- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
APAS-VLA proposes an adaptive action temporal scaling framework aimed at addressing the low physical execution efficiency of VLA models caused by slow teleoperated demonstrations. Its core idea is to take larger action strides during stable motion phases while retaining dense action coverage during fine-grained, contact-rich manipulation phases. Specifically, APAS first introduces an Offline Temporal Teacher that combines Generation Instability and Action Variation to generate token-speed labels. Next, a lightweight Token-Speed Predictor (-Predictor) is trained to predict the temporal stride of each action token within an action chunk (i.e., the token-speed profile) based on the current observation. Finally, a Profile-Conditioned Action Expert (-Action Expert) directly generates actions conditioned on the predicted speed profile. Experiments on LIBERO, CALVIN, and a real-world robot validate its effectiveness, substantially reducing execution steps and task completion time while largely preserving task success rates.
Critical strengths
1.The motivation of this paper is clear, directly targeting the low physical execution efficiency of VLA policies. By introducing adaptive temporal resolution, the method achieves significant execution speedup while maintaining high task success rates.
2.The ablation studies are comprehensive and effectively demonstrate the contribution of each proposed component.
3.The figures and visualizations are well-designed, clear, and aesthetically pleasing.
Critical weaknesses
1.The paper seems omits a substantial number of highly relevant prior works [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Broadly speaking, endowing policies with adaptive temporal resolution during training is not a new concept. However, the authors appear not to have conducted a thorough literature survey, discussion, or comparison with these closely related methods—especially considering that most of the works listed below were already publicly available on arXiv or accepted at conferences at least four months prior to the ICLR submission deadline.
2.As noted in the Strengths section, while the ablation studies show that the individual components work as intended, the effectiveness of such adaptive temporal scaling components has largely already been validated by prior works in this line of research.
3.Benchmark selection: In my view, reporting standard LIBERO as the primary benchmark is no longer an ideal choice today, as the benchmark is heavily saturated. Evaluating and reporting primary results on more challenging and less saturated benchmarks, such as LIBERO-Plus or RoboTwin 2.0, would be much more convincing. I view this both as a weakness of the current evaluation and as a constructive suggestion based on practical experience: on benchmarks like LIBERO-Plus or RoboTwin 2.0, the proposed method might simultaneously demonstrate stronger task success rates and higher execution efficiency, rather than appearing to trade off task performance for execution efficiency as seen on standard LIBERO in Table 1 (where APAS achieves 96.25% vs. Vanilla's 96.85%).
Reference
[1] SpeedAug: Policy Acceleration via Tempo-Enriched Policy and RL Fine-Tuning
[2] AutoSpeed: Annotation-Free Stage-Adaptive Motion Speed Learning for Robot Manipulation
[3] SkiP: When to Skip and When to Refine for Efficient Robot Manipulation
[4] Speedup Patch: Learning a Plug-and-Play Policy to Accelerate Embodied Manipulation
[5] FrameSkip: Learning from Fewer but More Informative Frames in VLA Training
Questions for authors
1.Referring to Weakness 1, could the authors discuss the missing related works [1–5] and clarify the core technical contributions and distinct advantages of APAS-VLA compared to them?
2.In the component ablation study in Table 5, according to the paper, the APAS w/o τ-Expert variant applies post-hoc retiming to the outputs of a Vanilla-trained action expert, resulting in a drastic drop in success rate (49.60%). What would happen if the standard (unconditioned) action expert were still trained directly on the Retimed Demonstration Targets (generated by the proposed Offline Temporal Teacher) without explicit -prediction and -conditioning at inference time? Fundamentally, my concern is whether explicitly predicting and conditioning on the token-speed profile is truly necessary when the action expert could implicitly learn adaptive step sizes directly from the retimed demonstration targets.