missing action components across data sources and enable human–robot co-training.

The method is evaluated on 15 real-robot manipulation tasks across four categories. Compared with directly using human 6DoF actions, the proposed approach increases the average task success rate from 12.50% to 22.50%, and further to 38.33% with large-scale human-only pre-training. Ablation studies indicate that jointly supervising Bridging Action on human and robot data is important for skill transfer.

Critical strengths

To address noise in human wrist-rotation estimates and differences in human–robot contact patterns, the authors propose shared 3D wrist translation as an action representation. The idea is simple and reasonably motivated, and the experiments provide preliminary evidence of its effectiveness.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficient Experimental Validation:
  • Missing core comparison. Table 2 compares 3D and 6DoF without human-only pre-training, whereas the full method includes large-scale human pre-training. The authors should add a 6DoF baseline with the same pre-training setup.
  • Limited evaluation scale and lenient success criteria. Each task is tested only eight times across two scene layouts; some success criteria are permissive (e.g., opening a microwave door by 50% counts as success). The authors should increase the number and diversity of trials, apply stricter success criteria, and report statistical analyses.
  • Inconsistent post-training gains. Figure 4 shows performance declines on some tasks after post-training. The authors should investigate the cause and assess training stability through repeated experiments.
  1. Limited Methodological Novelty:
  • Prior work, such as MimicPlay[1] has already used 3D hand trajectories for human-to-robot manipulation skill transfer. The main distinction here is to use 3D wrist translation as shared human–robot action supervision within a VLA; however, its substantive novelty relative to prior approaches remains limited. Moreover, the Interleaved Action Sequence largely relies on existing Transformer token organization and masking mechanisms.

[1] Wang, C., et al. "MimicPlay: Long-Horizon Imitation Learning by Watching Human Play." Conference on Robot Learning (CoRL), 2023. https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.12422

Questions for authors
  1. Fairness of the core baseline: Table 2 only compares 3D and 6DoF methods co-trained from scratch, while the full method includes large-scale human pre-training. Why is there no 6DoF baseline under the same pre-training conditions? Could this comparison change the paper’s central conclusion?
  2. Reliability of the evaluation: Each task has only eight trials, and some task-success criteria are lenient. Can the authors report results using stricter success criteria and provide repeated evaluations or statistical analyses to establish the reliability of the reported improvements?
  3. Post-training performance degradation: Figure 4 shows declining performance for some tasks after post-training. How do the authors explain this behavior, and does the decline persist across repeated training runs and evaluations?
Reviewer_6LT2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the problem of transferring manipulation skills from scalable, robot-free human demonstration videos and poses to a bi-manual robot equipped with parallel grippers. The core premise is that directly treating human demonstrations as 6DoF robot trajectories introduces detrimental errors due to noisy hand-pose estimation and morphological divergence between articulated human fingers and rigid parallel grippers. To bypass rotational noise, the authors propose using the relative wrist translation in the head-camera frame as a shared "bridging action representation". To integrate heterogeneous data sources with missing action components (in-the-wild video lacking gripper states and 6DoF actions), the authors construct a π0-like vision-language-action (VLA) model utilizing interleaved action tokens ([a_3D-wrist -> a_6D-eef -> a_gripper]) optimized via flow matching. The training recipe follows three sequential stages: human-only pretraining on ~600 hours of bridging actions, human-robot co-training on ~72 hours of robot pick-and-place paired with ~45 hours of in-lab human demonstrations, and few-shot robot fine-tuning. The system is evaluated on 15 real-world bi-manual manipulation tasks. The authors report that training with bridging actions achieves a 22.50% overall success rate from scratch (outperforming a naive 6DoF human action baseline at 12.50%), which increases to 38.33% with large-scale pretraining and 55.00% after 10-shot robot fine-tuning.

Critical strengths
  1. Real-Robot Bi-Manual Hardware Validation and Controlled Disentanglement: The authors validate their pipeline on a physical bi-manual manipulation setup across 15 multi-step household tasks (involving microwaves, drawers, mugs, and tabletop objects). Furthermore, the diagnostic experiment in Section 5.4 (Table 4) provides a valuable controlled study: by constructing a "gap-free" robot-to-robot bridging reference (achieving 55.83% success), the paper cleanly isolates the impact of observation viewpoint gaps and human tracking noise from the bridging representation itself.

  2. Flexible Multi-Modal Supervision via Token Interleaving: Organizing diverse action modalities into an interleaved token sequence within a single transformer backbone (Section 4.2) offers an architecturally unified method to ingest heterogeneous datasets (in-the-wild video, in-lab human data, and teleoperated robot data) without designing ad-hoc projection heads for each embodiment.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Unacknowledged Conceptual and Methodological Overlap with Traj2Action (arXiv:2510.00491): The foundational thesis and technical formulation of this paper—namely, that human hand-pose estimation exhibits severe rotational noise and contact discrepancy with parallel grippers, making operational endpoint / wrist 3D translation the optimal shared intermediate bridging representation to condition a π0-style flow-matching VLA—is conceptually and functionally near-identical to Traj2Action: A Co-Denoising Framework for Trajectory-Guided Human-to-Robot Skill Transfer (arXiv:2510.00491). Both works argue that rotation should be excluded from cross-embodiment human priors, both use 3D Cartesian endpoint trajectories as intermediate bridging representations, and both co-train a flow-matching VLA on human trajectories and robot demonstrations. The current submission neither cites nor discusses arXiv:2510.00491. While this work expands the experimental setup to bi-manual tasks and replaces the dual-expert module with token interleaving, the core scientific proposition has already been established in prior literature without proper attribution.

