- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose RetinaPlex, which is a biologically (e.g. semi-connectome) constrained model of the primate retina that operates on 4K input. They then show that, concordant with marmoset retinal recordings, that in their model, retained response differences in their model separate current and past signals, and adaptation in the model redistributes past signals across pathways.
Critical strengths
I think more models of primate retina are needed, and so this to me is a considerable strength of the work, as prior high-fidelity retinal models have been in other animal models (e.g. salamander as in Maheswaranathan et al. 2023)
Critical weaknesses
-
It is not clear to me what mechanisms this work better predicts that wasn't already present in existing data (e.g. Kruppel et al. 2023). In other words, it is presently unclear what the benefit you get from using this model that this better enables for science (see my questions below in the next section).
-
It would be important to compare to other retinal models (e.g. Maheswaranathan et al., 2023 and OpenRetina) to see if their model better predicts the phenomena in Figs 3-4, especially in marmoset retinal data that they compare to of Kruppel et al. 2023 in Fig 4c.
Questions for authors
-
Can you clarify how response difference between current and past signals is novel in the retina? After all, we know that there is considerable temporal filtering in the retina, so this seems to already be well-known
-
Likewise, can you clarify how the adaptation in the model isn't already explained by known adaptation mechanisms, like contrast adaptation, luminance and mean adaptation, spatial adaptation, etc.?
-
Similarly, can your model recapitulate other known mechanisms in the retina, as well as predict anything new, like Tanaka et al. NeurIPS 2019 (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35283616/) did with the omitted stimulus response (OSR)?
Authors' Response: Mechanistic Scope, Model Comparisons, and Falsifiable Predictions
Response to Reviewer Mv64:
We greatly value your expertise and high-confidence assessment. Your question—what does this model enable that existing data or models do not?—is exactly the right one.
M1. Is the current/history response difference new? What does the model enable scientifically?
Response. We agree that retina-dependent temporal filtering and history-sensitive RGC responses precede this work. We do not claim to have discovered history dependence itself. The tested question is how a spatially structured population makes present and recent variables simultaneously accessible, and which changes to effective pathway dynamics alter this geometry.
Unlike unconstrained observations, our fork–rejoin design controls the subsequent input, and interventions isolate retention and adaptation. To further demonstrate the scientific benefit, we added Section 4.6, showing that a frozen, two-channel S/T state serves as a computationally viable preprocessing module for a real-video downstream task. This confirms that the S/T organization is not merely a generic filter, but a highly structured, low-bandwidth representation capable of supporting actual decisions.
M2. How does RetinaPlex compare with Maheswaranathan et al. and OpenRetina?
Response. We have now performed a shared-stimulus representation-phenotype comparison. Phenotype groups are determined using independent step responses before the current/preceding decoding task (100–150 ms).
For RetinaPlex, S and T groups achieve 100% current decoding, with 46.48% vs. 94.53% history decoding. Equalizing r changes history accuracies to 82.81% vs. 60.55%. A generic four-state control also shows a related effect, while OpenRetina core and Raw Two-IIR reach 100% on all four components, creating a ceiling effect.
However, reaching 100% does not mean black-box models provide the same insight. While OpenRetina achieves high decoding, our model disentangles the S/T contributions, providing mechanistic insight that black-box models cannot offer. Furthermore, as shown in Sec. 4.6, RetinaPlex compresses 19 frames into just two biologically interpretable maps, matching high-dimensional models. This suggests complex temporal filtering is highly organized and can be efficiently captured at the early bipolar-cell stage. We also analyzed native GC outputs; they are not conflated with hidden C2/core features.
M3. Is the modeled “adaptation” already explained by known mechanisms?
Response. The adaptation state in Eq. (4) is an effective temporal variable. It is not identified with a specific molecular process, presynaptic resource-depletion, or comprehensive luminance adaptation circuit.
Our controlled light-history analysis shows that under a strictly common drive, the measured history-by-suffix-luminance interaction is numerically zero, as expected analytically. For learned representations, a nonzero interaction appears, but a fixed, memoryless softplus also creates nonzero interaction. Thus, that statistic alone cannot identify biological feedback. We restrict our physiological claim to effective dynamics and their population-coding consequences, not a newly established form of retinal adaptation.
M4. Can the model make a genuinely new, independently validated biological prediction, e.g., an OSR?
Response. We agree that predicting an OSR-like phenomenon would constitute stronger cellular validation. We have not tested OSR and do not claim to have predicted it.
Our tests establish a different, falsifiable result: for prespecified manipulations, changing retention and adaptation produces distinct consequences for readout geometry. A neuron-level prospective validation remains a separate target. However, our fork–rejoin framework provides a generative tool to propose such hypotheses in future work. The present paper's claims are strictly about population representation, intervention, and conditional downstream utility.
Summary on Relation to Krüppel et al. (2023): Finally, regarding the distinction between our model and existing empirical data: while Krüppel et al. established the biological phenomenon of heterogeneous history sensitivity, our model provides a causal, generative explanation for how this heterogeneity emerges from specific S/T pathway dynamics.
We emphasize that the anatomical priors act as an inductive bias to reveal computational principles, rather than a recovered biological ground truth. This aligns with the classic computational neuroscience approach: using constrained models to propose testable mechanistic hypotheses (such as the distinct roles of retention and adaptation) that are difficult to isolate purely through experimental observation. We hope this clarifies the complementary relationship between our theoretical platform and empirical recordings.