- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PDEG, a cross-embodiment imitation-learning framework combining shared predictive modeling with embodiment-specific encoding and control grounding, without explicit action-space alignment. Experiments on three manipulation tasks using three end effectors mounted on the same RM65 arm report improved success rates over UVA and adapted EgoMimic, alongside lower parameter growth per embodiment.
Critical strengths
-
The paper provides a conceptually clear alternative to explicit cross-embodiment action alignment by sharing predictive interaction dynamics while retaining embodiment-specific control interfaces.
-
The Single and Multi comparison keeps the target-embodiment data budget and predictive initialization fixed, providing reasonably controlled evidence that additional heterogeneous demonstrations can improve target-embodiment performance.
Critical weaknesses
-
The conclusion that cross-embodiment transfer does not require action alignment appears stronger than the current evidence supports. All three embodiments share the same RM65 arm and differ only in their end effectors, and the evaluation covers only three relatively simple manipulation tasks. It remains unclear whether the approach can handle broader embodiment gaps involving different arm kinematics, workspaces, and control structures.
-
Despite positioning explicit action alignment as the main alternative, the paper does not provide a controlled comparison with alignment-based approaches. Therefore, the experiments show that PDEG can achieve positive transfer without explicit alignment, but do not establish whether avoiding alignment is preferable, or under what conditions alignment is unnecessary.
Questions for authors
-
Why not evaluate cross-embodiment transfer under a more rigorous setting where the evaluated task is absent from the target embodiment’s training data but present in the training data of the other embodiments? Given the three relatively simple tasks considered in the paper, such an evaluation seems feasible and would provide more convincing evidence of cross-embodiment transfer.
-
Why are both Stage I and Stage II need 500 training epochs? Given the relatively limited size of the dataset, this appears to be a large training budget. Could the authors report the actual epochs of the validation-selected checkpoints and clarify whether such a long training horizon is necessary?
As we near the end of the discussion period for this submission, please check whether the authors have answered questions or responded to critiques. If they have, we encourage the reviewers to leave a comment for the authors. If reviewers have raised new points, a gentle nudge to the authors to respond would also be appreciated.