- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Context-Conditioned Monotonic Response Surface Networks (CMRSN), a neural network architecture that flexibly models multivariate monotonic response surfaces whose shapes vary with unconstrained contextual features while preserving partial monotonicity.
The proposed method combines context-conditioned basis transformations, expert gating, nonnegative score directions, and Bernstein polynomial-based components to guarantee partial monotonicity
Experiments on regression, binary classification, and ordinal classification demonstrate competitive predictive performance without monotonicity violations.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
The partial monotonicity guarantee claimed as a contribution in this paper has already been achieved by numerous prior studies (Almost all monotonic neural networks discussed in the Related Work section). Therefore, it is difficult to regard this property as a major contribution of the paper.
-
Considering (weakness 1), I believe the proposed method should be evaluated through comprehensive experiments that include relevant existing approaches, rather than excluding them from the comparisons. Such experiments are necessary to clearly demonstrate the motivation for and advantages of the proposed method over prior work, particularly in terms of computational efficiency, predictive performance, or other practical benefits. Otherwise, it is difficult to identify a significant novel contribution of this work compared to the numerous existing (partially) monotonic neural network architectures.
-
The experimental evaluation omits several relatively recent studies (e.g., Liu et al., 2020; Sivaraman et al., 2020; Nolte et al., 2023; Kim & Lee, 2024). Given the claimed contributions of this paper, I believe these methods should be included as baselines for comparison.
-
The source code has not been made accessible, making it difficult to verify the reproducibility of the experimental results.
Questions for authors
-
I am not opposed to introducing new approaches to problems that have already been addressed in the literature. However, I believe that a newly proposed method should offer clear and meaningful contributions that distinguish it from existing approaches. In my view, CMRSN employs a relatively complex architecture compared to recently proposed monotonic neural networks (e.g., Runje & Shankaranarayana, 2023; Kim & Lee, 2024). Nevertheless, it remains unclear what unique advantages or novel contributions CMRSN offers over these existing methods. Therefore, I believe the authors should explicitly justify why the additional architectural complexity is necessary and clarify what benefits the proposed method provides that are difficult to achieve with existing approaches.
-
Is there any particular reason why some related works (e.g., Nolte et al., 2023; Kim & Lee, 2024) were excluded from the experimental comparisons? These studies have demonstrated strong predictive performance, and I believe they would serve as relevant baselines for evaluating the proposed method.