- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
L1ResPrune derives an importance score from an analysis of the L1 reconstruction-loss change induced by removing alpha-blended primitives. The score combines an opacity factor alpha/(1 − alpha) with the magnitude of the L1 gradient and aggregates it across pixels and views. Non-gradient and integral approximations reduce computation. Evaluation covers static and dynamic scenes and several primitive types.
Critical strengths
- Broad empirical coverage. The paper evaluates static and dynamic Gaussian representations as well as alternative alpha-blended primitives.
- Useful perceptual improvements. At 90% pruning on Mip-NeRF360, Table 1 improves SSIM/LPIPS over Speedy-Splat from 0.776/0.298 to 0.785/0.281, although PSNR decreases from 26.74 to 26.62. Table 2 also reports improvements over SpeeDe3DGS on NeRF-DS.
- Practical approximations. The NGS and IAS variants offer lower-cost scoring, and the appendix studies aggregation choices and scoring factors.
Critical weaknesses
- The finite-deletion bound needs an additional assumption. Equation 8 ensures nonzero channel residuals at the expansion point, but does not prevent sign changes during complete deletion. Appendix A.7, Equations 19–29, establishes local mixed-derivative identities within a smooth L1 branch; these identities do not establish the general finite-deletion bound in Equation 9. A counterexample is one pixel and one primitive on a black background, with color c = (1, 1, 0), alpha = 0.6, and target y = (0.5, 0.7, 0.01). The mean RGB L1 loss is locally constant at 0.07, with all derivatives zero and all channel residuals nonzero. Deletion raises the loss to 121/300, an increase of 1/3, while Equation 9 has a zero right-hand side. Equation 13 likewise assigns zero importance. This challenges the stated bound, not the empirical usefulness of the score.
- The independent score does not inherit a joint-deletion guarantee. Even within a fixed-sign region, Equation 12 contains interactions among removed primitives. The transition to Equation 13 does not establish that the independent ranking controls their combined removal error. The opacity reweighting can be empirically useful, but the derivation does not justify a general non-heuristic error guarantee.
- Cross-primitive evidence does not directly test the main L1 score. The setup on page 6 specifies the gradient-free NGS variant for alternative primitives. Table 3 therefore supports applicability of the opacity-based simplification rather than generality of the central L1-gradient score. Matched-budget comparisons with other generic pruning criteria would strengthen this claim.
- Evaluation details require reconciliation. Table 5 reports 27.26/0.806/0.246 for Full, n = 2, Visibility, high-ratio pruning, whereas Table 7 reports 27.22/0.801/0.252 for the corresponding setting; the former matches the Max row in Table 7. The appendix also states that test views are sampled from training views. This may be imprecise wording, but camera splits and scoring-view usage should be clarified before concluding that evaluation is independent.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors reconcile Equation 9 with this counterexample? Does the intended claim assume that every channel residual retains its sign throughout deletion? Please state and justify any such restriction, account for sign changes, or explicitly frame the analysis as a local approximation.
- What formal relationship connects Equation 13 to simultaneous deletion error, and which claims should instead be framed as empirical motivation?
- Can the full gradient-based score be evaluated across primitive types? Please reconcile Tables 5 and 7 and specify whether optimization, scoring, and test cameras are disjoint where required.
2 comments
Thank you for taking the time to address my questions. However, I believe that the pruning score used in Mini-Splatting could also be applied to other types of primitives; therefore, its applicability across different representations is not, in itself, sufficient to establish this method's advantage over that baseline. For Triangle Splatting and 3DCS, the improvements offered by L1ResPrune are quite limited—with PSNR gains of only 0.12 dB and 0.10 dB, respectively—and the differences in SSIM/LPIPS are also marginal. While I acknowledge the more significant improvements observed with 2DGS, the current results do not yet provide sufficient evidence to support a clear performance advantage across different representations. I would be interested to hear the authors' perspective on this; for now, I maintain my initial assessment. If the authors have any further points to add, please feel free to provide a brief response before the deadline.
Appreciation for the Thorough Analysis and Constructive Suggestions
W1.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for pointing out this important issue. We have address this concern in our public response (Concern 1) and provided further clarification. We have also revised the manuscript accordingly.
We focused too much on the derivation itself and overlooked a subtle condition for the validity of the Taylor expansion, namely, the smoothness of the function between the expansion point and the evaluation point. As explained in our public response, this issue can be resolved with a minor modification by replacing L with C. The resulting importance scores are nearly identical to the original ones, and the experimental results also remain essentially unchanged.
W2.
We address this concern in our public response (Concern 2).
W3.
In our public response (Concern 3), we have provided additional comparisons using the Full formulation. We have further improved the comparison in the revised manuscript.
W4.
We sincerely apologize for these errors.We conducted extensive experiments with various parameter configurations. However, we inadvertently reported the results for n=1 in the main paper, while those in the appendix correspond to n=2. We have corrected this inconsistency in the revised manuscript.
Regarding the camera views, we sincerely apologize for the misleading wording. What we intended to convey is that regions with denser training-view coverage also tend to have more test views, rather than that test views are sampled from training views. The training and test sets are strictly separated, and test images are never used to compute importance scores or train. We will revise the Appendix to clarify this distinction.
Q1.
The Taylor expansion is based on rigorous mathematical analysis. The subsequent equations are more intuitive, empirically motivated formulations.
Q2.
see W2, and We address this issue in our public response (Concern 2).
Q3.
We address this issue in our public response (Concern 3).