- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses cross-subject generalization in biomedical time-series classification by modeling individual variation as reusable conditional shifts. The authors introduce a subject-conditioned refinement framework that constructs a semantic anchor with individual-conditioned MoE adaptation. Experiments on seven datasets against 15 baselines demonstrate strong classification performance, supported by ablation and representation analyses.
Critical strengths
Interesting problem and clear presentation. The paper starts from a meaningful problem and tells a clear story. I particularly like how the authors use visualizations to explain their motivation and ideas. Overall, the paper is well written and easy to follow.
Strong experimental results. The authors have clearly put substantial effort into the experiments, covering seven datasets, 15 baselines, and several ablation studies. The results are convincing in showing that the full pipeline works well and is computationally efficient.
Critical weaknesses
The experiments do not fully support the original motivation. The authors provide extensive results showing that the proposed architecture works well, but it is unclear to me why the semantic anchor and individual context actually represent the claimed information, or how the learned residual captures reusable individual variation. The experiments mainly validate the architectural design, the overall pipeline, rather than establishing a clear connection to the original research question.
Unclear novelty and incomplete related work. I like the two motivating observations: task semantics and individual variation can overlap, and individual variation may contain reusable structure. However, these ideas are not entirely new. The related work mainly discusses approaches that suppress individual variation but does not sufficiently cover existing methods. Although the proposed architecture is well motivated, it is still unclear what the main scientific contribution is compared with prior individual-aware approaches.
Questions for authors
Representation decomposition. Why can the proposed decomposition be interpreted as separating task-related semantics from individual information? I do not see clear evidence that these representations actually correspond to the claimed physiological meanings. Can the authors justify this interpretation beyond showing better classification results of the overall pipeline?
Scientific contribution. What is the main scientific contribution of this work relative to prior individual-aware and subject-adaptive learning? I would appreciate a clearer discussion of related approaches that already model or leverage individual variation, and an explanation of what this work adds beyond them. This would help me better assess the novelty.
Thank you for the detailed response and the additional experiments. The clarifications regarding the Figure 3 protocol, the reframing of the anchor–context split as a functional division rather than strict disentanglement, and the additional controls on correction pathways and expert routing have addressed several of my concerns. I have increased my Soundness score accordingly. However, I remain unconvinced that the revisions sufficiently address my main concerns, particularly regarding the necessity of individual-conditioned refinement and the extent to which the motivation, proposed method, and supporting evidence are aligned. Therefore, I do not believe a change in my overall rating is warranted at this stage.