- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes MULTA (Mutli-Level Transport Alignment) for time-series domain generalization. MULTA is a balanced optimal transport objective and learns a globally organized transport structure in the unit representation space. The globally balanced optimal transport yields a tighter bound on class-conditional source variation than row-wise local matching.
Critical strengths
- The abstract and Introduction section motivate the challenge very well and clarify the contributions of the paper. The paper is easy to understand.
- The main methodological strength is the mathematically transparent analysis connecting the objective to representation geometry.
Critical weaknesses
Weaknesses:
- A visualization of the proposed theoretical alignment would help to understand Section 4 better.
- The evaluation contains a comparison to several state-of-the-art techniques. Why are many domain adaptation techniques not included? Most of the baseline methods are 2 years old. Methods such as DAN, CDAN, HoMM, CoDATS, AdvSKM, CPDA, Bures alignment techniques, and also Slices Wasserstein DA are not included. Furthermore, there exist recent architecture-specific time-series DA methods, such as CauDiTS, TransPL, LCA, VLH-DA, DWLR, TA4LS, CADT, TF-DAN, FADA-SPL, CATS, and Rainforest. Furthermore, I think the contribution in the related work section is insufficiently distinguished from the closest prior transport-based and contrastive learning methods.
- While the results of MULTA perform significantly better than comparison techniques on the P2018, DSADS, USC, HAR, EMG, and PAMAP datasets, the improvement are marginal for other datasets, including ISRUC (no improvement), Sleep-EDFx, SHH, HMC, etc.
- Regarding the ablation study: Component ablations and sensitivity analyses are restricted to EMG and PAMAP2, using three seeds. There are no corresponding ablations on sleep staging, despite its different signal characteristics and dataset-level shifts.
- The limitations section state that “MULTA introduces additional computational overhead due to optimal transport estimation”. How large is the overhead compared to state-of-the-art techniques? A comparison of training/inference times and RAM usage would be necessary. The batchwise transport matrices require quadratic storage, yet the paper provides no controlled runtime or peak-memory comparison against ERM and SupCon.
Minor:
- In Figure c (e to h), the axis labels and unit are missing.
Reproduciblity:
- I had a look on the source code and appendix and believe that the paper is reproducible. Datasets are publicly available.
- Appendix I uses pairwise, two-sided paired t-tests over only five seeds, without a reported multiple-comparison correction. With approximately 20 methods, this produces many comparisons per task -> however, the five training runs provide limited support for assessing distributional assumptions.
Questions for authors
See the questions in the weaknesses
Response to Reviewer NBpn
We thank the reviewer for this constructive feedback which greatly improved the clarity and quality of our original manuscript. We have expanded the baseline methods as well as the number of tasks and the random seed number for the ablation and sensitivity analyses with the manuscript being updated as well.
W1. Magnitude and consistency of improvements
We agree that “consistently improves” should distinguish aggregate performance from improvements on every individual target. MULTA achieves the highest average balanced accuracy on both benchmarks, although the magnitude of improvement varies across datasets. We have revised the wording in the abstract, introduction, experiments and etc. to make this distinction explicit.
To strengthen this comparison, we have added four recent methods with public code that cover complementary approaches: COGS (AAAI 2026) for causal representation learning [1], DCCL (KDD 2025) for domain-connecting contrastive learning [2], CorSW (KDD 2026) for sliced-Wasserstein alignment of correlation distributions [3], and PhASER (TMLR 2025) for phase-aware learning in nonstationary time series [4].
Sleep cross-dataset DG
HAROOD cross-person DG
Both tables report balanced accuracy in the form of mean ± SD across the same five seeds as the main paper. We also apply the Benjamini–Hochberg (BH) correction[5] within each target task to control false positives from multiple testing while retaining our original significance rank definition.
Across both benchmarks, MULTA still achieves the highest average balanced accuracy and maintains the best BH-corrected significance rank of 1. These comparisons support its effectiveness alongside recent causal, contrastive, transport-based, and time-series-specific DG approaches.
Theorem 1 also clarifies the limits of our claim: MULTA addresses variation across source domains, while the bound separately includes the unseen domain’s discrepancy from its closest source distribution mixtures. Source-only training cannot measure or guarantee a reduction in this term, so the analysis does not imply uniform gains across unseen targets.