- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes RadGenome-Anatomy, a dataset for anatomy segmentation on chest X-rays. It is built from RadGenome-ChestCT, which provides organ-level segmentation masks. The authors project the 3D CT volumes and their masks into synthetic PA and LL radiographs. They benchmark several segmentation models on the dataset and demonstrate how predicted masks can support anatomical measurements for assessing cardiomegaly, scoliosis, and thoracic kyphosis.
Critical strengths
- The dataset addresses a meaningful annotation challenge by providing geometrically consistent masks for overlapping anatomical structures that are difficult to annotate directly on chest X-rays.
- The real-image evaluation and measurement-based applications provide initial evidence that the dataset can support anatomy segmentation.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited novelty. The projection and measurement pipeline follows prior work such as PAX-Ray++. The main contribution is expanded dataset scale and anatomical coverage.
- Insufficient label quality validation. The manual correction process is unclear, and direct expert assessment of the projected labels is lacking. Real-image validation mainly covers the lungs and heart.
- Insufficient evidence of practical value. The comparison with VLMs does not isolate the dataset’s contribution, as the segmentation-based pipeline uses task-specific geometric rules. The paper does not establish whether the dataset improves performance over strong chest X-ray segmentation baselines or adds value beyond existing training data.
Questions for authors
- ChestCT provides segmentation masks for 197 categories, whereas this dataset contains 210 classes. What accounts for this difference, and how were the additional or modified labels generated?
- Who performed the manual corrections shown in Figure 1? Were clinicians involved, and what proportion of the data was reviewed? How was label quality assessed?
Minor presentation issues include a repeated sentence in the Introduction (lines 42–44), an awkward paragraph break around line 182.