  2. Severe Disconnect Between Architectural Narrative and Inference Execution (Technical Soundness Flaw): In Section 4.2, the authors explicitly state that action tokens are ordered as a_3D-wrist -> a_6D-eef -> a_gripper so that "the shared bridging signal should be attended to by the 6DoF action tokens, enabling explicit manipulation knowledge transfer from human to robot within the attention layer." However, in Section 4.3 (Stage II) and Section 4.2, the authors reveal: "In practice, we randomly drop either a_3D-wrist or a_6D-eef during training. Dropping a_3D-wrist enables us to generate solely a_6D-eef for inference." During test-time deployment on the physical robot, the bridging token a_3D-wrist is completely dropped and never generated or conditioned upon. Consequently, the claim that 6DoF tokens explicitly attend to the bridging action during rollouts is factually incorrect at inference time. The mechanism reduces to standard multi-task parameter sharing rather than an active trajectory-conditioned generation pipeline.

  3. Complete Omission of Rotational Supervision Causes Capability Ceilings and Extremely Low Absolute Success: Discarding wrist rotation entirely creates a crippling inductive bottleneck. Because human demonstrations supply zero orientation signals, the robot must extrapolate 6DoF orientations purely from generic pick-and-place robot data. As shown in the authors' own failure analysis (Section 5.5, Figure 6 and Appendix Figure 11), tasks requiring precise angular alignment fail catastrophically (e.g., "Insert Straw into Cup" achieves 0.00% success; "Open Drawer" fails to grasp handles). An overall success rate of 22.50% from scratch and 38.33% after 600 hours of pretraining indicates that the learned policy remains largely unreliable for real-world deployment.

  4. Absence of External Baselines and Statistical Rigor: The empirical validation compares solely against an internally constructed "naive 6DoF human action" baseline and ablation variants. The paper lacks comparisons against established human-to-robot transfer methods (e.g., AnyTeleop, DexCap, or affordance/point-tracking approaches). Furthermore, Tables 2, 3, and 4 report single evaluation values over a small number of rollouts without standard deviations or multi-seed trials.

Questions for authors

My questions can be found in the above weakness part.

Reviewer_RuMiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates how human demonstration data enable bimanual robots to acquire manipulation skills absent from the robot training data. The authors use relative wrist translation in a head-mounted camera coordinate frame as a shared bridging action to mitigate the effects of rotation-estimation noise and differences between human and robot contact patterns. The model uses interleaved action tokens and combines pretraining on human demonstrations with human–robot co-training to connect the shared representation to executable robot end-effector actions. Across 15 real-world manipulation tasks, co-training without the large-scale human-only pretraining stage achieves a success rate of 22.50%, compared with 12.50% for a simple 6DoF human-action baseline; adding human-only pretraining raises the success rate to 38.33%.

Critical strengths
  1. The main text and appendix are well organized. The action definitions, supervision associated with each data source, and staged training procedure are clearly described, making the method easy to follow.
  2. The experimental design includes targeted controls for evaluating human-to-robot skill transfer. In the main setting, robot training data contain only pick-and-place demonstrations, whereas demonstrations of the target skills come exclusively from humans. This separation helps distinguish transfer from human demonstrations from direct learning of the target skills using robot data.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological contribution appears incremental. The proposed bridging action is primarily motivated by noisy human wrist-rotation estimates and the mismatch between human-hand and parallel-gripper contact patterns. This observation provides a reasonable basis for training with heterogeneous data. However, the resulting modification appears limited in scope, and the paper does not sufficiently establish its significance as a standalone methodological contribution for ICLR.

  2. The main paper lacks comparisons with representative VLA or WAM methods. The main-text experiments focus on ablations of the proposed method rather than comparisons against established approaches. Benchmark comparisons in simulation or on real robots, under comparable evaluation conditions, are important for assessing the method’s performance relative to existing methods.

  3. The low absolute success rates leave the practical significance unclear. The evaluation includes tasks that appear relatively simple, yet the full model achieves an overall success rate of 38.33% without task-specific robot demonstrations. Together with the absence of broader comparisons against established methods, these results leave insufficient evidence that the proposed training modification provides a substantial practical advantage.

Questions for authors
  1. In the definition of a6D-eef\mathbf{a}^{\mathrm{6D\text{-}eef}}, does the reference position correspond to the first frame of the entire task episode or to the first frame of each action chunk?

  2. How does the method define “human hand closure,” given that a single human hand has more than 20 degrees of freedom and supports a wide range of configurations?

  3. With the bridging supervision and handling of missing components held fixed, how much additional benefit do interleaved action tokens provide over concatenation/padding or alternative token orderings?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.