- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes DiLAST for reference-image-guided 3D style transfer. It uses a pretrained 2D diffusion model to guide sampling in the latent space of a pretrained 3D generator. Attention distillation transfers style, while a content loss and two regularization terms preserve structure and reduce artifacts. Experiments show stylization results on TRELLIS and extensions to UniLat3D and Hunyuan3D.
Critical strengths
-
Applying 2D style guidance to a pretrained 3D latent space is useful. The presented results transfer a range of styles while preserving recognizable object structure. The examples on different 3D generators also suggest that the approach is not restricted to TRELLIS.
-
The floater removal and color speckle suppression terms address practical problems during optimization. Figure 5 shows their effects on the generated assets.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main concern is the methodological novelty. Using 2D diffusion priors to optimize 3D representations has been studied extensively, starting with DreamFusion. More closely, DiffStyle3D already uses diffusion attention features to guide 3D style transfer. The style and content losses in Eqs. (7)-(8) are adopted from Attention Distillation, which the paper cites. The main difference appears to be applying this guidance during sampling in a pretrained structured 3D latent space, rather than directly optimizing an existing 3D representation. This is a reasonable adaptation, but the paper should explain more clearly what additional technical contribution it provides.
-
The comparisons do not establish the advantage over existing 2D-diffusion-guided 3D stylization. Table 1 compares with MorphAny3D and StyleSculptor, while Appendix C.2 considers transfer-then-generate approaches. These are useful comparisons, but they do not test whether directly optimizing the generated 3D asset with 2D diffusion guidance would achieve similar results. DiffStyle3D optimizes the color parameters of an existing 3DGS scene, so its original task differs from DiLAST. An adapted comparison starting from the same content-conditioned 3D asset would help show the benefit of optimizing the 3D latent during sampling. The comparison should account for optimization time, given DiLAST's 500-step procedure.
Questions for authors
- How does DiLAST compare with direct 3DGS optimization, or optimization of the final clean 3D latent, using comparable style supervision and optimization time?
- How many content-style pairs are evaluated in Table 1, and how are the claimed OOD styles defined?