- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces FocusStereo, a stereo depth estimation framework based on point queries. The method employs point queries to guide stereo feature matching, refines local depth through disparity residual prediction and reliability-guided fusion, and further computes 3D spatial relationships in the vicinity of target points. Experiments conducted on the VKITTI2 and HAMMER datasets validate the method's performance in both local depth estimation and 3D localization.
Critical strengths
This paper explores the use of point queries to improve the accuracy of local depth estimation, offering notable practical value. The proposed framework integrates query-conditioned stereo matching with reliability-guided depth refinement, and has demonstrated strong experimental results on the VKITTI2 and HAMMER datasets.
Critical weaknesses
The paper lacks concrete downstream applications to justify the necessity of the Point Query task formulation. Furthermore, the experiments fail to compare the proposed approach against conventional depth refinement methods under identical initialization conditions, making it difficult to fully validate the specific contribution of Query Conditioning. The discrepancies in the results presented in Table 1 and Table 2 are not clearly explained, and the inclusion of certain modules even leads to a decline in depth estimation accuracy.
Questions for authors
-
Research motivation. The authors focus on local depth accuracy rather than global depth estimation. While this idea is intuitively reasonable, the paper does not clearly explain which specific tasks require point queries to obtain more accurate depth. The proposed setting seems mainly motivated by CV benchmarks, without concrete examples of its necessity in real applications. For instance, under what conditions would local navigation require this setting instead of conventional depth estimation or simply using depth cameras or LiDAR? Methods such as FoundationStereo address general-purpose depth estimation and support applications such as 3D reconstruction and data annotation, making their problem setting clear. In contrast, the proposed setting appears more task-specific. For such tasks, would adding depth sensors or LiDAR be a more direct solution? I would like the authors to justify the advantages of Point Query over conventional global depth estimation or refinement from the perspective of the task setting rather than the model design. Additionally, although global depth metrics are reported, the lack of separate evaluation on non-query regions makes it unclear whether improving local accuracy affects depth estimation elsewhere.
-
Experimental settings. In Section 4.4, the authors state: "The ablation results are obtained from a separate controlled run and are therefore used only for within-table comparisons across model variants." Does this mean that Table 1 and Table 2 use different experimental settings? If the same model and test data are used, why are separate runs necessary, and why are the results not directly comparable? For example, the Query-XYZ error of the full model on VKITTI2 is 0.46776 in Table 1 but 0.358675 in Table 2. The authors should clarify the differences between these experiments and explain the discrepancies.
-
Insufficient validation of Query Conditioning. Although the authors conduct ablations with a fixed FoundationStereo initialization and show improvements from additional refinement modules, they do not compare against conventional refinement without Point Query. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the gains come from Query Conditioning or simply from additional stereo matching and refinement. Further experiments are needed to isolate the contribution of Query Conditioning.
-
Lack of comparison with D3RoMa and other depth refinement methods. D3RoMa uses existing depth or disparity estimates to guide depth restoration and could potentially be applied to this setting. For example, would D3RoMa achieve comparable results if initialized with depth predicted by FoundationStereo? The authors should consider this comparison, with appropriate input adaptation and training settings, to better demonstrate the advantages of their method.
-
Insufficient validation of individual modules. On HAMMER, adding RGGF increases Query-XYZ error from 0.015995 to 0.031453, nearly returning to the initialization baseline, while Focus AbsRel worsens from 0.037934 to 0.045398. Although the authors attribute this to an accuracy–reliability trade-off, they do not sufficiently justify the accuracy loss or demonstrate the advantages of RGGF over simpler confidence-based filtering. Moreover, GARD mainly relies on standard 3D back-projection and depth-based geometric relations, while providing only marginal improvements in Topology F1. The authors should further justify the trade-off introduced by RGGF and compare both modules with simpler alternatives to demonstrate their necessity.