- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors extend MEI approaches to generate population receptive field (pRF)-constrained images. They analyze two frameworks and compare the effect of natural images bias.
Critical strengths
The authors introduce a framework that enable spatially-constrained MEI synthesis, and compare gradient-based and diffusion-based optimization methods for the same brain regions. Their extension can be relevant especially for early and intermediate retinotopic cortex, in which receptive field is narrowed, and their generated images support this localized optimization. They further provide in-silico validation using an independent test brain encoder and show MEIs consistently elicit higher predicted responses than natural-image controls.
Critical weaknesses
I find the novelty and contribution limited. In terms of algorithmic novelty, both the encoding model and the two optimization approaches are largely adapted from prior work. I therefore evaluate the contribution primarily based on whether applying these components to V1–hV4 yields new neuroscientific insights. While the analysis reveal differences within optimization method, the biological contributions remain relatively limited, and most results characterize the behavior of the proposed pipelines rather than establish new biological insights.
Questions for authors
Can you use your framework to provide additional new neuroscientific insights? Since only in-silico validation was provided, can you propose a way to improve the reliability of the results without requiring closed-loop experiments with human participants?